M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[summit_fever]

Terrible. Would have been nice if Bismarck did something prior to a full blooded claim with less than 10 minutes to go and no viable alternative wagon. I wasn't going to vote EMC. I can't articulate why, but lynching EMC just seemed silly.

I agree with Vecna. Please try to keep things more concise. This was a stultifying day.

[xorxes]

Well, guess it's now time to pick out who voted Bismarck because they scumread him and who did it to save me

Why would you find that interesting?

[Jamiet99uk]

How is there any guarantee whatsoever that EMC is town?

Let's spend the next 72 hours talking about it again.

PLEASE GOD NO

We won't have to if you can give a clear and persuasive answer to my question. Why should we assume EMC is town? What happened at EoD that you think proves this?

[Jamiet99uk]

Well, guess it's now time to pick out who voted Bismarck because they scumread him and who did it to save me

Yes. We should indeed do that.

[Jamiet99uk]

Well, guess it's now time to pick out who voted Bismarck because they scumread him and who did it to save me

Why would you find that interesting?

Why wouldn't you?

[Chaqa]

Well, guess it's now time to pick out who voted Bismarck because they scumread him and who did it to save me

Yes. We should indeed do that.

Assuming EMC is town, what would this tell us?

Assuming EMC is scum, what would this tell us?

[Chaqa]

The way EoD happened strongly makes me think it was TvT, though.

[Vecna]

if EMC is scum here he's really putting in a very solid performance

[rdrivera2005]

Sorry Bismarck, the result was pretty bad for town, it was a really powerful role.
And we will have more one long day discussing EMC if he can't provide some info after this night.
Will cook dinner, back later.

[e.m.c^42]

Well, guess it's now time to pick out who voted Bismarck because they scumread him and who did it to save me

Why would you find that interesting?

Isn't this your area of expertise lol

But it occurred to me because I was townreading him, but out of lack of counterwagons voted.

[xorxes]

Well, guess it's now time to pick out who voted Bismarck because they scumread him and who did it to save me

Why would you find that interesting?

Why wouldn't you?

I would. I was wondering why emc would, since from his perspective it would have been town vs town, no?

[Jamiet99uk]

@Chaqa: A mislynch just happened.

Why are you so strongly opposed to looking into the motivations of the people who participated in the mislynch?

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa: A mislynch just happened.

Why are you so strongly opposed to looking into the motivations of the people who participated in the mislynch?

"strongly opposed"?

You like to put words in people's mouths

[xorxes]

Well, guess it's now time to pick out who voted Bismarck because they scumread him and who did it to save me

Why would you find that interesting?

Isn't this your area of expertise lol

But it occurred to me because I was townreading him, but out of lack of counterwagons voted.

Asking me why you would find it interesting is kind of evasive.

You said it was time to pick out who was trying to save you and who was scumreading Bismarck, but if you are town that would not tell you very much. Town could be doing either one and still be towny. Scum would not care much about the result.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Chaqa: A mislynch just happened.

Why are you so strongly opposed to looking into the motivations of the people who participated in the mislynch?

"strongly opposed"?

You like to put words in people's mouths

I am not attempting to misrepresent you. From my perspective, EMC said we should look into the people who voted for Bismarck, I agreed with him, and you immediately jumped in and questioned it.

Please clarify what your position is, then?

[e.m.c^42]

if EMC is scum here he's really putting in a very solid performance

If I am this good and dedicated as scum, I'd get always lynched in my town games lol

[e.m.c^42]

Why would you find that interesting?

Isn't this your area of expertise lol

But it occurred to me because I was townreading him, but out of lack of counterwagons voted.

Asking me why you would find it interesting is kind of evasive.

You said it was time to pick out who was trying to save you and who was scumreading Bismarck, but if you are town that would not tell you very much. Town could be doing either one and still be towny. Scum would not care much about the result.

Huh? I didn't ask you why you found it interesting? You were the one to ask me.

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa: A mislynch just happened.

Why are you so strongly opposed to looking into the motivations of the people who participated in the mislynch?

"strongly opposed"?

You like to put words in people's mouths

I am not attempting to misrepresent you. From my perspective, EMC said we should look into the people who voted for Bismarck, I agreed with him, and you immediately jumped in and questioned it.

Please clarify what your position is, then?

Assuming EMC is town, what would this tell us?

Assuming EMC is scum, what would this tell us?

This is indeed me questioning, I'm wondering what sort of information you think to find? I didn't shut down the discussion, I'm furthering it?

Why are you so strongly in favor of casting shade on and misinterpreting me?

[xorxes]

Isn't this your area of expertise lol

But it occurred to me because I was townreading him, but out of lack of counterwagons voted.

Asking me why you would find it interesting is kind of evasive.

You said it was time to pick out who was trying to save you and who was scumreading Bismarck, but if you are town that would not tell you very much. Town could be doing either one and still be towny. Scum would not care much about the result.

Huh? I didn't ask you why you found it interesting? You were the one to ask me.

Yes, and you said it was my area of expertise, as if I should be answering for you why you would find it interesting.

[e.m.c^42]

But also because it was so close it tells us at least reads. Scum already know I'm tracker so obviously they'd prefer me to die over an unknown, if that makes sense?

Dunno, this is not something I do often.