MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[damo666]

why do we even care abt the third party thing?? isn't just saying "I am town" objectively better from town pov (assuming we have a town lie detector who isn't tampered with, it'll give us more information, with either a town clear or a confirmed non-town (town enemy) person)?

It's a request for an additional statement. Ask yourself who wouldn't want to say it.

I am not third party

Still think just saying town is stronger, but sure.

Yes I agree the former statement is stronger but saying both has benefits.

[brainbomb]

##Vote ND
##End

[brainbomb]

We really can make webdip great again!

[Vecna]

##vote ND

fuck it, upside to sanity, and makes it harder for that 3p role to achieve its win condition

[miminena]

i was looking back through the roles and misread "weak doctor" as "witch doctor", now i have that song stuck in my head

[miminena]

why is ND self voting
##VOTE red neurax
for lurking

even if red turns out to be mafia, doesn't the fact that they're lurking give us little to work off for day 2?

You're probably wondering who I am
Good luck, to you, with such an endeavor
My tracks were covered in a manner adequate
And I am not yet ready to reveal myself

not even rhyming :/

##vote ND

fuck it, upside to sanity, and makes it harder for that 3p role to achieve its win condition

How would voting ND make it harder for 3p?

[Jamiet99uk]

GM NOTE

I have been asked via PM whether the Mafia know the exact roles drawn by their partners (for example do the other two Mafia know if Stearne is Strongman / Executioner, etc..) or only their partners' general identity.

For transparency, the answer is the latter (until they can talk in their Discord N1).

[kingofthepirates]

why is ND self voting
##VOTE red neurax
for lurking

even if red turns out to be mafia, doesn't the fact that they're lurking give us little to work off for day 2?

It could, but there will be the NK and investigative roles to work with.

I’m keeping my vote steady (it was originally a pressure vote); red’s ND vote sealed it for me. Felt halfhearted and far from genuine. Their overall play has also been pretty lukewarm imo

[miminena]

why is ND self voting
##VOTE red neurax
for lurking

even if red turns out to be mafia, doesn't the fact that they're lurking give us little to work off for day 2?

It could, but there will be the NK and investigative roles to work with.

I’m keeping my vote steady (it was originally a pressure vote); red’s ND vote sealed it for me. Felt halfhearted and far from genuine. Their overall play has also been pretty lukewarm imo

oh, that makes sense. I also want to hear more from them atm. it also feels like they're trying to hit participation limit and then they won't interact for the rest of the day

@RedNeurax do you have any opinions on anybody other than ND?

[damo666]

##vote ND

fuck it, upside to sanity, and makes it harder for that 3p role to achieve its win condition

How would voting ND make it harder for 3p?

ND is a likely early kill and would be a relatively easy guess for Warlock but a D1 kill takes him out of the equation.

[DemonRHK]

Alright, it took like 30 seconds to reread ND.

I feel like the votes are very much personally motivated as there substance to base it off is really thin. I'm sure there is an allegory to be made there both ways, but it is very much neither the time nor the place.

I haven't caught up on anyone else yet, so let's park somewhere spicy at least for now.

##Vote Vecna

[kingofthepirates]

ND is a likely early kill and would be a relatively easy guess for Warlock but a D1 kill takes him out of the equation.

Warlock needs 3 guesses though. Not saying this isn’t a good/interesting idea, but we do have a bit of wiggle room. Plus with how it’s looking now, several players might be other easy targets (red, ghug(?), etc.)

[damo666]

ND is a likely early kill and would be a relatively easy guess for Warlock but a D1 kill takes him out of the equation.

Warlock needs 3 guesses though. Not saying this isn’t a good/interesting idea, but we do have a bit of wiggle room. Plus with how it’s looking now, several players might be other easy targets (red, ghug(?), etc.)

I don't disagree. I was simply trying to explain what Vecna was getting at for mimi (she wouldn't know the meta).

[foodcoats]

is the bot offline?

has been for me the whole time

You need to manually preface it with https://

HTTP won't work.

[brainbomb]

Every setup needs live guns day 1. This could be so much easier

##end

I'm OK trading a possible early numbers disadvantage for clearheadedness, and he could be scum too.

Did you ever feel this same way about the way worcej was playing earlier?

[damo666]

Voting ND day 1 is a lazy copout.

[damo666]

You're probably wondering who I am
Good luck, to you, with such an endeavor
My tracks were covered in a manner adequate
And I am not yet ready to reveal myself

…

##unend

Did you crack Dip's code?

[ND]

This devolve into performative-

Wait he was performing all along anyway thats it. But it was always just terrible and hes done that as mafia before.

The self voting
The total lack of interest in engaging with anyone

Dude what did we do to you that has turned you into this homonculus of absurdity

Quack

#Make Webbbbbbb Dip GREAT again

[brainbomb]

Aflac

[ND]

I also cannot shake the feeling that ND is actually being nicer than he would normally be, and less abbrasive and obnoxious than i would expect him to be given current events.

It almost feels weird to say this, but in the ND frame of things he feels like he's trying to stay well under the radar.

Agreed

Interesting. Saving this for later.

#Make WEB dip mafia great again