M1025 Game Thread

[Chaqa]

Sigh.

I wonder if bunny was roleblocked.

Hammering him was probably a mistake in retrospect.

[Chaqa]

I was thinking about whether mafia believed his claim or thought brain was the doctor and what that may mean.

[Jamiet99uk]

Sigh.

I wonder if bunny was roleblocked.

Hammering him was probably a mistake in retrospect.

Yours was the first hammer vote on him. But I accept my involvement. Sorry. If he had been RBed it might have prompted him to speak up.

I still don't understand his outburst to be honest.

[Chaqa]

Who knows.

Make sure you leave a reads list in case you die.

Hopefully they roleblock you and kill Bozo or me and you guys can get the roleblocker killed tomorrow to go infinite

[pyxxy]

I was thinking about whether mafia believed his claim or thought brain was the doctor and what that may mean.

We haven't had any roleblock claims so far, right?

[Chaqa]

I was thinking about whether mafia believed his claim or thought brain was the doctor and what that may mean.

We haven't had any roleblock claims so far, right?

Presumably they’ve been roleblocking their kills, but it’s possible bunny was roleblocked. I was so sure he was mafia I didn’t think about it.

[pyxxy]

I was thinking about whether mafia believed his claim or thought brain was the doctor and what that may mean.

We haven't had any roleblock claims so far, right?

Presumably they’ve been roleblocking their kills, but it’s possible bunny was roleblocked. I was so sure he was mafia I didn’t think about it.

Right, no, I understood your point, I'm following the same logic of no claims=must be roleblocking the kills=possible that brain was also roleblocked but not certain.

Bunny being roleblocked would have cleared him then?

[Chaqa]

We haven't had any roleblock claims so far, right?

Presumably they’ve been roleblocking their kills, but it’s possible bunny was roleblocked. I was so sure he was mafia I didn’t think about it.

Right, no, I understood your point, I'm following the same logic of no claims=must be roleblocking the kills=possible that brain was also roleblocked but not certain.

Bunny being roleblocked would have cleared him then?

Yeah, which is why I suspect he wasn't, but we'll not know til post-game I guess.

[pyxxy]

Okay yeah, maybe, but then we're also waiting for a roleblock cc, I think.

[pyxxy]

Eh okay but then we're sort of back where we started, the roleblock claim is 100% believable but scum!bunny and his teammate certainly think about that during the night time and probably just roleblock bunny to make it real. Idk if rb could have been self-target but either way partner carries the kill so it doesn't matter?

Anyways, that's dead mech. Maybe a more helpful thought is that I consider this unlikely because brain is dead. But I do think we need to think about which scum pair would believe brain's claim, or at least believe it enough to kill him.

[Foxcastle]

##GM NOTE: Just a reminder that Night 4 ends in just under 40 minutes!

[pyxxy]

Eh okay but then we're sort of back where we started, the roleblock claim is 100% believable but scum!bunny and his teammate certainly think about that during the night time and probably just roleblock bunny to make it real. Idk if rb could have been self-target but either way partner carries the kill so it doesn't matter?

Anyways, that's dead mech. Maybe a more helpful thought is that I consider this unlikely because brain is dead. But I do think we need to think about which scum pair would believe brain's claim, or at least believe it enough to kill him.

I'm re-reading brainbomb from post-tie and I did realize that I don't want to minimize that he scumread me + paired me with Flum as his final (imo serious) legacy post

WIth twenty minutes remaining, Flum made no effort to leave any reads. He asked bunny to doc claim and said if you doc claim I will unvote you. (now granted I also did this at one point so this is not a talking point exclusive to flum)

as time waned down flum offered to self vote if bunny claimed doc, and then did not do so when it did actually happen.

during this time I think the posts by pyxxy spell it out

Ah, and here's this post. It makes more sense in context after Chaqa's bunny/pyxxy (that's me) bussing post.

Do you see how this makes you and bunny look though?

You say this and you're voting bona with him?

Y'all look paired.

Obviously I've paid way more attention to bunny this game than you but I think that you're in the possible pairs that Chaqa posted? So.....yeah. If you're town, figure out if bunny is fooling you or not. Don't do this weird voting for scum bussing pass nonsense. You have time. Solve the game.

pyxxy sees flum might die, and claims that bunny and flum are paired.

uh sure ##VOTE damo

So why does pyxxy go damo instead?

requoting this becuase this is the only post I have made this game that I actually care about. this is what I leave you with. Make the right decision

I know I responded to this earlier when I woke up and logged on but it feels wrong not to mention here given I'm thinking about why brain died, probably up until EON.

[pyxxy]

Was it ever discussed if Eden was PR hunted?

Yea Eden played well and that kill makes sense. He was never gonna be daykilled after how much ghug tried to push that avenue

I just went through D3 and this post from brain seemed like the only NKA that I could find. Kinda ironic given N2's ruckus about NKA

I don't think he was, I think Eden died for being solidly town, but just making sure we're all working from the same place or at least discussing differences tomorrow. I do think we can at least say that RDR was a PR hunt at this point, I remember that discussion pretty well.

[Chaqa]

Was it ever discussed if Eden was PR hunted?

Yea Eden played well and that kill makes sense. He was never gonna be daykilled after how much ghug tried to push that avenue

I just went through D3 and this post from brain seemed like the only NKA that I could find. Kinda ironic given N2's ruckus about NKA

I don't think he was, I think Eden died for being solidly town, but just making sure we're all working from the same place or at least discussing differences tomorrow. I do think we can at least say that RDR was a PR hunt at this point, I remember that discussion pretty well.

The Eden kill is perplexing and my best theory so far is Bona thought he was screwed because it's like him+Flum and wanted to kill Eden for fun.

[pyxxy]

Was it ever discussed if Eden was PR hunted?

Yea Eden played well and that kill makes sense. He was never gonna be daykilled after how much ghug tried to push that avenue

I just went through D3 and this post from brain seemed like the only NKA that I could find. Kinda ironic given N2's ruckus about NKA

I don't think he was, I think Eden died for being solidly town, but just making sure we're all working from the same place or at least discussing differences tomorrow. I do think we can at least say that RDR was a PR hunt at this point, I remember that discussion pretty well.

The Eden kill is perplexing and my best theory so far is Bona thought he was screwed because it's like him+Flum and wanted to kill Eden for fun.

That's where you remember Eden's reads ending up?

[pyxxy]

to be clear I'm gonna go re-read Eden but also worth knowing what you remember as important vs what the thread said to help inform both sides

[Chaqa]

Was it ever discussed if Eden was PR hunted?



I just went through D3 and this post from brain seemed like the only NKA that I could find. Kinda ironic given N2's ruckus about NKA

I don't think he was, I think Eden died for being solidly town, but just making sure we're all working from the same place or at least discussing differences tomorrow. I do think we can at least say that RDR was a PR hunt at this point, I remember that discussion pretty well.

The Eden kill is perplexing and my best theory so far is Bona thought he was screwed because it's like him+Flum and wanted to kill Eden for fun.

That's where you remember Eden's reads ending up?

Whose reads?

[pyxxy]

way too early EON because I’m not waking up for this lol.

I understand the sentiment that someone probably must have bussed ghug, but I have bozo and Chaqa as unimpeachable towncore, so FMPOV, either pyx and/or Bunny are mafia, or the sentiment is wrong.

Outside those voters are Flum, damo, brain, Jamie, and Bona. brain is also unimpeachable to me. I kind of like Flum’s posting in parts but unsure if he leaves POE for it. damo seems sus, Bona and Jamie are solid when here but aren’t here often

I’m passing out as I type so goodnight and may this aid you

Eden's pre-death reads ^

it was a different time and yet....it was the same time :/

hm

[pyxxy]

I meant it more like, "oh, Eden had bona in his solve? I kinda remember that but lemme double check what Eden had to say on Flum too"

[bozotheclown]

I am OK assuming Bonatogether and damo are the last mafia. If Bonatogether had not tied the vote, damo would have been eliminated, and Bonatogether was already under pressure D3, so preventing the damo DK, which cost town a mis-kill, was probably the best mafia play in that situation. Also, there is no good town explanation for it, and I did not find it particularly believable when Bonatogether said he thought there was still time left to break the tie.