MAFIA 49 -Avengers "Re-release"- GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]

[Foxcastle]

Because I have no fucking clue what "townie" looks like besides "trying my fucking hardest to find scum". So that's what I'm doing...

We're on page 182! You must have picked up some idea of what looks townie and what looks scummy!

Sadly...this is my first time not playing f2f. And I have a 0 confirmed scum hit rate. I have a 0 confirmed scum theory correct rate. So while I have some ideas...I don't have confirmation.

Interesting how you try to wriggle out of the question of whether you have a reasonable idea of what scumplay or townplay looks like, with an added dash of "take pity on me, I don't know what I'm doing and I'm new"...

What I'm curious about is these occasional mixed messages: hard-charging scumhunter versus uncertain noobie.

[Foxcastle]

##VOTE SULIT

[damo666]

@darg as you are willing to vote Tem why not switch now so we a clear leader?

[BunnyGo]

We're on page 182! You must have picked up some idea of what looks townie and what looks scummy!

Sadly...this is my first time not playing f2f. And I have a 0 confirmed scum hit rate. I have a 0 confirmed scum theory correct rate. So while I have some ideas...I don't have confirmation.

Interesting how you try to wriggle out of the question of whether you have a reasonable idea of what scumplay or townplay looks like, with an added dash of "take pity on me, I don't know what I'm doing and I'm new"...

What I'm curious about is these occasional mixed messages: hard-charging scumhunter versus uncertain noobie.

OK...think of it this way:

I know bullshit when I see it--and I call it hard when I do

BUUUUUT

I'm willing to believe that most people write bullshit by accident when they are confused.

[dargorygel]

@darg re your proposal

you can't suggest we all vote for the HAC from all our top 3s and then end up by saying from these 3 A, B, C.

All you can say is my top 3 are A B C.

Is this what you meant?

I am not sure I understand the question...
So let me restate, more simply.
We all state our HAC: A,B,C
We compare ABC's and all vote for whichever of them is Most Common. Most Common Denominator...

Does that make sense?

@Bunny... Thanos' power ring will not help if we are all on the same vote.
And regarding him using the time ring... it IS a danger. But it is a danger that happens anyway. Here we have SOME control. Maybe enough to get more than 2 majority.

[damo666]

Bunnies Foxes Goats and Bulls

Bloody Menagerie

[BunnyGo]

This is the conflict. I hate seeing horrible analysis. I hate seeing arguments I can't make sense of. BUUUUT I don't really know how to construct my own. Every time I go and do an ISO I come back with "probably town"

[BunnyGo]

@Dargo

Agreed. I was merely pointing out we need to be aligned 12 hours before EOD

[Foxcastle]

This is the conflict. I hate seeing horrible analysis. I hate seeing arguments I can't make sense of. BUUUUT I don't really know how to construct my own. Every time I go and do an ISO I come back with "probably town"

How many of the remaining players have you iso'd?

[dargorygel]

@darg as you are willing to vote Tem why not switch now so we a clear leader?

My HAC includes vape... where I am presently voting.
Perhaps an adjustment (because of pesky Thanos) would be for us to list our HAC, and vote for whichever one is presently most common.

idk.

[damo666]

@darg re your proposal

you can't suggest we all vote for the HAC from all our top 3s and then end up by saying from these 3 A, B, C.

All you can say is my top 3 are A B C.

Is this what you meant?

I am not sure I understand the question...
So let me restate, more simply.
We all state our HAC: A,B,C
We compare ABC's and all vote for whichever of them is Most Common. Most Common Denominator...

Does that make sense?

@Bunny... Thanos' power ring will not help if we are all on the same vote.
And regarding him using the time ring... it IS a danger. But it is a danger that happens anyway. Here we have SOME control. Maybe enough to get more than 2 majority.

OK. It's just sounded that you were prepared to vote the most popular candidate provided that it was in your own ABC.

[BunnyGo]

Also, if the vision stone isn't used by then, I think we can assume that:

Neph's strange 95%--no wait--60% theory may actually hold water and the scum have it

[Foxcastle]

@Dargo

Agreed. I was merely pointing out we need to be aligned 12 hours before EOD

If scum have the time stone, poor Ike will be stuck running EOD at 6AM his time for the rest of game. Scum have an incentive to make the game inconvenient.

However, if the SK has the time stone, we may yet see a return to the normal hour. He needs to prevent town from getting rolled.

[BunnyGo]

This is the conflict. I hate seeing horrible analysis. I hate seeing arguments I can't make sense of. BUUUUT I don't really know how to construct my own. Every time I go and do an ISO I come back with "probably town"

How many of the remaining players have you iso'd?

At some point...I've done all of them.

Recently: Neph, Vap, Tem, Sul

[dargorygel]

Did chaqa ever get an answer from the GM about when the stone becomes available? If he did, I missed it.

##CALL GM does the mind stone become available on THIS day? Or after the start of the next Night Phase?

[Jamiet99uk]

KALEL CHASE
RDRIVERA
SULIT
VAPOR


WHY are you not VOTING??

[BunnyGo]

KALEL CHASE
RDRIVERA
SULIT
VAPOR


WHY are you not VOTING??

Have they even been online?

[damo666]

This is the conflict. I hate seeing horrible analysis. I hate seeing arguments I can't make sense of. BUUUUT I don't really know how to construct my own. Every time I go and do an ISO I come back with "probably town"

With a competent scumteam of course you're gonna come to the conclusion that everyone is town. Actions speak louder than words. That's why VCA is so important and runaway wagons unhelpful.

And just having written that darg's idea is bad.

Every one should just vote for their strongest scumread.

[BunnyGo]

This is the conflict. I hate seeing horrible analysis. I hate seeing arguments I can't make sense of. BUUUUT I don't really know how to construct my own. Every time I go and do an ISO I come back with "probably town"

With a competent scumteam of course you're gonna come to the conclusion that everyone is town. Actions speak louder than words. That's why VCA is so important and runaway wagons unhelpful.

And just having written that darg's idea is bad.

Every one should just vote for their strongest scumread.

And what, hope the SK wants to put his weight on catching scum so they don't run away with this?

[Foxcastle]

This is the conflict. I hate seeing horrible analysis. I hate seeing arguments I can't make sense of. BUUUUT I don't really know how to construct my own. Every time I go and do an ISO I come back with "probably town"

With a competent scumteam of course you're gonna come to the conclusion that everyone is town. Actions speak louder than words. That's why VCA is so important and runaway wagons unhelpful.

And just having written that darg's idea is bad.

Every one should just vote for their strongest scumread.

And what, hope the SK wants to put his weight on catching scum so they don't run away with this?

They do have an incentive to prevent scum from winning. If town doesn't start making progress in flipping scum, soon, they'll lose too.