MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[y2kjbk]

it's not his last suggestion, but he posited it on pages 246 and 247 and I want to challenge him if he disagrees with my scum-reads

[Durga]

agh my head hurts. it would be so shit for mafia to have both armours I want to maybe say yav-ND but yav-Vecna also makes a little sense...

[Durga]

If its worcej we're a little fucked

[y2kjbk]

flash, if i'm wrong and yav is town, i take all the blame. unless you have a very convincing case for yav being scum besides the armor situation, please consider the argument for vecna/durga. and concerning the situation of the armor, squigs lying about having MF's hammer instead of his actual armor is what put us all off.

[Vecna]

Also, when he got called out by rdrivera, yavuz was screaming for the repair kit to come and clear him.

The last guy on scum likely has the repair kit. Go and check Yavuz iso.

Meaning Worcej Or Y2k for 2nd scum

So you are saying either Worcej or Y2K lied somehow about their nurse kits. How?
I don't understand why you would not follow the logic of your earlier theory...which points at ND via PoE.

im not saying i know whats what, i just have suspicions.

yav + nd
yav + worc
yav + y2k
y2k + nd

all are possible imo.

the repair kit couldve been used to determine what has died, but it wouldve been a major gamble.

it might just as well be yav/nd with the items thry claimed. heck it could even be flash.

[y2kjbk]

agh my head hurts. it would be so shit for mafia to have both armours I want to maybe say yav-ND but yav-Vecna also makes a little sense...

does your head hurt from how open your logical lynch options are?

[y2kjbk]

flash, if i'm wrong and yav is town, i take all the blame. unless you have a very convincing case for yav being scum besides the armor situation, please consider the argument for vecna/durga. and concerning the situation of the armor, squigs lying about having MF's hammer instead of his actual armor is what put us all off.

ugh, if i'm wrong and yav is "scum"

[flash2015]

flash, if i'm wrong and yav is town, i take all the blame. unless you have a very convincing case for yav being scum besides the armor situation, please consider the argument for vecna/durga. and concerning the situation of the armor, squigs lying about having MF's hammer instead of his actual armor is what put us all off.

If we have narrowed it down to Durga/Vecna vs Yav/ND and there is no second head in play, then we should win since if we choose wrong tonight, we just choose the other theory the following night.

However if we choose wrong tonight and the head still is in play, we lose. The question then becomes, if the head is in play who has it? Durga can't have it because she had the gun. Vecna can't have it because if he was scum he had to lose the armour to rdr.

So the only people who can potentially have it are yav or ND. So I would argue, even if you are not convinced by the yav/ND argument, testing yav/ND tonight will ensure town win.

[y2kjbk]

flash, if i'm wrong and yav is town, i take all the blame. unless you have a very convincing case for yav being scum besides the armor situation, please consider the argument for vecna/durga. and concerning the situation of the armor, squigs lying about having MF's hammer instead of his actual armor is what put us all off.

If we have narrowed it down to Durga/Vecna vs Yav/ND and there is no second head in play, then we should win since if we choose wrong tonight, we just choose the other theory the following night.

However if we choose wrong tonight and the head still is in play, we lose. The question then becomes, if the head is in play who has it? Durga can't have it because she had the gun. Vecna can't have it because if he was scum he had to lose the armour to rdr.

So the only people who can potentially have it are yav or ND. So I would argue, even if you are not convinced by the yav/ND argument, testing yav/ND tonight will ensure town win.

Chaqa took the head to the grave

[Durga]

Also, when he got called out by rdrivera, yavuz was screaming for the repair kit to come and clear him.

The last guy on scum likely has the repair kit. Go and check Yavuz iso.

Meaning Worcej Or Y2k for 2nd scum

So you are saying either Worcej or Y2K lied somehow about their nurse kits. How?
I don't understand why you would not follow the logic of your earlier theory...which points at ND via PoE.

im not saying i know whats what, i just have suspicions.

yav + nd
yav + worc
yav + y2k
y2k + nd

all are possible imo.

the repair kit couldve been used to determine what has died, but it wouldve been a major gamble.

it might just as well be yav/nd with the items thry claimed. heck it could even be flash.

I can't really understand why you've totally cleared me. Can you explain that

[y2kjbk]

But I see your reasoning, I'm just afraid someone like Demon will screw that up.

[flash2015]

flash, if i'm wrong and yav is town, i take all the blame. unless you have a very convincing case for yav being scum besides the armor situation, please consider the argument for vecna/durga. and concerning the situation of the armor, squigs lying about having MF's hammer instead of his actual armor is what put us all off.

If we have narrowed it down to Durga/Vecna vs Yav/ND and there is no second head in play, then we should win since if we choose wrong tonight, we just choose the other theory the following night.

However if we choose wrong tonight and the head still is in play, we lose. The question then becomes, if the head is in play who has it? Durga can't have it because she had the gun. Vecna can't have it because if he was scum he had to lose the armour to rdr.

So the only people who can potentially have it are yav or ND. So I would argue, even if you are not convinced by the yav/ND argument, testing yav/ND tonight will ensure town win.

Chaqa took the head to the grave

How can you be so sure?

[y2kjbk]

His first post was a clear attempt to make it seem like he made no night action, and votes ghug.

[flash2015]

But I see your reasoning, I'm just afraid someone like Demon will screw that up.

Again, this is why we need to lynch Yav tonight. It also proves that Demon actually used the heart.

[y2kjbk]

and him having the head at the start of D1 would be an explanation for him seeming to just not care about the day.

[y2kjbk]

##VOTE yavuzovic then

the game lies on ND/worcej/flash lynching Durga/Vecna. and Demon is dead so yeah this is OK. sorry yav, i'll be joining you soon.

[Vecna]

So you are saying either Worcej or Y2K lied somehow about their nurse kits. How?
I don't understand why you would not follow the logic of your earlier theory...which points at ND via PoE.

im not saying i know whats what, i just have suspicions.

yav + nd
yav + worc
yav + y2k
y2k + nd

all are possible imo.

the repair kit couldve been used to determine what has died, but it wouldve been a major gamble.

it might just as well be yav/nd with the items thry claimed. heck it could even be flash.

I can't really understand why you've totally cleared me. Can you explain that

I havent totally cleared you, ive just accepted that if youre scum you have succesfully pocketed me - and im following my reads, always.

[Durga]

##VOTE yavuzovic then

the game lies on ND/worcej/flash lynching Durga/Vecna. and Demon is dead so yeah this is OK. sorry yav, i'll be joining you soon.

If you really believe the scum team is me and Vecna why tf you voting yav

[Vecna]

##VOTE yavuzovic then

the game lies on ND/worcej/flash lynching Durga/Vecna. and Demon is dead so yeah this is OK. sorry yav, i'll be joining you soon.

Why do you keep talking like you know yav will flip town?

[Durga]

im not saying i know whats what, i just have suspicions.

yav + nd
yav + worc
yav + y2k
y2k + nd

all are possible imo.

the repair kit couldve been used to determine what has died, but it wouldve been a major gamble.

it might just as well be yav/nd with the items thry claimed. heck it could even be flash.

I can't really understand why you've totally cleared me. Can you explain that

I havent totally cleared you, ive just accepted that if youre scum you have succesfully pocketed me - and im following my reads, always.

Sometimes I feel like you've pocketed me...