Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Foxcastle]

Did

we

[Foxcastle]

Did

we

win

[Foxcastle]

Did

we

win

longest

[Foxcastle]

we

win

longest

game

[Foxcastle]

win

longest

game

yet?

[Foxcastle]

DAY 6

ND (4) — Foxcastle, et, Durga, connorcompton
Foxcastle (3) — ND, FlaviusAetius, Squigs44
et (1) — Percy Williams

Here's a thing to consider. And I think it's a big thing.

On N5, the scumteam roleblock ND and there's not assassin kill. So they must have known that ND was the BA. (Maybe the BA held the kill, but they had strong evidence that ND was the BA, at least.)

So on D6, the remaining two scum really need to kill the BA. Et is looking really good, so as long as they kill the BA, they have a good shot at the win.

Connor has been scumreading me pretty consistently from at least Day 4, so he votes me. He's been pretty iffy on ND, but has mostly been commenting that he thinks ND could be the BA (this is especially prominent during N5 when the Mafia QT would have been discussing who could be the BA and they end up roleblocking ND), but is otherwise pretty null on him.

And then, at the end, he switches his vote to ND. WHY?

Because he's scum and he knew ND was the BA, and he needed to kill the BA.

(You can see all his posts here. Just search for me and ND and you can see the progress. A tip: when you search for ND, put a space before it so it only picks up the name and not every instance of "and".)

Reconsidering this. They were partly counting on et making it through unscathed, so things only got fucked for them when ND exposed et...

It was 5-2-1 and they knew they could RB the SK.
So a mislynch plus a NK would have been 3-2-1.
At which point they just needed a mislynch to make it 2-2-1 and a NK to control the game...

They did not know this when Night 5 ended, so they couldn't coordinate based on it... I guess the question is: would Flavius have done that calculation?

[Foxcastle]

Connor, Yav, I need to you to both give a deep analysis of the whole Damo/Connor roleblock thing.

Because that's pretty ridiculous for scum to try to pull off.

[Foxcastle]

Connor, Yav, I need to you to both give a deep analysis of the whole Damo/Connor roleblock thing.

Because that's pretty ridiculous for scum to try to pull off.

Sorry, I know Yav is incorrect. I should have said Yavuz.

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 9.0

(0)

Currently NOBODY is set to be lynched.

1 day, 5 hours, 23 minutes remain.

[Foxcastle]

... Anybody? Anybody?

I don't understand why either scum or town would ignore the game at this point.

[yavuzovic]

Firstly, thank you Foxcastle for making really long reads and pointing some suspicious points in early days - I doubt scum you would bother that much. But a slight sensation of you to be sided when you made the comments never left me.

About Percy to die instead of me, I think this happened because I was either on the wrong track - I was scumreading Fox and connor wanted me to lynch him. OR scum wanted me to think I was on the wrong track when I actually wasn't. To be honest I don't think scum would leave the player nearest to townclear (that's what I consider myself) for second purpose. That is gambling - I mightnever notice the second option. I feel like an anti-connor situation here.

I really will try and look into both of you here but I can tell that today for me will probably end up in me just trying to convince Yav I'm not scum and it's Fox instead.

This seems genuine though. Or scum finding Fox easier to lynch over me - considering how suspicious Fox is, this actually possible too. I don't know.

For now, I'm really unsure and confused. Either one of you is scum and ... town one is as scummy as scum one *pathetic laugh*

[Foxcastle]

Are you going to go back and try to do any reads or analysis, Yav?

[Foxcastle]

Are you going to go back and try to do any reads or analysis, Yavuz?

DAMMIT. I don't know why I keep shortening your name. >_<

[yavuzovic]

You are the best person of the site because although I warned everyone before you are the only one caring this, I can vote connor just for this thank you Foxcastle.

I will, I will eat and do some of my works, I think I will be able to do this in 1-2 hours.

[yavuzovic]

Okay I'm starting, thanking Peter making games easier.
Instead of seeing scum relations, I'm planning to look at your interactions with other players, both mafia and town. Later can take a look at vote counts maybe.

[yavuzovic]

Actually we can say I will make ISO for all turns. I'm not going to include others mentioning you.

[Foxcastle]

Okay I'm starting, thanking Peter making games easier.
Instead of seeing scum relations, I'm planning to look at your interactions with other players, both mafia and town. Later can take a look at vote counts maybe.

Are you going to do Connor as well, or have you just decided to find whatever justification is necessary to vote me?

[connorcompton]

DAY 6

ND (4) — Foxcastle, et, Durga, connorcompton
Foxcastle (3) — ND, FlaviusAetius, Squigs44
et (1) — Percy Williams

Here's a thing to consider. And I think it's a big thing.

On N5, the scumteam roleblock ND and there's not assassin kill. So they must have known that ND was the BA. (Maybe the BA held the kill, but they had strong evidence that ND was the BA, at least.)

So on D6, the remaining two scum really need to kill the BA. Et is looking really good, so as long as they kill the BA, they have a good shot at the win.

Connor has been scumreading me pretty consistently from at least Day 4, so he votes me. He's been pretty iffy on ND, but has mostly been commenting that he thinks ND could be the BA (this is especially prominent during N5 when the Mafia QT would have been discussing who could be the BA and they end up roleblocking ND), but is otherwise pretty null on him.

And then, at the end, he switches his vote to ND. WHY?

Because he's scum and he knew ND was the BA, and he needed to kill the BA.

(You can see all his posts here. Just search for me and ND and you can see the progress. A tip: when you search for ND, put a space before it so it only picks up the name and not every instance of "and".)

I'm here now. I've read and will do my best at an analysis of both of you.
With this, it's a good point but I don't think you should take someone's ability at documenting their 'progress' (especially when that person clearly hasn't put much detail into their thoughts) as an important factor.

As another point, if you're scum, well done, well done on really making me think and worry.
If you're town, well done and thank you for the effort you've put into this game.

[connorcompton]

Connor, Yav, I need to you to both give a deep analysis of the whole Damo/Connor roleblock thing.

Because that's pretty ridiculous for scum to try to pull off.

I really don't see what analysis I could give. I don't know why damo decided to do that, we know his claim was false, I can eliminate the possibility of me being scum, all I have for the motive is that they thought they could get away with it because of my general absence from the game.

[Foxcastle]

You are both so wishy-washy and indecisive, I am not sure this game is worth playing out to the end.

I quit.

##VOTE FOXCASTLE END