M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

@Bunny - enjoy this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDxn0Xfqkgw

@nanook, this is how you meme.

[rdrivera2005]

I do think it's especially sus that RIVERA would say excuse-Chaqa is scum-Chaqa, when he has played several games with me that would go against that.

Durga hasn't been around as much since I came back, so more benefit of the doubt there.

That said, I do give a lot of excuses regardless of alignment.

I didn't vote you, did I? But I really think you give more detailed excuses when you were scum. I remember last game when your date had a problem so you can be at EOD (and got daykilled) and another one that involves a soccer game and both times you were scum.

And Among us really sucks, my daughter plays it....

[ghug]

Can you really not post pictures on the forum? Is there a workaround I don’t know about??

Be an admin, that is the workaround

Becoming an Admin isn’t as easy as you think

Disagree

[Maniac]

Hey Chaqa can you talk about something that isn't mechanics or anchoring

Hmmm...

Did you know that in World War 2, in order to throw off the Germans, the Allies made a fake army of inflatable tanks led by General Patton and faked a bunch of radio traffic to make it look like the D-Day landings would be at Calais, and not Normandy? And it was so successful they didn’t send the panzer reserves in because they thought a second army was about to land there and that Normandy was a diversion?

^this is fake news

[worcej]

Yeah, my readthrough of the setup got a lot less thorough as I went down the list, so I didn't consider/fully read the 3P when I was suggesting it. :/

With no 3P, you still think it’s a good idea to convert 9 lives to innocent child with no miskill for analysis?

Town clears warp the game in town's favor IMO. They provide trusted voices and decision makers, as well as increasing the complexity of the mafia NK WIFOM game. Every town clear adds another chance for a protective role to make a save as the mafia will want to eliminate the clears, and if they don't, and instead PR hunt, they're leaving a town clear alive for another day/night that they need to deal with later.

I've been playing A LOT of Among Us and I've fallen severely back into the PoE/logical mode of thought on these kinds of games, which is why I'm a bit lost today as I have absolutely no information to work with. Anyone who's played with me knows my value to town has always been at its lowest on Day 1.

I think many people can say their D1 value is the lowest when they are town. You only have comments to work off of, unless someone is so terrible and makes it too obvious they are scum.

[worcej]

Hey Chaqa can you talk about something that isn't mechanics or anchoring

Hmmm...

Did you know that in World War 2, in order to throw off the Germans, the Allies made a fake army of inflatable tanks led by General Patton and faked a bunch of radio traffic to make it look like the D-Day landings would be at Calais, and not Normandy? And it was so successful they didn’t send the panzer reserves in because they thought a second army was about to land there and that Normandy was a diversion?

^this is fake news

You're fake news.

[worcej]

PRs claiming is bad
Next

Who do you believe is the best scum player out of the players in this game?

[bozotheclown]

I've done this twice and been town both times.

I found this from M29, when you were mafia: "You said Vash is a good daykill regardless of alignment. I'm scum so I thought it was a good idea. Jeez you're thick."

Meta doesn't usually work like that.

ghug was indirectly defending Maniac with something that was not accurate.

[Nanook]

Pretty crappy that the response to “can someone help me figure this out” is “lol no fuck you”

Welcome to webdip, hope you stay a long time

More like 'Welcome to the internet, hope you can take a joke'

Wouldn’t count on it!

[Fluminator]

PRs claiming is bad
Next

Who do you believe is the best scum player out of the players in this game?

I haven't seen a lot of players scum games. Probably HR out of the ones I know.
Bozo and Maniac are the ones I have the hardest reading usually.

[Nanook]

Admin being able to post images while normal users can only post links sounds an awful lot like fascism to me!

[bozotheclown]

I've done this twice and been town both times.

I found this from M29, when you were mafia: "You said Vash is a good daykill regardless of alignment. I'm scum so I thought it was a good idea. Jeez you're thick."

Jesus

Ok well I've also done it twice as town, and those were the times people made a big stink about it.

I remember one game, M41, where you got mis-killed D1 for it:

Im feeling like my attempts at trolling are highly ineffectual and heavily ignored

/pouts

Get on my level
Your trolling is quite boring
I claim I am scum

However, the primary reason you got mis-killed was because of this:

##vote Ghug

GET HIM GUYS, WERE NOT LETTING HIM GET AWAY WITH IT AGAIN

This apparently was a reference to where you claimed scum as scum, which was discussed earlier in M41, when you said this:

Oh man, I'd forgotten about the game where I claimed scum. That was excellent.

[worcej]

PRs claiming is bad
Next

Who do you believe is the best scum player out of the players in this game?

I haven't seen a lot of players scum games. Probably HR out of the ones I know.
Bozo and Maniac are the ones I have the hardest reading usually.

Noted - inverse question: who do you think is the best town players here?

[Fluminator]

Who do you believe is the best scum player out of the players in this game?

I haven't seen a lot of players scum games. Probably HR out of the ones I know.
Bozo and Maniac are the ones I have the hardest reading usually.

Noted - inverse question: who do you think is the best town players here?

There's no such thing as good town player.

[ghug]

I found this from M29, when you were mafia: "You said Vash is a good daykill regardless of alignment. I'm scum so I thought it was a good idea. Jeez you're thick."

Meta doesn't usually work like that.

ghug was indirectly defending Maniac with something that was not accurate.

No, I was defending me, because rd likes to say I do things as scum that I don't, and at some point I will probably claim scum again because it's fun.

[Chaqa]

I don't really follow the summit case, or the end votes. Is this just Day 1 memes still?

What don’t you understand about it. It’s like the simplest case of all time? You can agree or disagree with it, but I find it hard to believe if you genuinely looked you would be confused by it...

I meant that it didn't make sense to me, in that it doesn't hold water.

[ghug]

I found this from M29, when you were mafia: "You said Vash is a good daykill regardless of alignment. I'm scum so I thought it was a good idea. Jeez you're thick."

Jesus

Ok well I've also done it twice as town, and those were the times people made a big stink about it.

I remember one game, M41, where you got mis-killed D1 for it:

Im feeling like my attempts at trolling are highly ineffectual and heavily ignored

/pouts

Get on my level
Your trolling is quite boring
I claim I am scum

However, the primary reason you got mis-killed was because of this:

##vote Ghug

GET HIM GUYS, WERE NOT LETTING HIM GET AWAY WITH IT AGAIN

This apparently was a reference to where you claimed scum as scum, which was discussed earlier in M41, when you said this:

Oh man, I'd forgotten about the game where I claimed scum. That was excellent.

I claimed scum as town in a game where I was a wagon for about four straight days because of it (largely thanks to you), and routinely managed to get scum daykilled instead of me. I believe snowy and Ezio were scum, perhaps Vash. I think Vecna was referencing that game here and misremembering my role.

I also claimed scum a couple games ago in the one where Bunny won as third party.

[kgray]

And yet Ghug is top poster without actually saying anything. Interesting, <<Rubs chin and nod to myself>>

He did helpfully say that he has one read - and then he never said what it was.

It was you

Really? I'm your one read? Do you think I'm town or scum?

[ghug]

He did helpfully say that he has one read - and then he never said what it was.

It was you

Really? I'm your one read? Do you think I'm town or scum?

I have others now, like Vecna is scum and Moscow and bunny are probably town.

Something about our interaction around your Tom jokes didn't seem likely coming from scun.

[kgray]

Chaqa, What is your take on revealing the 9 lives role now?

Well, if the 3P is the Freelancer, it's a bad idea unless we have a Doctor or someone who could catch the Freelancer somehow. If the 3P is Marvin, I think it's a good idea.

So...

Probably wait a bit. As I said, it doesn't have to done right now, but I still think it's a good play at some point once we have more information.

What does this post mean? You think it's a bad idea for the RR to reveal if there's not a 3p that kills by guessing people's roles? But if there is that role, then RR should claim? I don't follow this at all.

And both 3p roles are named Marvin.