Mafia Olympics - Final Medal Game - Confirmation Thread

[brainbomb]

I can tell from the reactions that the setup is extremely unpopular and widely disliked. Possible changes coming soon.

[Jamiet99uk]

It only tells mafia who has those actions; and the mafia can very well be the ones elected to take these actions.

You choose to fill the ten slots. The bench is just unelected so there was no reason to keep it that way.

Sorry I don't understand.

Mafia knows who the Tracker is every Night.
Mafia knows who the Doctor is every Night.

How is this balanced?

[brainbomb]

Okay I dont really see why it matters but im gonna go ahead and step down as gm and let someone else run whatever they want. The kouncil advised me to keep this setup weeks ago when I offered to change it and they said nah go ahead and keep it.

So im out. Hopefully someone else has a fun game Jamie likes.

[brainbomb]

You were in the chat with my setup. You were in it for weeks as adjustments were being made. Last minute you are now acting like the setup is broken and acting blindsided by it. It makes no sense how you can suddenly become so disgustingly toxic about it when you had no problem with it for over a month and a half.

[dargorygel]

Brain, please do not back out.

[dargorygel]

If you think carefully... you can see what is unique about this game. I am still convinced it has balance, workability, and will be fun.

[dargorygel]

So the mafia will know who has what powers? Why would they ever target the protected players?

i will not provide anyone specific strategies on how to play but the watcher can always try to catch mafia in whatever way they see fit. And the mafia can always try to outguess what the watcher that night will do. Ect.

This is an important answer

[ghug]

I don't see an obviously gamebreaking strategy for mafia here despite knowing who has what roles.

[brainbomb]

Okay well I am not stepping down. Just frustrations.

[Jamiet99uk]

You were in the chat with my setup. You were in it for weeks as adjustments were being made. Last minute you are now acting like the setup is broken and acting blindsided by it. It makes no sense how you can suddenly become so disgustingly toxic about it when you had no problem with it for over a month and a half.

If that is directed at me, no I wasn't.

I was running a game, then I was about to be in Worcej's game. There wasn't a big period in between where I was a neutral party.

[Jamiet99uk]

Okay well I am not stepping down. Just frustrations.

Glad to hear it.

So: How is this balanced?

[brainbomb]

You were not running a game in mid july when the setup was being discussed and modified. After this image the setup was modified and discussion in that channel continued. Was I supposed to track you down and ask if you still approved of a setup you already had approved of?

If you have a constructive suggestion please do arrive at a point soon. Otherwise im going to conclude youre just trying to be really rude for no reason.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm not trying to interfere but if the GM can't answer that question then what the fuck.

[Jamiet99uk]

IMG_1015.png

You were not running a game in mid july when the setup was being discussed and modified. After this image the setup was modified and discussion in that channel continued. Was I supposed to track you down and ask if you still approved of a setup you already had approved of?

If you have a constructive suggestion please do arrive at a point soon. Otherwise im going to conclude youre just trying to be really rude for no reason.

Okay, hello Brainbomb!

I'm not being rude for no reason; I'm concerned that this setup is unbalanced.

I have explained why.

I am not being mean; I care about everyone having a good experience. I am concerned that this setup is not balanced. I have explained why.

I hope this feedback is helpful.

[brainbomb]

I cant answer a vague question claiming the setup isnt balanced when you arent saying what actually makes it imbalanced.

The mafia knowing who has what powers each night doesnt matter as they have no idea what those people will do with those powers

[Jamiet99uk]

I cant answer a vague question claiming the setup isnt balanced when you arent saying what actually makes it imbalanced.

The mafia knowing who has what powers each night doesnt matter as they have no idea what those people will do with those powers

They can choose which PR they want to kill.

[brainbomb]

No it is drama for the sake of drama and it is not adding anything constructive nor specific as to what your problem is with the setup. It is not imbalanced at all. It is nuanced and yes the mafia get to know what everyone is each night but they have no idea what will be done with those powers and they also are potentially the ones selected to have said powers

[Jamiet99uk]

I fundamentally don't get what the point of this game's central mechanic is.

I'll be honest.

[brainbomb]

I cant answer a vague question claiming the setup isnt balanced when you arent saying what actually makes it imbalanced.

The mafia knowing who has what powers each night doesnt matter as they have no idea what those people will do with those powers

They can choose which PR they want to kill.

They arent PR.
And if you read what the PR do theres a watcher a doc and a joat essentially. Mafia has to outguess what those roles will do with their actions. The joat has a tracker or a gun or a vest.

[rdrivera2005]

Just to say that I didn't understand the setup but will play anyway if the game is still going on.