M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[foodcoats]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

[worcej]

Just caught up and I agree. I have no idea how anyone scum reads bunny so much that they're ok losing the game here.

@PE, @Worcej: How can you feel at all good about being on the only wagon that could lose us the game? Especially considering that Will just joined it. He's looked scummy for days now and we somehow keep not voting him out. And now he's on the wagon you're stubbornly staging on.

@Food: At the very least, please show up and break this tie. If you don't vote a wagon, you're implicitly relying on Monarch to be telling the truth about ghug being scum, and then you should just be voting for Bunny. If ghug was VT (which I think is true), we lose the game on a tie here.

I disagree that the wagon on Bunny is the only loss here.

The fact that bunny has been angle shooting that has irked me - his whole move right now could be for setting up the final unknown scum PR to influence the end of the game somehow and his play would take us to a real Lylo and after he dies it’s 3-2 and available for scum to walk away with this.

The claim bullshit and all the masking doesn’t make sense for town while Monarch was very straight forward and upfront about it. Also, putting myself in scum!Monarch shoes - it’s dumb to PR claim when she could have just claimed VT to hide and force Bunny to share more and the scum team figure out what information he has.

I think Bunny is actually the scum here.

So you're implying bunny either is a scum role cop or he randomly picked the last hidden town PR to call out?

I think he is trying to get an easy miskill here and picked Monarch, which is an obvious play

[aarodactyl]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

thank goodness

[aarodactyl]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

thank goodness

oh wait. why would you vote bunny? I just saw you showed up and figured you voted monarch

[Ezio]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

thank goodness

Thank goodness? He's voting Bunny. If Bunny flips we lose unless Bunny was lying what?

[Ezio]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

thank goodness

oh wait. why would you vote bunny? I just saw you showed up and figured you voted monarch

He's voting bunny b/c he's scum. Sadge.

[aarodactyl]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

What you need to know is:
-If Bunny is town and we vote him, we lose.
-If Monarch is town and we vote her, we wouldn't lose because it would be mean ghug was a good. This would also hard clear you.

[aarodactyl]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

thank goodness

Thank goodness? He's voting Bunny. If Bunny flips we lose unless Bunny was lying what?

yeah, I didn't read carefully because I was happy we had our final player show up

[foodcoats]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

thank goodness

oh wait. why would you vote bunny? I just saw you showed up and figured you voted monarch

As I said after sweet flipped he was my best guess.

His bit is stupid so it is also a policy kill.

Finally I was also thinking how at this point there have to be scum in the townie players so we should be YOLOing into the “towncore.”

[aarodactyl]

thank goodness

oh wait. why would you vote bunny? I just saw you showed up and figured you voted monarch

He's voting bunny b/c he's scum. Sadge.

The bunny wagon can't be all scum (mathematically). Hopefully the town on it switch in time.

[Ezio]

Welp. We suck.

[worcej]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

What you need to know is:
-If Bunny is town and we vote him, we lose.
-If Monarch is town and we vote her, we wouldn't lose because it would be mean ghug was a good. This would also hard clear you.

Strongly disagree here. Bunny is baiting here with that analysis

[Ezio]

oh wait. why would you vote bunny? I just saw you showed up and figured you voted monarch

He's voting bunny b/c he's scum. Sadge.

The bunny wagon can't be all scum (mathematically). Hopefully the town on it switch in time.

Ya but it ain't food lol.

[foodcoats]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

What you need to know is:
-If Bunny is town and we vote him, we lose.
-If Monarch is town and we vote her, we wouldn't lose because it would be mean ghug was a good. This would also hard clear you.

Huh? We lose here if we miskill no matter what. What am I missing? There are 9 of us and 9-2=7 with 4 scum.

[President Eden]

##VOTE TheMadMonarch

I decided I was going to switch my vote right before Bunny spilled the beans while I was driving around 2 hours ago. I got back to my computer and was surprised that the Bunny wagon was so sticky when the “obvious correct” play was to kill Monarch. It struck me that my remaining on the wagon and making it look viable might have created an opportunity for the mafia to misplay by switching votes at the last second to kill Bunny, so I decided to afk on purpose, post nothing, not appear online, but have this message prepared to flip at the last second and possibly catch them out.

I don’t know if this will play out that way (this message was prepared about an hour prior to EOD), but I don’t see the harm in trying. I’m pretty sure my vote for Monarch will push her through and make sure we don’t outright lose here.

[President Eden]

Oh fuck my life.
Well, note the wagons when I posted early LMAO

[foodcoats]

##VOTE TheMadMonarch

I decided I was going to switch my vote right before Bunny spilled the beans while I was driving around 2 hours ago. I got back to my computer and was surprised that the Bunny wagon was so sticky when the “obvious correct” play was to kill Monarch. It struck me that my remaining on the wagon and making it look viable might have created an opportunity for the mafia to misplay by switching votes at the last second to kill Bunny, so I decided to afk on purpose, post nothing, not appear online, but have this message prepared to flip at the last second and possibly catch them out.

I don’t know if this will play out that way (this message was prepared about an hour prior to EOD), but I don’t see the harm in trying. I’m pretty sure my vote for Monarch will push her through and make sure we don’t outright lose here.

We should flash Eden.

[Bonatogether]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

What you need to know is:
-If Bunny is town and we vote him, we lose.
-If Monarch is town and we vote her, we wouldn't lose because it would be mean ghug was a good. This would also hard clear you.

Huh? We lose here if we miskill no matter what. What am I missing? There are 9 of us and 9-2=7 with 4 scum.

macca!town saw ghug!scum, in which case we have a miskill

[aarodactyl]

##VOTE Bunny

After a quick iso the “guess my role” bit deserves dying for irrespective of alignment.

What you need to know is:
-If Bunny is town and we vote him, we lose.
-If Monarch is town and we vote her, we wouldn't lose because it would be mean ghug was a good. This would also hard clear you.

Huh? We lose here if we miskill no matter what. What am I missing? There are 9 of us and 9-2=7 with 4 scum.

Monarch claimed necro and said ghug was scum. If she's town, it means we're actually at 6-3

[Ezio]

##VOTE TheMadMonarch

I decided I was going to switch my vote right before Bunny spilled the beans while I was driving around 2 hours ago. I got back to my computer and was surprised that the Bunny wagon was so sticky when the “obvious correct” play was to kill Monarch. It struck me that my remaining on the wagon and making it look viable might have created an opportunity for the mafia to misplay by switching votes at the last second to kill Bunny, so I decided to afk on purpose, post nothing, not appear online, but have this message prepared to flip at the last second and possibly catch them out.

I don’t know if this will play out that way (this message was prepared about an hour prior to EOD), but I don’t see the harm in trying. I’m pretty sure my vote for Monarch will push her through and make sure we don’t outright lose here.

oh thank god.

I was doing a similar play pushing Bunny/being as sus as I was. I really hoped mafia hopped onboard for the win.