Mafia 87: Madness in Mega-City One - GAME THREAD

[ghug]

6 scum left
It seems impossible to me that both Chaqa AND Balki are lying about being doctor, as the real doctor would then counterclaim and both of them would end up on the chopping block

Therefore at least one of them is actually the doctor

Given the number of clears, the scum team has to include DrFidelis

Unless we believe that brainbomb is lying, which is not a reality I'm willing to entertain right now

Wait a sec, something's wrong:
rd (multiple scans)
worcej (multiple scans)
brain (un-CCed)
kotp (un-CCed)
snowy (King's scan)
ghug (role PM)

Doesn't leave room for either doctor claimant. If we don't get a doc claim from rd or worcej, something's wrong with either a scan or a doctor. Obviously to the outside world here a more straightforward conclusion is that ghug is scum, which is concerning, as I am not.

But yes, I guess you're probably right about Fid.

That is the reasonable conclusion, is it not?
I am open to counterarguments, at a convenient time (or now if you prefer)

That being what? There are three conclusions in the post.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

If brain flips scum not only does it mean that the rdr-worcej pair scan could in fact be false but it also means that only kotp, me, and the two docs are clear

[snowy801]

Wait a sec, something's wrong:
rd (multiple scans)
worcej (multiple scans)
brain (un-CCed)
kotp (un-CCed)
snowy (King's scan)
ghug (role PM)

Doesn't leave room for either doctor claimant. If we don't get a doc claim from rd or worcej, something's wrong with either a scan or a doctor. Obviously to the outside world here a more straightforward conclusion is that ghug is scum, which is concerning, as I am not.

But yes, I guess you're probably right about Fid.

That is the reasonable conclusion, is it not?
I am open to counterarguments, at a convenient time (or now if you prefer)

That being what? There are three conclusions in the post.

That you are scum

Though personally I truly, truly am rooting for a third doctor to claim. That'd be a twist for the ages

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I don’t know how the mechanics work but I know what my gut says

Your gut? Not your PM? Lmao okay judge

Are you not outed scum along with ghug?

I’m pretty lost here

I am resigned to my fate because even though I am cop I am still going to die due to either brian or angel shenanigans

[Chaqa]

Your gut? Not your PM? Lmao okay judge

Are you not outed scum along with ghug?

I’m pretty lost here

I am resigned to my fate because even though I am cop I am still going to die due to either brian or angel shenanigans

I am willing to vote ghug first.

I think he is the most likely mafia

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I’m just watching the caught scums flail about and honestly I’m all for it

[Chaqa]

Also demon is prob scum

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Are you not outed scum along with ghug?

I’m pretty lost here

I am resigned to my fate because even though I am cop I am still going to die due to either brian or angel shenanigans

I am willing to vote ghug first.

I think he is the most likely mafia

Ok sure man they’re all scum to me

##VOTE GHUG

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Also demon is prob scum

You are all scum

[snowy801]

I'm glad Will's at least having fun with all this
It can be very frustrating to have a cop scan dropped on you

[Chaqa]

##Vote ghug

[ghug]

That is the reasonable conclusion, is it not?
I am open to counterarguments, at a convenient time (or now if you prefer)

That being what? There are three conclusions in the post.

That you are scum

Though personally I truly, truly am rooting for a third doctor to claim. That'd be a twist for the ages

Yeah I mean I'd probably flip me but I'm town so please at least humor me for a bit while I try to solve it.

I hardclaim VT.

[Chaqa]

Also demon is prob scum

You are all scum

I’m not but those other jokers might be

[ghug]

Also to vote for me because I'm the one who realized this is a fallacy. There are several other players mechanically identical to me at this point.

[ghug]

4 Angel Gang: D&W
3 Dark Judges:

12 Town:
0-1 Cop*
0-1 Addictive Cop*
0-1 Macho Cop*: ND
0-1 Naive Cop*
0-1 Methodical Cop: Brain
0-1 Parity Cop: Kak
0-1 Vanilla Cop: Kotp
0-1 SJS Cop: Will
0-1 Psychic Cop
1-2 Doctor: Balki, Chaqa
4-7 PRs:
5-8 Vanilla Citizens: Hamilton, Sweet, Vecna, Food, ghug

Unclaimed:
rd, worcej, Snowy, Fid, damo, RHK

Confirmed
Claimed
Scanned town

[snowy801]

Also to vote for me because I'm the one who realized this is a fallacy. There are several other players mechanically identical to me at this point.

The exact list, to my best discernment, being as follows:

Assuming:
1) brain is cop and Will is scum
2) only ONE of the two doctor claimants (Chaqa, Balki) are true

The following players are scum
1. Chaqa OR Balki
2. ghug
3. DemonRHK
4. DrFidelis
5. damo666
6. Will

Unless Chaqa isn't high on steroids and worcej/rivera are both scum, which... honestly we can't be blamed for losing if this is true

[Chaqa]

Also to vote for me because I'm the one who realized this is a fallacy. There are several other players mechanically identical to me at this point.

The exact list, to my best discernment, being as follows:

Assuming:
1) brain is cop and Will is scum
2) only ONE of the two doctor claimants (Chaqa, Balki) are true

The following players are scum
1. Chaqa OR Balki
2. ghug
3. DemonRHK
4. DrFidelis
5. damo666
6. Will

Unless Chaqa isn't high on steroids and worcej/rivera are both scum, which... honestly we can't be blamed for losing if this is true

I seriously think we should at least consider the possibility they are both scum.

But we should still flip ghug, Will, etc.

[snowy801]

Which now means we can probably have an in depth look at the D1 wagon to see who damo's teammates are, but perhaps we can save that for tomorrow

[snowy801]

Also to vote for me because I'm the one who realized this is a fallacy. There are several other players mechanically identical to me at this point.

The exact list, to my best discernment, being as follows:

Assuming:
1) brain is cop and Will is scum
2) only ONE of the two doctor claimants (Chaqa, Balki) are true

The following players are scum
1. Chaqa OR Balki
2. ghug
3. DemonRHK
4. DrFidelis
5. damo666
6. Will

Unless Chaqa isn't high on steroids and worcej/rivera are both scum, which... honestly we can't be blamed for losing if this is true

I seriously think we should at least consider the possibility they are both scum.

But we should still flip ghug, Will, etc.

I am considering it. But it's not really actionable right now, regardless I would say.

I think the safest bet is in fact Will personally, though I am open to shooting judges in particular as they have all the kill power if anyone has any guesses

Mine is DrFidelis judge, based on Dip's scum slip argument which was rather enthusiastic, which makes me want to flip there first

[snowy801]

Alright, I shall also take a break to attend to other matters
Good Will hunting