M54: Not a Carrot Conspiracy

[Foxcastle]

In general, nicknames do not support solving. Because when I refer to you as "Jean" from here on out, a bunch of people won't know what I'm talking about and most of them won't care to get a clarification. And when you flip scum and people are searching through everybody's posts looking for connections, they're going to say "Foxcastle only ever mentioned kgray twice" when in fact I referred to you as "Jean" 40 times. So it's bad practice because it makes it harder to solve and creates confusion.

lol weren't you the person who complained about people answering other people's questions?

Notice how I waited for Jamiet to answer the question before I added my own answer?

Do try to keep up, Jean.

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Jamiet is likely town, FYI.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Jamiet is likely town, FYI.

Yes, I am town and you are not.

Keep away from my stockpile of toilet rolls and canned foods.

[Foxcastle]

@Jamiet is likely town, FYI.

Yes, I am town and you are not.

Keep away from my stockpile of toilet rolls and canned foods.

Jamiet is flipping his lid a little earlier and a little more dramatically than usual, but I'm finding it somewhat convincing.

[Fluminator]

Jamiet's meta was
Is he likable and agreeable? Scum
Is he being super abrasive? Town

And it was incredibly accurate. Is that still the meta for him?

[Fluminator]

Don't scare away new players with that foxy sass lol

[brainbomb]

For the duration of the game, as per the new protocols of social distancing.

I will only post henceforth when mentioned by name and asked a question.

[brainbomb]

I suggest all players cease posting as you may accidentally be answering a questiom for someone else.

if a question is asked, at all, to anyone, you must stay silent until the question is answered under these new guidelines

[Fluminator]

ya rite

[Fluminator]

oh ok good nm

[Jamiet99uk]

For the duration of the game, as per the new protocols of social distancing.

I will only post henceforth when mentioned by name and asked a question.

Please do this. PLEASE.

Nobody else, just you.

[BunnyGo]

I see you lurking sulit...

uwu

What? Is this some Minecraft code?

In other news: Balki and Jaime are amusing me. Probably same team, leaning Town on both.

[Fluminator]

I actually recently learned what uwu meant.
It's pronounced oowoo and it's supposed to be a baby face.

[Fluminator]

SHIT
I just answered a question for someon else

I must go silent as penance now

[kgray]

lol weren't you the person who complained about people answering other people's questions?

Notice how I waited for Jamiet to answer the question before I added my own answer?

Do try to keep up, Jean.

Okay this is frustrating to me. Because nicknames are either unhelpful and mafia-indicative or whimsical and fun. If you're town, you can't have it both ways. If you're agreeing with jamiet that Balki doing it is unhelpful and suspicious, then you doing it would be equally unhelpful and suspicious.

@jamie, do you think Foxcastle is also mafia?

[BunnyGo]

Isn't this your fifth game or something? You're not new anymore!

Fair enough. Newer? The rest of my questions stand.

I would think that you were doing this to milk some sympathy and boost your chances to win as scum, except you also did it last game.

I’m working on getting better.

[Jamiet99uk]

Notice how I waited for Jamiet to answer the question before I added my own answer?

Do try to keep up, Jean.

Okay this is frustrating to me. Because nicknames are either unhelpful and mafia-indicative or whimsical and fun. If you're town, you can't have it both ways. If you're agreeing with jamiet that Balki doing it is unhelpful and suspicious, then you doing it would be equally unhelpful and suspicious.

@jamie, do you think Foxcastle is also mafia?

I do not currently scumread Foxcastle, no.

And before you ask "but why Balki then?", you should note that my suspicion of Balki has to do with much more than the use of nicknames, as I have made clear. (And if it is not clear to you, I refer you to my iso via the bot).

[kgray]

Do try to keep up, Jean.

Okay this is frustrating to me. Because nicknames are either unhelpful and mafia-indicative or whimsical and fun. If you're town, you can't have it both ways. If you're agreeing with jamiet that Balki doing it is unhelpful and suspicious, then you doing it would be equally unhelpful and suspicious.

@jamie, do you think Foxcastle is also mafia?

I do not currently scumread Foxcastle, no.

And before you ask "but why Balki then?", you should note that my suspicion of Balki has to do with much more than the use of nicknames, as I have made clear. (And if it is not clear to you, I refer you to my iso via the bot).

Okay thanks. And yeah, I get that there's more to your Balki suspicions than that. I just find the hypocrisy suspect, although I guess it could just be trolling.

[Foxcastle]

Okay this is frustrating to me. Because nicknames are either unhelpful and mafia-indicative or whimsical and fun. If you're town, you can't have it both ways. If you're agreeing with jamiet that Balki doing it is unhelpful and suspicious, then you doing it would be equally unhelpful and suspicious.

@jamie, do you think Foxcastle is also mafia?

I do not currently scumread Foxcastle, no.

And before you ask "but why Balki then?", you should note that my suspicion of Balki has to do with much more than the use of nicknames, as I have made clear. (And if it is not clear to you, I refer you to my iso via the bot).

Okay thanks. And yeah, I get that there's more to your Balki suspicions than that. I just find the hypocrisy suspect, although I guess it could just be trolling.

It's just trolling. My theory of scum is that they try very hard to not be caught out in any inconsistency or hypocrisy.

[BunnyGo]

@Jamiet99uk, can you explain to me why you have a problem with Balki using nicknames for BunnyGo?

Because it's misleading,
it's unclear,
it's unhelpful,
it's silly.

There was this whole shebang in the last game about people referring to each other by their nicknames from college and it annoyed the fuck out of me, and here's Stephen doing it again.

So how is you referring to Jeff, Torqvald, Mr. Smith, Wilberforce, Sebastian, Zultar, Randy, Saspirella and Princess Prissypants any less misleading, unclear, unhelpful or silly?

If it bothers you so much, why continue to do that exact thing?

Hmm. Kgray just lost a clever point I’d mentally awarded her.