M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

Do you think Maniac's participation is meaningful?

[damo666]

I dont like the way damo progressed on blamp and just gave it up after minimal pressure.

I'm glad you posted this because it's made me realise something.

The reason I was voting Blamp was I couldn't formulate a scumteam without him. However this was on the assumption Bona is town (due to Chaqa's mucking about).

Therefore I now realise AT LEAST ONE OF BONA AND BLAMP MUST BE SCUM. Of these Bona is much more likely imo.

So ##vote Bona.

If Bona doesn't take off (it should, follow the reasoning) I'll revert back to Vecna or maybe Durga.

And why is Bona so fixated on TFB?

And why was he displeased at the celaph kill post the scumslip? Weird in the extreme.

[damo666]

Do you think Maniac's participation is meaningful?

Up to Kouncil innit?

It's not exactly fish level.

[Jamiet99uk]

I dont like the way damo progressed on blamp and just gave it up after minimal pressure.

I'm glad you posted this because it's made me realise something.

The reason I was voting Blamp was I couldn't formulate a scumteam without him. However this was on the assumption Bona is town (due to Chaqa's mucking about).

Therefore I now realise AT LEAST ONE OF BONA AND BLAMP MUST BE SCUM. Of these Bona is much more likely imo.

So ##vote Bona.

If Bona doesn't take off (it should, follow the reasoning) I'll revert back to Vecna or maybe Durga.

And why is Bona so fixated on TFB?

And why was he displeased at the celaph kill post the scumslip? Weird in the extreme.

Can you explain why one of them *must* be scum?

I have Bona in my scum pool but I want to understand your logic

[Jamiet99uk]

Do you think Maniac's participation is meaningful?

Up to Kouncil innit?

It's not exactly fish level.

I don't think there's much difference.

Vecna is still missing, too.

[damo666]

@Jamie based on my assumptions (which could be wrong ofc) then if Bona is town Blamp must be scum (no other team works) so Blamp and Bona cannot both be town.

[damo666]

Do you think Maniac's participation is meaningful?

Up to Kouncil innit?

It's not exactly fish level.

I don't think there's much difference.

Vecna is still missing, too.

Vecna did say he was busy though. And I had a massive gap so I wouldn't want to see the rule used unless in extremis tbh.

[damo666]

Where'd Durga go?

##Vote Durga

And demonRHK and HR and rdr

[damo666]

Are 48 hour day phases too long? We seem to be losing momentum.

[damo666]

Is anybody there?

[rdrivera2005]

Where'd Durga go?

##Vote Durga

And demonRHK and HR and rdr

It was weekend and it's summer time here (beach, caipirinha, meeting with friends after a long time because of pandemics). Today I am working so I will be around but not that much, at least I should be updated and around at EOD.

I have trouble following your assumptions but I don't rule out Bona as scum. But I think tryng to find the whole scumteam at once isn't the way to go so early in the game. I think HR and Durga are likely scum, just feel HR is more likely.

[BusinessLamp]

Bobert hasn’t posted in a bit either, right?

For me it seems obvious that the immediate reaction to yesterday is an HR or Durga vote. Durga’s lack of passion and just coming on to pick at my one post has made me feel pretty confident in keeping my vote there. I don’t really get why there’s momentum on Vecna, they don’t seem as directly implicated by the celaph flip.

But also damo, in response to your Bona logic, I don’t necessarily agree with the base assumption that only one person could have bussed on celaph. Scum need to get 5 people incorrectly voted off I think (Jamie don’t come at me if my math is wrong), so if taking out celaph sets up like, three wrong votes, I could see how it’s a viable strategic play to do that. I don’t think that’s the most likely scenario for sure, but I’m hard-pressed to completely write it off. Granted, I’m probably not the one to give this opinion and have it seem unbiased.

[damo666]

Interesting that the last 2 posts have Durga and HR as scum. Both are in my scumpool. Perhaps we are getting somewhere.

Bona Durga HR Maniac/Vecna ?

[Jamiet99uk]

@Jamie based on my assumptions (which could be wrong ofc) then if Bona is town Blamp must be scum (no other team works) so Blamp and Bona cannot both be town.

Is there a post where you set out in detail what those assumptions are?

If so, which page is that post on?
If not, please could you provide that information now?

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok, well I've made a GM call about Maniac so:

##Vote Durga (ga ga ga)

[damo666]

I have revisited the voting and conclude the following are town.

Bob
TFB
Chaqa
DemonRHK
Donny
ghug
Jamiet
rdr


So the remaining scum are in this pool

Blamp
Bona
Durga
Vecna
gold
HR
kgray
Maniac


I find the following pairings unlikely

Blamp Durga
Gold Vecna
Gold HR
kgray Durga
Maniac HR

More to follow....

For Jamie. These WERE my assumptions however I have moved kgray to town for her RB claim and Blamp more or less to town because he just doesn't seem like scum. So the unlikely BlampDurga and kgrayDurga can be ignored.

The only 2 possibles teams are therefore

Bona Durga Gold Maniac

OR

Bona Durga Vecna HR

So Bona and durga both deffo scum.

##vote Durga

##End

[Jamiet99uk]

Thank you Damo.

I must say again that I do not care for your performative endvoting. We are not going to endhammer today, especially not as that will give a free pass to the people who are not participating.

[damo666]

Thank you Damo.

I must say again that I do not care for your performative endvoting. We are not going to endhammer today, especially not as that will give a free pass to the people who are not participating.

I know we are most unlikely to hammer the day but given the timing of EOD I won't be around so I am indicating I've finalised my vote.

[kgray]

I dont like the way damo progressed on blamp and just gave it up after minimal pressure.

I'm glad you posted this because it's made me realise something.

The reason I was voting Blamp was I couldn't formulate a scumteam without him. However this was on the assumption Bona is town (due to Chaqa's mucking about).

Therefore I now realise AT LEAST ONE OF BONA AND BLAMP MUST BE SCUM. Of these Bona is much more likely imo.

So ##vote Bona.

If Bona doesn't take off (it should, follow the reasoning) I'll revert back to Vecna or maybe Durga.

And why is Bona so fixated on TFB?

And why was he displeased at the celaph kill post the scumslip? Weird in the extreme.

Bona’s insistence that it should’ve been boatman is weird but I see no reason why he’d fake all that emotion as scum when boatman was (incorrectly imo) calling him out for being “too weird” like an hour before. Bona would steer away from that if he were scum. Also he always latches on to a read like that as town, as I mentioned D2.

[rdrivera2005]

I dont like the way damo progressed on blamp and just gave it up after minimal pressure.

I'm glad you posted this because it's made me realise something.

The reason I was voting Blamp was I couldn't formulate a scumteam without him. However this was on the assumption Bona is town (due to Chaqa's mucking about).

Therefore I now realise AT LEAST ONE OF BONA AND BLAMP MUST BE SCUM. Of these Bona is much more likely imo.

So ##vote Bona.

If Bona doesn't take off (it should, follow the reasoning) I'll revert back to Vecna or maybe Durga.

And why is Bona so fixated on TFB?

And why was he displeased at the celaph kill post the scumslip? Weird in the extreme.

Bona’s insistence that it should’ve been boatman is weird but I see no reason why he’d fake all that emotion as scum when boatman was (incorrectly imo) calling him out for being “too weird” like an hour before. Bona would steer away from that if he were scum. Also he always latches on to a read like that as town, as I mentioned D2.

Í don´t remember so clearly Bona´s meta and find him hard to read as any alignment. This said, his current play is so anti-town that I don´t discard he being scum. Probably not the flip for today, but if he keep doing this he will eventually be the DK.

Answering BLamp, you are correct, scum needs 5 misskills. We are today at 13-4, so we have 4 misskils before kilo, considering Doc is gone.