M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

I sleep now.

[ghug]

This has to be one of the worst scum performances in a long time.

The extreme reticence to vote Goldie makes me pretty convinced he's the GF, so this should be a hilariously short game.

The fact that it's this bad should lead you to the opposite conclusion, HR. My scum performances have usually been pretty good. The fact that I was counter-wagon to Vecna and Vecna voted me (there's only one scum other than GF alive) should pretty much clear me. Cop, scan me tonight to prove I'm not the goon. There's no reason the roleblocker would try to push the vote on the GF.

That all being said, good job to everyone except me. I'm easily LVT - least valuable townie here. Frankly surprised Durga would go that far protecting Fox off the bat, tbh.

Lol

[Hellenic Riot]

This has to be one of the worst scum performances in a long time.

The extreme reticence to vote Goldie makes me pretty convinced he's the GF, so this should be a hilariously short game.

The fact that it's this bad should lead you to the opposite conclusion, HR. My scum performances have usually been pretty good. The fact that I was counter-wagon to Vecna and Vecna voted me (there's only one scum other than GF alive) should pretty much clear me. Cop, scan me tonight to prove I'm not the goon. There's no reason the roleblocker would try to push the vote on the GF.

That all being said, good job to everyone except me. I'm easily LVT - least valuable townie here. Frankly surprised Durga would go that far protecting Fox off the bat, tbh.

Last time we were scum together, there was an optional group chat with a third party that we all told you not to post in at any point. You made one post, and BunnyGo (the 3P) immediately identified you

Vecna's vote on you was with such hilarious reluctance that it really counts for jack all. At that point it was pretty much a surrender. He tried to make it him vs me, failed, and then didn't know how to react when I kept pushing for you instead of switching to him.

[Chaqa]

Oh awesome

Glad I picked right

[Chaqa]

TFB godfather?

[Hellenic Riot]

TFB godfather?

No, we have the Goldfather right here, asking to be scanned to protect his last teammate.


TFB turning up yet again only when mentioned was peak memes though. I'm glad Bob sees what I do.

[Hellenic Riot]

I'll make you into a junior version of me yet, Bob

[kgray]

Run away, Bob!

[BobMcBob]

@Bob: Who do you think the last 3 scum are?

You, chaqa and goldie

[BobMcBob]

Run away, Bob!

Oh shoot, better be off!

[Chaqa]

Getting rid of the Roleblocker just as the Cop gets outed.

Bittersweet.

Let's hope Maniac is just scum doing a fake claim.

I don't see why he needed to claim when he had only two votes.

[TheFlyingBoat]

TFB godfather?

No, we have the Goldfather right here, asking to be scanned to protect his last teammate.


TFB turning up yet again only when mentioned was peak memes though. I'm glad Bob sees what I do.

You keep saying that, but it's just not true lmao. I show up at random hours all the time. I feel like 12am-2am was among the most common time for me to post and those were routinely without being mentioned.You've just turned it into a meme so "Where in the World is ~~Carmen SanDiego~~ TheFlyingBoat" posts just get made constantly which is especially dumb given that I am an average poster by count, which is exactly where I normally hover in all my town games and the D1 activity was very much an outlier from the norm.

There's also not been much that has given me the need to update my reads so I haven't felt the need to post as I feel posting for the sake of posting is anti-town. Scum has been very scummy and remained so. I think the only read that changed since just before the end of Day 2 to now was Damo getting subbed out for you because of what happened during Day 3. I am willing to consider that Vecna was the only person being protected and go for rdr first tomorrow, though.

Speaking of which, I'll also use this time to toot my own horn and brag a bit though because I am really sick and tired of this stupid posting from an otherwise very smart person.

From D2:

i stopped reading at alphabetically, wtf

I have an alphabetical notes list that I was reading down, hence why it is in alpha order. I figured I would make it clear what the order was before Bona mocks my ordered/unordered question, which I thought was a perfectly fine question to ask and lead to me probing ghug more later.

If you want it ordered most scum to least I'd go:

Vecna,Celaph,rdr,Durga,Bona,Damo

I've been fucking nails this entire game and I've gotten for it is flak from Bona who accuses me of not reading when he's been among the useless players in the game (kudos to him for ending on someone other than me for the first time all game) and HR and one or two others who accuse me of only showing up when pinged when it's just not true [/endrant]

[rdrivera2005]

Well, three scum in a row, pretty great job even with most of them just not playing

I need to look at the voting more carefully but Kgray looks better and Jamiet looks a lot worst to me.

[TheFlyingBoat]

Getting rid of the Roleblocker just as the Cop gets outed.

Bittersweet.

Let's hope Maniac is just scum doing a fake claim.

I don't see why he needed to claim when he had only two votes.

I guess he was worried that we'd do the classic webDip move and off a lurker instead of our most favored scum target after scum whispers sweet nothings into some easily moved townies' ears. He wanted to sleep and worry about the rest later. Do I wish he held back? Sure. But what can you do?

[goldfinger0303]

Last time we were scum together, there was an optional group chat with a third party that we all told you not to post in at any point. You made one post, and BunnyGo (the 3P) immediately identified you

Vecna's vote on you was with such hilarious reluctance that it really counts for jack all. At that point it was pretty much a surrender. He tried to make it him vs me, failed, and then didn't know how to react when I kept pushing for you instead of switching to him.

Didn't we still win that game though? My scum and 3P win rate is pretty damn good.

Vecnas vote on me tied it. Given the bloodlust out for me, it's likely I could've died. Highly improbable that I'm a more valuable scum role because of that.

[goldfinger0303]

Unfortunately, a quick vca doesn't really reveal much information. D1 nobody was voting Fox/Vecna, and Vecna stayed on Chaqa or ghug til the end. Vecna was on celaph all day two, which at the time made sense because celaph was a goon, Vecna a PR, and Vecna was a leading wagon at the time. D3 was a runaway on Durga and useless.

And then today, Vecna was on damo (useless, like my vote), then HR. The switch from HR to me could be viewed as a save of HR. It was a switch from a 5 vote wagon on HR to a 5 vote wagon on me. It should have made no difference whatsoever in saving himself, but it did make the counter-wagon me instead of HR.

[Maniac]

Well done again team. Sooner or later I’ll be on a scum wagon I promise, maybe not this game, but it will happen.

Looking back over Vecna. His first post was…

Well that request for replacement didnt take long.

Sort of disappointing EoD time. Probably will not be there for that ever.

Only have given this game a quick glance this morning, and Rdrivera seemed pretty active in a towny jokey way.

And later on…

All this is distracting from my original request for a pizza.


How about I give a free day 1 AND day 2 townread to the first person that townreads me today.

I townread Flum.

so far it did seem pretty close to his usual levels of not giving a shit.

durga deserves suspicion if she did not try to stop the flum wagon

So the clues were there and I could’ve been 3/3 if I’d not been so lazy.

[TheFlyingBoat]

Well done again team. Sooner or later I’ll be on a scum wagon I promise, maybe not this game, but it will happen.

Looking back over Vecna. His first post was…

Well that request for replacement didnt take long.

Sort of disappointing EoD time. Probably will not be there for that ever.

Only have given this game a quick glance this morning, and Rdrivera seemed pretty active in a towny jokey way.

And later on…

I townread Flum.

so far it did seem pretty close to his usual levels of not giving a shit.

durga deserves suspicion if she did not try to stop the flum wagon

So the clues were there and I could’ve been 3/3 if I’d not been so lazy.

That this contraction thing kinda worked is the funniest thing ever

[TheFlyingBoat]

My only wonder is what the false positive rate is for pinging mafia on the no contraction thing

[TheFlyingBoat]

Unfortunately, a quick vca doesn't really reveal much information. D1 nobody was voting Fox/Vecna, and Vecna stayed on Chaqa or ghug til the end. Vecna was on celaph all day two, which at the time made sense because celaph was a goon, Vecna a PR, and Vecna was a leading wagon at the time. D3 was a runaway on Durga and useless.

And then today, Vecna was on damo (useless, like my vote), then HR. The switch from HR to me could be viewed as a save of HR. It was a switch from a 5 vote wagon on HR to a 5 vote wagon on me. It should have made no difference whatsoever in saving himself, but it did make the counter-wagon me instead of HR.

Both Jamie and I were loud supporters of the Fox/Durga theory D1 if that changes your analysis of Vecna's death. Good point on HR. I do like the HR kill quite a bit.