Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[FlaviusAetius]

Ok Im going to bed now see you guys I'll reread everything on this page when I come back, I think I'll be up early tomorrow so yay

[Squigs44]

Hey, soooo, y’all seem mixed on whether I should out my power role scan. I would like to ask that nobody come forward with a PR claim unless they give me a chance to reveal first, as this is the one way I can prove that I am Blind Assassin.

If 8 people vote Reveal in blue, then I’ll reveal my scan. If not, I’ll wait until EON, so that it cannot influence Night Actions. I’d like to reveal by EON, because if this player flips, I no longer have a way to reveal my role.

Also, for the record, I believe that Foxcastle and teacon are both mafia. But that’s not based on anything special. Just my reads. I have no reason to lie. If you guys lynch Town this phase, I lose right along with you.

Why wait til EoN? They are already going to RB you and kill Rdrivera if you are telling the truth. Giving us the info sooner helps us make a better decision for us today.

Reveal

[Balki Bartokomous]

If you're BA you'll actually reveal it. Your only chance at winning is the death of the roleblocker. It's a little scummy if you don't reveal actually, because then we have to way to confirm your claim, and our best bet is actually to lynch you.

Blah blah blah

I’m glad I don’t have to pretend to be on your team anymore.

[Durga]

If you're BA you'll actually reveal it. Your only chance at winning is the death of the roleblocker. It's a little scummy if you don't reveal actually, because then we have to way to confirm your claim, and our best bet is actually to lynch you.

Blah blah blah

I’m glad I don’t have to pretend to be on your team anymore.

you still have to somewhat pander to me

pls reveal

[Durga]

@squigs - should we just lynch him if he doesn't? it doesn't make sense to not reveal as BA imo

[Squigs44]

That's about it Nephthys, also imo
I think we should ignore lurkers, for now, there are too many at this point and I feel like we are taking a shot in the dark if we go after them, lets instead focus on active players where we got information and can find things out
If we get the active players we can then go for the lurkers
The current lurkers are
Xorxes
Percy
Connor
teacon
peterlund
damo

Their probably scum there, but honestly its not even worth going after them at this point, so lets go after someone else

We also can ignore Balki since the BA will take care of him
We can also ignore et since the two picks were likely town v town
We can also ignore rdrivera, I still think him revealing Balki so soon is silly but what you going to do

Flavius(me)
FoxCastle(scum)
Squigs
ND
Nephthys
Durga
Chippie

I think in this pot there's a few scum

I'm sorry but this posts kinda meanders without a clear purpose. You are saying you think we should lynch only from:
Flavius
FoxCastle
Squigs
ND
Nephthys
Durga
Chippie

I think that is a terrible idea, but you are entitled to your opinion.

Also how is Nephthys in this pool when he has less posts than Percy, teacon, damo, and Xorxes in your lurker pool?

[Squigs44]

Flav wants us to ignore my entire scum pool Nice.

Yup

His "lynch pool" includes pretty much all of my townreads.

[Balki Bartokomous]

If you're BA you'll actually reveal it. Your only chance at winning is the death of the roleblocker. It's a little scummy if you don't reveal actually, because then we have to way to confirm your claim, and our best bet is actually to lynch you.

Blah blah blah

I’m glad I don’t have to pretend to be on your team anymore.

you still have to somewhat pander to me

pls reveal

Eh, you kinda have to pander to me. I mean, what’s the percentage chance of me winning now? Is it even possible? It would take a truly crazy set of circumstances.

[Squigs44]

@squigs - should we just lynch him if he doesn't? it doesn't make sense to not reveal as BA imo

I want to see his answer about the EoN reveal

Balki is a smart guy (according to Flav), so I am increasingly thinking he has to be scum because he wouldn't play BA the way he is claiming to have played.

[Durga]

Well I can't really be around for the rest of the days so I really wanted it all resolved today so I could weigh in on it

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Squigs, what do you want to know?

[Squigs44]

I need to look at Xorxes and Fox again. Fox might still be the right lynch even with TrPrado likely not having scanned him.

[Squigs44]

@Squigs, what do you want to know?

Why wait till EoN to reveal? If you are telling the truth, they will have to RB you and kill Rdr, so revealing now vs EoN doesn't change mafia's actions.

[Squigs44]

I want to see cases and questions from others on Fox and Xorxes and Percy, or whoever else you think is scum. I don't want to be the only one putting out cases today.

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Squigs, what do you want to know?

Why wait till EoN to reveal? If you are telling the truth, they will have to RB you and kill Rdr, so revealing now vs EoN doesn't change mafia's actions.

Well they could do that. They also could kill the player I reveal, RB Rdrivera, and hope you guys lynch me or I kill Town. They have an awful lot of ways to win.

I mean, I don’t know what Scum will do. But I have one tiny piece of information, and I’d frankly like to live.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I’m going to bed.

[Durga]

Yeah sorry I can't be helpful this phase then. Good luck I'll check in frequently but it'll be busy for me from now on.

##vote Balki

[Nephthys]

##vote flav

He isn't at all staying up to date. Purely reactive play and not solving.

Then there's the car bomb...

[Squigs44]

@Squigs, what do you want to know?

Why wait till EoN to reveal? If you are telling the truth, they will have to RB you and kill Rdr, so revealing now vs EoN doesn't change mafia's actions.

Well they could do that. They also could kill the player I reveal, RB Rdrivera, and hope you guys lynch me or I kill Town. They have an awful lot of ways to win.

I mean, I don’t know what Scum will do. But I have one tiny piece of information, and I’d frankly like to live.

You think they would kill judge/inno over BA? I don't think they would.

Okay new question:
When you scanned this person, were you townreading at that time, or did you townread them after the fact? It doesn't make sense to scan someone you townread, it makes much more sense to scan the person you are scumreading most, and I trust you would make optimal plays as BA. So how did you go from most scumread to pretty sure they are town if this is the case?

Your claims just don't add up to me.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Yeah sorry I can't be helpful this phase then. Good luck I'll check in frequently but it'll be busy for me from now on.

##vote Balki

Lynching me would be an appropriate way for this game to end.

My win condition is less than one percent. Thinking I should pander to you here is pretty darn entitled.