M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

Hi @Col7by! Thoughts?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Wait no are parenthesis and parentheses different thigns what

[foodcoats]

Oh, and Ezio ALSO doesn’t like Yoyo but has never stated why. Expect Ezio to find a way onto Yoyo soon to steam that wagon up as EOD approaches?

You saying this 10 times this phase doesn't make it true. It does show that you don't know what you're talking about.

"Ezio
Day-3 21:56
page 192 / orig
↑Fluminator: "Is there more to Yoyo besides him being a replacement?"
I've really hated his votes: SnC->me->ending on dip. Now he's on RHK.
I found his assumption the vig was mafia exactly opposite (if he flips scum, I think it's actually really like the vig *is* mafia).

I'm also just, very unimpressed by his play which I think is scum indicative for yoyo.
"

Ah, I didn’t see this. Thank you.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I read you scum claimed like three times this game.

In my experience, joking about being scum is a strong indicator of actually being scum. I think you are nervous.

Uhhhh what nobody would ever do that

Shockingly nobody has pointed that out. Just one or two people who thought his jokes were real and meant for daychat, which is an insane assumption.

True that. It takes some serious stupidity to type out a whole webdip message meant for discord

[sweetandcool]

@Vecna
@Squiggs

Is Foodcoats decent at the game? Are they a player you guys scumread when they're wrong, or is that just par for the course with them?

My past two games with Food I was very impressed with their ability and ability to project towniness.

Not this game at all.

And hasn't he also significantly altered his playstyle today after I called him out for not solving?
If he did it *because* of me calling him out, that's also incredibly scummy.
I also stand by my vote analysis on him from yesterday.

I just assumed it was because he was under pressure. But yes, he seems to be putting in an effort to solve now, which I assume is an attempt to be townread.

[FlaviusAetius]

I don't agree with some of the stuff yoyo has posted, but his opinions feel genuine and his posts are all logically consistent, so I don't see anything blatantly scummy from yoyo.
He hasn't done a ton of scum hunting but as a sub id give him a little bit of a break on activity, and his voting records not fantastic, but from vibes/feel I don't think yoyo is my first or second or third option to vote here.

I would like to hear a bit more from yoyo on his scum reads, especially S&C and aarodactyl

This is a really good point, so good that it it turns out yoyo turns out to be a mafia...Squigs is also likely one...which would be BIG news.
I think our vigilante should shoot yoyo

[President Eden]

Wait no are parenthesis and parentheses different thigns what

My brother in mafia, those are quotation marks.

[BunnyGo]

Uhhhh what nobody would ever do that

Shockingly nobody has pointed that out. Just one or two people who thought his jokes were real and meant for daychat, which is an insane assumption.

True that. It takes some serious stupidity to type out a whole webdip message meant for discord

maybe he'll listen to you...

[foodcoats]

Fuckin still have no idea what happened to frogsterking
Where tf did he go
But ye i am glad you at least realize that 0/4 is a stretch, i think if you doubled down i was mildly scumread you for it and think you were just mafia trying to get towncred for a bad take

It’s mostly that sweet is acting weird but I feel relatively confident his obstinacy is townie, but… I have only see him be scum the one time where you massively bussed him lol. His move off Flum there and his unwillingness to participate in the game is making me wonder. But I wouldn't vote sweet today, rather I am now curious to push Flum for the reactions.

[sweetandcool]

Wait no are parenthesis and parentheses different thigns what

My brother in mafia, those are quotation marks.

It's because he's Canadian.

[Ezio]

Oh, and Ezio ALSO doesn’t like Yoyo but has never stated why. Expect Ezio to find a way onto Yoyo soon to steam that wagon up as EOD approaches?

You saying this 10 times this phase doesn't make it true. It does show that you don't know what you're talking about.

"Ezio
Day-3 21:56
page 192 / orig
↑Fluminator: "Is there more to Yoyo besides him being a replacement?"
I've really hated his votes: SnC->me->ending on dip. Now he's on RHK.
I found his assumption the vig was mafia exactly opposite (if he flips scum, I think it's actually really like the vig *is* mafia).

I'm also just, very unimpressed by his play which I think is scum indicative for yoyo.
"

Ah, I didn’t see this. Thank you.

But you've pinged like 100 times today. How can you be so active and have such a huge part of your day be spent talking about me and just be so *wrong*? I don't understand. It looks really lazy.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Wait no are parenthesis and parentheses different thigns what

My brother in mafia, those are quotation marks.

Ah fuck

[FlaviusAetius]

@colby

[foodcoats]

I read you scum claimed like three times this game.

In my experience, joking about being scum is a strong indicator of actually being scum. I think you are nervous.

Uhhhh so…

Okay.

See I asked some questions… You appear to have gone back to me going GOT HB WOO YEAH SCUM!

Fucking vote me you weakling.

That's what I think about your intuition. Anyways, I promise if you get another vote I will switch to you.

You can even test it out by self voting!

Can you explain the intuition that moved you from lead wagon Flum to yoyo?

[sweetandcool]

Uhhhh so…

Okay.

See I asked some questions… You appear to have gone back to me going GOT HB WOO YEAH SCUM!

Fucking vote me you weakling.

That's what I think about your intuition. Anyways, I promise if you get another vote I will switch to you.

You can even test it out by self voting!

Can you explain the intuition that moved you from lead wagon Flum to yoyo?

Same one that would lead me to vote you if you get another vote.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Wait no are parenthesis and parentheses different thigns what

My brother in mafia, those are quotation marks.

Ah fuck

Nobody saw this conversation

[foodcoats]

@Vecna
@Squiggs

Is Foodcoats decent at the game? Are they a player you guys scumread when they're wrong, or is that just par for the course with them?

My past two games with Food I was very impressed with their ability and ability to project towniness.

Not this game at all.

And hasn't he also significantly altered his playstyle today after I called him out for not solving?
If he did it *because* of me calling him out, that's also incredibly scummy.
I also stand by my vote analysis on him from yesterday.

I will give you the actual reasons I coasted until last night:

-busy week
-26 players!

Now the game is at a size and there is enough data that I can put on my thinking cap.

[worcej]

Using the rectangle reference:

• Yoyoyozo - Eh... null at best. Mostly mechs and voting Monarch for her catchup when he's also lurking. Seems a little opportunistic/low effort than actually contributing to consensus.
• JustAGuyNamedWill - "Shitposting" town. I'd be more concerned if he was being active and a stronger pressence. It'd be flashbacks to when he won down 9-1 as scum in the game I GM'ed if he was active.
• BunnyGo - Obv!Town, like OMG~duh~town. The pushing for the claims is acceptable and wasn't compromising.
• Fluminator - Investigative Town. His early pushes on me and questioning of Bunny is fair and in line with what I'd expect.

##vote yoyo - worst corner of the 4. Not my ideal vote though...

Outside of the rectangle that I'd actually want to flip:

• I am more inclined to be at Eden for how fast he had insight on the ghug kill mechanic, but Eden is going to sort himself out by participating without the "2000 pages"
• Fox has me slightly concerned at this point after the massive Balki feud and daychat (Sweet beat this thoroughly in the thread) being an ability to perpetuate this. If we're really honest, Balki was a potential wagon but D&W excellently grabbed him when he was desperate. Could be some serious scum theater here.
• I still don't like Jamie's weird thing about people assuming the tadpole. Nasty vibes from my perspective on questioning the tadpole thoughts as much as he did. The hard part is thinking he'd "wolf" (not the right use of the term, but best I can think to say) so much.

Outside of Bunny, strong town vibes on Food and Squigs - won't participate in a kill on any of them.

[BunnyGo]

Wait no are parenthesis and parentheses different thigns what

My brother in mafia, those are quotation marks.

It's because he's Canadian.

no he isn't...is he?

[foodcoats]

You saying this 10 times this phase doesn't make it true. It does show that you don't know what you're talking about.

"Ezio
Day-3 21:56
page 192 / orig
↑Fluminator: "Is there more to Yoyo besides him being a replacement?"
I've really hated his votes: SnC->me->ending on dip. Now he's on RHK.
I found his assumption the vig was mafia exactly opposite (if he flips scum, I think it's actually really like the vig *is* mafia).

I'm also just, very unimpressed by his play which I think is scum indicative for yoyo.
"

Ah, I didn’t see this. Thank you.

But you've pinged like 100 times today. How can you be so active and have such a huge part of your day be spent talking about me and just be so *wrong*? I don't understand. It looks really lazy.

There’s a lot of content and you have posted extremely little. I am happy to see you posting more so I can sort you better.