MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

Sorry, this was uncalled and unnecessary. I am having some RL problems but it doesn't give me the right to be rude. I honestly apologize. In fact you are probably the best town player in this game, considering Ghug catch.

okay i'm sorry i do not trust people who apologize for being rude because of RL problems. ghug did that and he was scum.

only scum feel bad about being rude checkmate

I don't know if this is a joke or not, but I am not engaging you anymore.

##vote BobMcBob

I think he and Bo being a wagon could be interesting. I would not mind voting Bozo too.

And I have serious doubts at Fox being scum at this point.

bro the only thing that changed from fox is he stopped scum reading you, and now you have serious doubts?

Okay, I give up. Y'all kill whoever you want

[damo666]

Calling TOWN

Can we please not tie it tonight.

I think we should endeavour to have this wrapped up with (say) a good 10 minutes to go and treat late switches with utmost suspicion.

Please quote and add your name if you agree.

[Durga]

Calling TOWN

Can we please not tie it tonight.

I think we should endeavour to have this wrapped up with (say) a good 10 minutes to go and treat late switches with utmost suspicion.

Please quote and add your name if you agree.

Agreed, no more last second voting circus.

And 10 minutes before EoD I will leave my vote wherever yours is damo, even if I don't agree with it.

[seth24c]

Calling TOWN

Can we please not tie it tonight.

I think we should endeavour to have this wrapped up with (say) a good 10 minutes to go and treat late switches with utmost suspicion.

Please quote and add your name if you agree.

Sounds great to me.

[rdrivera2005]

Calling TOWN

Can we please not tie it tonight.

I think we should endeavour to have this wrapped up with (say) a good 10 minutes to go and treat late switches with utmost suspicion.

Please quote and add your name if you agree.

I agree. As long as you don't decide to consolidate on me, lol.

[rdrivera2005]

okay i'm sorry i do not trust people who apologize for being rude because of RL problems. ghug did that and he was scum.

only scum feel bad about being rude checkmate

I don't know if this is a joke or not, but I am not engaging you anymore.

##vote BobMcBob

I think he and Bo being a wagon could be interesting. I would not mind voting Bozo too.

And I have serious doubts at Fox being scum at this point.

bro the only thing that changed from fox is he stopped scum reading you, and now you have serious doubts?

Okay, I give up. Y'all kill whoever you want

Fox read something the same way I do, and this makes me think he might be town like me, why this is so incomprehensible?

[Durga]

Man, I don't get it. Why do you have to act like I'm an idiot for even considering you're scum with every message you reply to me with. Why is it so INCOMPREHENSIBLE to YOU that I might think this way that you have to undermine everything? And it isn't just with me, your only retort to being scum read is to attempt to shade/undermine whoever is doing it.

If this is your town game, seriously step up.

[Durga]

Like - can I read your mind rdr? How would I know you have the same thought as Foxy? Which thought? You also found a PR who "scanned" you? LIke what

[Durga]

##vote emc

[Foxcastle]

Let's test TrPrado's theory...

##VOTE BO

[Hamilton Brian]

Thank you!!! Your benevolence knows no bounds.

[e.m.c^42]

I thought this one was a bit strange. Key word here for me is “strong” thoughts, because that implies that emc had strong thoughts about Chaqa. The prior post was the only substantial post toward or regarding Chaqa that emc had made, and it doesn’t seem to break the “strong thoughts” threshold to me. Emc, what sort of thoughts did you have toward Chaqa prior to voting for him that you didn’t share with us?

Aha, this was the post with question, it was an oddly strong feeling

===

Emc, why did you leave HB’s wagon? How do you read him now?

The way Chaqa was acting seemed to reenforce the scummy gut feel, so off HB I went. I townread him more now.

===

With two minutes to go, you ask Chaqa for… scumreads? I don’t get this. Why are you asking him for his reads with two minutes to go until the deadline? If this is important to you, why not ask it before the deadline?

Last prod to see if he had any chance of being, well, not scum.

[e.m.c^42]

Do you have examples of this? I don’t recall it, but I also personally ignore the first few hours of most games.

Yes.

D1 M1009

Hey guys. About to head out to dinner with friends, but I’ll touch base later. Haven’t played a vanilla game in forever, and good to see a few old faces back (sup food) as well as some new blood.

##Vote EMC until he casts a vote (<3)

D1 M54

About halfway caught up. It's hard to even see the screen through all this toilet paper, but I'm trying. Preliminary and not that serious ##Vote EMC until he casts a vote or I find someone better.

D1 M1011

Today we don't have to worry about it if my reading of the roles is right, but tomorrow onward the mafia could have a vote doubling ability - so we need to make sure our wagons are not too close or else one mafia member could switch and do a 3 vote swing.

##Vote EMC until he votes, as is tradition

Not dropping damo off the radar, but I want to pressure EMC to not get modkilled again, like he has before. Damo's comment still seems like an extremely forced way to vote xorx. Maybe they're teammates?

D1 M56

Okay, I skimmed this first 10 pages or so, nothing stuck out. I'll have to go back and +1 everything when I re-read it more later. That was a nice way of keeping track of my place.

I was joking originally, but ##Vote EMC

It's way out of character for him to actually vote, and as much as I love him, he's definitely not town if he's voting this early.

I may have missed one where he subs in and does it on D2 or whatever, but you get the idea lol

[rdrivera2005]

Man, I don't get it. Why do you have to act like I'm an idiot for even considering you're scum with every message you reply to me with. Why is it so INCOMPREHENSIBLE to YOU that I might think this way that you have to undermine everything? And it isn't just with me, your only retort to being scum read is to attempt to shade/undermine whoever is doing it.

If this is your town game, seriously step up.

I just don't think we should discuss PRs now. There are two scums and 50% of a witch that are also reading the thread.
Just ignore me. Vote me if you think I am scum.
I don't think our interaction is helping town in any way.

[Hamilton Brian]

Will TrP take that vote off of RDR and put it on Bo to put his hypothesis to the test?

[e.m.c^42]

Why did you wait until 30 minutes prior to the deadline to try to “taunt” worcej, and what did you expect his reaction to be if he were town and if he were scum?

What did you accomplish with your “poke atcha” of Fox? You did not ask him any direct questions after voting for him.

Why did you take your vote off of Fox to go back to worcej? The vote count at this time was 4-4-3, with worcej and Bob with 4 and Fox with 3. You ensured with this vote that Fox did not have an opportunity to be the kill by making it 5-4-2, so you must have had a good reason to get off of him.

Why did you vote for Bob over worcej after bailing on your scumread to get worcej?

Why did you aim for the third party instead of aiming for scum? Did you townread the other wagons?

"poke atcha" of Fox he seemed townier. Pressure on certain people means nothing earlier in the day since they'll pass it off, within last 20-30 minutes til EOD is best time to do it, since there's enough risk for it to be real and enough time to respond for hop on or off.

Everything else can be answered by yes to the last question.

[e.m.c^42]

Anyways this makes me curious, ##vote bo

[Durga]

Man, I don't get it. Why do you have to act like I'm an idiot for even considering you're scum with every message you reply to me with. Why is it so INCOMPREHENSIBLE to YOU that I might think this way that you have to undermine everything? And it isn't just with me, your only retort to being scum read is to attempt to shade/undermine whoever is doing it.

If this is your town game, seriously step up.

I just don't think we should discuss PRs now. There are two scums and 50% of a witch that are also reading the thread.
Just ignore me. Vote me if you think I am scum.
I don't think our interaction is helping town in any way.

Sure, you still haven't' told me how you think like Fox but ok

##vote rdr

[e.m.c^42]

Anyways this makes me curious, ##vote bo

But, I will say, this is more to see Prado's reactions. His sudden post dump seems more like a tactic than anything else, but there is theory that makes this work I guess.

[e.m.c^42]

Maybe I am missing something but I'm not feeling the rivera scumreads for some reason, even if Vecna (bless his sqwakin' soul in the heavenly godthread) did seem to feel something on D1. I dunno.