Alrighty, I am home now and here are the reads as promised. The plus or minus is how far up or down the chain people moved, the person I most want to lynch is 1. Ergo, pluses are good and mean that person moved away from the lynch end, minuses are bad and mean that person moved close to the lynch end.
Lynch
1. snowy801 (+-0) - Snowy has just been off, he's not contributing, he's posted 32 times but has the lowest words per post ratio of every player. Maybe he's trying to make it past day 3, I don't know, but we all know he is capable of better and it needs to start showing
2. ghug (+-0) - I don't have a good feeling about Ghug, he goes between
This is you tryharding again and I'm
avoiding giving opinions on too many people. Not sure how to make him happy, but the game's not about that. Recapping what I've said about him, I think that he is scum and got me to out by forcing that wagon on me d1 since he saw a difference in my play. I also don't like that he changed his mind on if I should claim my full role.
3. Telamor (-4) - Day 2, Page 35.
I am not shy retiring violet by nature at this point he has made 5 posts, I get he's new but that level of activity seems like the amount a shy retiring violet would do. His timing on his posts seems off and seems to know more than what he lets on sometimes. Pg. 38 and 42. Respectively
I'm not sure I understand your logic here. Surely a night 1 kill would be ideal against a PR(Power Role?) as it'd dispose of you before you had a potential chance to copscan and start leaving clues for town to follow after you're dead.I'm confused. If Ike has claimed a PR but for some reason the Maf didn't either kill or RB him why are we lynching Snowy?
4. Yavuzovic (+-0) - He's still not Yav, I said it before but he doesn't have the conviction I remember him having in games past. I get that he may be busy, but this
Jamie is also on my suspect list. I haven't read him yet but I saw his vote on bozo without explanation.. Why would you ever allow a glance at the forum to affect your reads? Also, most of the meat of his last 10 posts is defending his inactivity. You can do better Yav.
5. thamrick (+2) – I had a hard time moving Thamrick down 2 slots, maybe it’s just because I came in so heavy on him D1. Both of the people he slotted as hard scum (xorxes and myself) are both town, and one of the three he slotted as slight scum (bozo) was also town. He did a vote analysis and asked a few questions but I’m not buying it.
6. DemonRHK (-7) – Probably a little bit of OMGUS, but this dude needs to quit going after me or come after me with a solid case.
If you really are PR throwing a temper tantrum and borderline refusing to play helps no one. Which I’m not doing and haven’t gotten an answer as to where my tantrum was. He aldo said that I asked someone who to vote for when I clearly haven’t. Alright so maybe a lot of OMGUS, but I’m not seeing any effort since he went after me.
7. rdrivera2005 (-11) – He was much higher, but I don’t like the way he played EOD1 his scum reads were
Xorxes, Ike, Reedeer, Peterlund, DrCJG, when I asked him why I was on there he said
Honestly, I want to make it five then he voted me to “make things interesting”. I just don’t see it adding up
8 to 13 is where I slotted lurkers
8. dargorygel (-9) couldn’t decide if I should be slotting Dargy as a lurker or not, but then this stuck out a little to me
After a quick catch up read, Ezio looks a bit better... and my vote isn't doing any real work there. My other possibles are Ike, Snowy, and Bozo. I hate voting and leaving... but i don't want to leave my vote on Ezio.
Ike doesn't need any extra votes to be lynched (looks like that is the likely end at this point... which I don't mind.)
Voting for Snowy, which is my next real choice would also be a waste.
But if I vote for Bozo, it puts him in range in case there is movement later.
Happy with Ike, Bozo, or snowy... but less happy with peter. Bozo and myself are town and I feel like Snowy is scum. Dargy set himself up here if snowy is indeed scum to give himself some town cred without actually doing anything. We’ll see how that plays out
9. reedeer1 (+1) - EOD 1
I guess I have to switch then. @@vote bozo, but we need to talk has posted 2 words since then. BE MORE ACTIVE
10. Stressedlines (+1)
I have. Few theories which seem to.be echoed by 1 other so I'm gonna keep reading and see how long til I start offering my personal thoughts By all means, share. I don’t have enough to go on for all these lurkers.
11. Ezio (+1) Doesn’t feel like Ezio to post this on D1
What're you thinking to gain by voting noLynch? Glad he also feels that Telamor is off though
12. Chaqa (+1) 3 posts on day 2 is not enough, I don’t care who you are.
13. DrCJG (+7) – I’m not 100% sure how I feel about him yet, slotted him as a lurker but in the highest lurker slot. I get a better feeling from him than I do the other newbies besides teacher, we’ll see how I feel when his post count picks up a bit
14. peterlund (+9) - Peter looks like he got a huge boost, but its only because I moved him above the lurkers and others moved down.
I have some news to come with. I have produced a hunch list of my slight scums and they currently are: Xorxes, Ike, Jamie, Ezio again Xor and myself are town. I think the reason I went after him yesterday was more self-preservation than I think he’s scum. He was kind of lurkey but I don’t know his meta. Jury is still out on Peter for me.
15. TrPrado (-1) – Hasn’t been super active yet day 2, but seemed to be asking good questions d1. Scum reads Jamie pretty heavily, if he does manage to get Jamie to flip that would obviously call for my read to change. I would like to see some updated reads.
16. Balki Bartokomous (+4) – I don’t see scum holstering or RB/Killing Xorxes so that Balki can claim. Forced me to give out focused reads d1 with reasons why I scum read who I did. I just get an overall town feeling from Balki
17. Jamiet99uk (+3) – Overall town vibes from Jamie. He is much less emotional this game, not sure if that’s a good or bad thing. I would like to know the rest of the story behind this from page 8 though
I was going to say something about Dargorygel but on second thoughts I'll leave it for later.
18. teacher2 (+3) – doesn’t seem to be holding anything back, is playing and is playing extremely openly and provoking thought. Has two reads lists and is just a general breath of fresh air given the status of the other newbies.
Don't Lynch