M1011 - Revenge of the Space Mutants - Game Thread

[Tom Bombadil]

I disagree with worcej. I would always tie to save myself as town.

I think Neph coming in ten mintues before deadline and then not voting one of the wagons is less than pathetic.

So you'd rather I vote based on no reading?

Just curious

Correct. Unless you know that one of them is town, I an uneducated guess is better than a tie.

[summit_fever]

##vote nephthys

9 minutes to go and he's cracking about forgetting the game and takes off.

I mean I had teaching but sure

It came down to the wire and those horses were neck and neck. If you have more important engagements I'm not one to question that but a word of warning would be nice.

[Nephthys]

rdrivera's flash onto damo and then flipping town is not interesting in the least?

worcej claiming vig with a shot on emc isn't more interesting than me voting damo after rdrivera?

how about neph claiming he'd like to lynch damo or xorxes and failing to do either?

Are you a primitive ancestor of a giraffe? Cause you don't seem to be able to reach past the low hanging fruit.

Would be a shame if there was a sudden increase in vegetative competition that selected for height...

[foodcoats]

Well, sorry for not being on at deadline. I'll try moving forward, but its tough for me with work - its why I don't play as much anymore, and why I can't GM anymore

Needless to say, a no-lynch D1 is a complete debacle as town, so lets not dwell on that and actually lynch someone today.

The rdr flip is interesting considering I don't think he was widely townread. Lets try to figure out why he was targeted.

From my perspective it suggests you or bozo are scum (and from each of yours probably the other two) although kgray has often been killed early as well (if I'm not getting things mixed up). I was obviously not going to be killed after D1 though. Scum may want to keep bozo to keep pestering me, so you are probably the most suspect by this kill choice, but it can also be scum wanting us to think that.

You don't think it's just because scum didn't want to target someone who might be commuted?

[summit_fever]

worcej claiming vig with a shot on emc isn't more interesting than me voting damo after rdrivera?

how about neph claiming he'd like to lynch damo or xorxes and failing to do either?

Are you a primitive ancestor of a giraffe? Cause you don't seem to be able to reach past the low hanging fruit.

Would be a shame if there was a sudden increase in vegetative competition that selected for height...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjoYl5aTWdw

[bozotheclown]

@bozo, what was/is your read of damo? It is clear that you preferred to lynch me over him, but given the risk of a tie, were you strongly opposed to a damo lynch, or were you just ok with the risk of a tie given there was still a chance of lynching me?

I did not have a significant read of damo and I was OK risking a tie. However, at EOD, damo did not appear to be online and had not posted for over half and hour, so it seemed to me damo was about to get lynched.

Do you have a read of him now, after what happened?

Well just know if I am ever being lynched and I am town, I'll let the flip go so you at least learn something from it.

Eh, I agree with Tom here somewhat. It's perfectly reasonable to vote for your counterwagon to save yourself if you're town.

@worc - I think revealing who you (attempted to?) shot at some point is good for town

I agree it is the correct play as town to tie the vote instead of letting yourself get lynched. However, waiting until less than minute left in the day while not giving any indication you are online is suspicious.

Nephthys:

Yea so I'm happy to ruthlessly butcher damo/xorx

Maybe Chaqa for lols

He had a choice on which one to ruthlessly butcher and didn't take it.

That is a good point, maybe xorxes, damo, and Nephthys as scum? Nephthys comes back to pretend he forgot about the game and would not catch up before EOD?

[Nephthys]

I disagree with worcej. I would always tie to save myself as town.

I think Neph coming in ten mintues before deadline and then not voting one of the wagons is less than pathetic.

So you'd rather I vote based on no reading?

Just curious

Correct. Unless you know that one of them is town, I an uneducated guess is better than a tie.

##vote nephthys

9 minutes to go and he's cracking about forgetting the game and takes off.

I mean I had teaching but sure

It came down to the wire and those horses were neck and neck. If you have more important engagements I'm not one to question that but a word of warning would be nice.

By the logic in these two posts everyone who didn't change their vote should get the same level of scrutiny

[Nephthys]

Scumreads
- Tom - Doesn't seem invested particularly, piggy-backing of other peoples pushes and generally just weak feeling
- Summit - Flippant entrance, seems waay to angry at me than I would consider reasonable, instant tunnel

Then probably one of Xorx/Damo (VCA indicates xorx)

Still uncomfortable about food

Town
- Chaqa
- bozo
- Kgray

[Nephthys]

##vote tom

[summit_fever]

Scumreads
- Tom - Doesn't seem invested particularly, piggy-backing of other peoples pushes and generally just weak feeling
- Summit - Flippant entrance, seems waay to angry at me than I would consider reasonable, instant tunnel

Then probably one of Xorx/Damo (VCA indicates xorx)

Still uncomfortable about food

Town
- Chaqa
- bozo
- Kgray

angry? come now. I look like chaqa or something?

[Tom Bombadil]

Not really - damo tied the vote with a minute left. Not a lot of time when it was actually tied.

You were the only one who we learn nothing about if either of those people flip.

But yes, other people including myself should have made it so a tie was not possible

[Tom Bombadil]

lol. I know you took the first 48 hrs off Neph, but you aren't reading if you think I'm piggy backing off of other peoples thoughts.

[Tom Bombadil]

Also, its weird that you don't mention that you scumread me, and I spend much of the day voting for summit.

[Tom Bombadil]

"piggy-backing of other peoples pushes"

Like this read is so fake. I voted for damo and summit and literally started both wagons. And defended xorxes. Where did I piggy back off anything?

[xorxes]

Well, sorry for not being on at deadline. I'll try moving forward, but its tough for me with work - its why I don't play as much anymore, and why I can't GM anymore

Needless to say, a no-lynch D1 is a complete debacle as town, so lets not dwell on that and actually lynch someone today.

The rdr flip is interesting considering I don't think he was widely townread. Lets try to figure out why he was targeted.

From my perspective it suggests you or bozo are scum (and from each of yours probably the other two) although kgray has often been killed early as well (if I'm not getting things mixed up). I was obviously not going to be killed after D1 though. Scum may want to keep bozo to keep pestering me, so you are probably the most suspect by this kill choice, but it can also be scum wanting us to think that.

You don't think it's just because scum didn't want to target someone who might be commuted?

That's also a possibility, yes.

[Nephthys]

@Tom

you seem hella defensive for a read that no ones ever gonna back up...

[Tom Bombadil]

Yeah - I'm defensive because you are voting me for some reason you just made up after coasting for 48 hours.

[foodcoats]

I think for sake of knowledge we have a imperative to resolve one of the Day 1 wagons in one way or another.

That is actually a very good point.

##VOTE xorxes

[Nephthys]

Yeah - I'm defensive because you are voting me for some reason you just made up after coasting for 48 hours.

cool beans

[Nephthys]

In other sad news

I was playing a mafia-like game with my friends the other day, nailed a slip and they all got annoyed that Itried to push it hard.

That person ended up winning the game for scum.

Painful