M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[FlaviusAetius]

Stop snipping quotes if you can't do it correctly Jesus Christ

I think we should hammer him. It's so easy to read the unquoted bottom of a post. I am not reading a garbled broken quoted post at all.

Listen I might have messed up the quoting feature but it certianly isnt a jumbled mess just read it

[FlaviusAetius]

Flav your insistence that mafia has a designated lurker is super weird

No who else thought it was weird? Balki! Makes me think its even more true than I thought before. And bruh it could be two lurkers but theres definetly one

[foodcoats]

And if Town activated the power to kill top two wagons they would have thought Dip and lfisch were Mafia, or sniped the duel and thought Balki and Dip were Mafia.

I guess the former is more likely, but I really think Mafia activated the power.

I suppose an ISO on Balki could possibly shed some light.

Actually no, I forgot my assessment of Town motivation. It would be less a matter of thinking top two wagons were scum and more a matter of top two wagons not being Townread.

People also just like having roles and using them. There was a whole flamethread about people just wanting to be PRs at one point. People fucking love abilities.

Anyway your analysis is townie, we just can't draw much meaning from the Battlemaster in my shitlord opinion.

[Squigs44]

Flav is playing with a completely different framework than the rest of us but not necessarily a scumslip TMI kind of framework, just a series of weird assumptions, like MadMonarch is going to sub, the mafia team has a designated lurker, etc.

It makes it really hard to follow Flavs logic because he has so many assumptions that the rest of us aren't making.

[Squigs44]

Flav your insistence that mafia has a designated lurker is super weird

No who else thought it was weird? Balki! Makes me think its even more true than I thought before. And bruh it could be two lurkers but theres definetly one

So you're just ignoring ghug?

lfischl suddenly becoming very active here is interesting. He had posted a rip damo and a vote a few pages prior, but getting involved because his teammate got dueled seems plausible.

Well my theory is that the mafia decided to put their team members into roles one of these roles was the "lurker" kotp doesnt count because he got replace dby Balki and balki was anything BUT a lurker

I have never seen a scumteam play this way.

[ghug]

noting the take by yoyo

How is this a nothing take??

This is NOT a nothing take! Yoyozo is supposed to be this mafia veteran and he cant realize that the vigilante is OBVIOUSLY a townie. He's made a huge scumslip here and we need to hold his feet to the fire. Remember theres one lurker who is a mafia, that cant be kotp becaue of Balki, probably not fischl because he's been this great target; I think its yoyozo

Oh boy

[Jamiet99uk]

lurkers so far;
lfischl (keeps being the ONLY lurker to get CONSISTENT wagons on him...but nothing more than being a lurker; WHY ONLY HIM?)
colby (has said some sus stuff, is still a newbie tho, maybe give him more chances?)
ezio (i like his reads and has been getting consistently more active)
yoyozo (starting to suspect)
themadmonarch (is about to get subbed out, no need to kill them now, surely a mafia wouldnt be THIS inactive)
worcecj(said before game began he would for first few days)
demon(high end of the lurkers, just hasnt talked during N2 )

Where did we learn madmonarch is getting subbed?

no where this is my prediction no way he stays in the game after this kind of insane inactivity

Another reminder that Macca is not male.

[Jamiet99uk]

noting the take by yoyo

How is this a nothing take??

This is NOT a nothing take! Yoyozo is supposed to be this mafia veteran and he cant realize that the vigilante is OBVIOUSLY a townie. He's made a huge scumslip here and we need to hold his feet to the fire. Remember theres one lurker who is a mafia, that cant be kotp becaue of Balki, probably not fischl because he's been this great target; I think its yoyozo

I highly doubt this is a huge scumslip, Flavius, stop jumping up an down on the couch please.

[FlaviusAetius]

##vote balki

Flavius initially voted Dip and then almost immediately changed his mind.

I like that.

Flavius, why did you change your mind?

Because I agreed with Kak that you dip and flum were all in a team, your votes made so much sense when viewed in that light. I thought it made more sense to go after you first tho not dip. I was trying to convince the dip voters of that logic. Then Dip became the only valid vote amongst you guys so I was like fine we'll go with Dip. Then Dip's arguments started making sense, and a lot of people were like bro lets just vote Balki for the boldness of Dip. So I agreed and boom off to Balki I went, that all happened in a few seconds in my mind BTW

[Squigs44]

Flav your insistence that mafia has a designated lurker is super weird

No who else thought it was weird? Balki! Makes me think its even more true than I thought before. And bruh it could be two lurkers but theres definetly one

So you're just ignoring ghug?

Well my theory is that the mafia decided to put their team members into roles one of these roles was the "lurker" kotp doesnt count because he got replace dby Balki and balki was anything BUT a lurker

I have never seen a scumteam play this way.

Oh I misread your post and thought it said "no one else" instead of "no who else" since it should have been "know who else"

[FlaviusAetius]

Where did we learn madmonarch is getting subbed?

no where this is my prediction no way he stays in the game after this kind of insane inactivity

Another reminder that Macca is not male.

oof my bad

[ghug]

How is this a nothing take??

This is NOT a nothing take! Yoyozo is supposed to be this mafia veteran and he cant realize that the vigilante is OBVIOUSLY a townie. He's made a huge scumslip here and we need to hold his feet to the fire. Remember theres one lurker who is a mafia, that cant be kotp becaue of Balki, probably not fischl because he's been this great target; I think its yoyozo

Oh boy

Since this has come up a few times: noting and nothing are different words

Also how the fuck is that a scumslip?

[FlaviusAetius]

No who else thought it was weird? Balki! Makes me think its even more true than I thought before. And bruh it could be two lurkers but theres definetly one

So you're just ignoring ghug?

I have never seen a scumteam play this way.

Oh I misread your post and thought it said "no one else" instead of "no who else" since it should have been "know who else"

oof typed that out too quickly

[foodcoats]

How is this a nothing take??

This is NOT a nothing take! Yoyozo is supposed to be this mafia veteran and he cant realize that the vigilante is OBVIOUSLY a townie. He's made a huge scumslip here and we need to hold his feet to the fire. Remember theres one lurker who is a mafia, that cant be kotp becaue of Balki, probably not fischl because he's been this great target; I think its yoyozo

I highly doubt this is a huge scumslip, Flavius, stop jumping up an down on the couch please.

Hmm. Not necessarily scum indicative, but has yoyo done anything town indicative? Not from my perspective.

[dargorygel]

Our Hour in the Night is all we have left. In this night.

[FlaviusAetius]

Yea that's me btw
not going to die without at least using my PR ability

Why did this duel help town? Why not let it ride out? What do we gain from limited options?

Squigs town using the same Flum logic.

I think a lot of people had this same reaction to what Dip was doing, NAI

[FlaviusAetius]

This is NOT a nothing take! Yoyozo is supposed to be this mafia veteran and he cant realize that the vigilante is OBVIOUSLY a townie. He's made a huge scumslip here and we need to hold his feet to the fire. Remember theres one lurker who is a mafia, that cant be kotp becaue of Balki, probably not fischl because he's been this great target; I think its yoyozo

I highly doubt this is a huge scumslip, Flavius, stop jumping up an down on the couch please.

Hmm. Not necessarily scum indicative, but has yoyo done anything town indicative? Not from my perspective.

I think he is playing willfully blind

[foodcoats]

FlaviusAetius has that kind of "Shit is so bananas!" energy that I am starting to wonder if he is scum.

I am coming around on worcej based on some recent posts.

I am coming around on Jamie being scum. Will have to do a re-re-read. My first re-read gave me no feelings at all. But that is probably scumleaning for Jamie. I usually feel "town Jamie" pretty fast and emphatically.

There's a niggle in my biggle that Squiggle could be... scum, but based on nothing. Squiggle sounds like me when I am scum. Extremely logical. This is mostly paranoia (mine), though, I think.

[Jamiet99uk]

Our Hour in the Night is all we have left.

We'll always have Paris, mon ami.

[foodcoats]

Oh you know what

I bet Will is scum

Like where is Will? Will why are you so chill this game?