Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[Maniac]

Technically we could force a win.

Tell unclears not to post and vote. If one does shoot them. If they don’t they’re modkilled.

I’m not suggesting this. Just saying. We should win/lose fairly.

[Fluminator]

Probably not a good idea for me to be in lylo, so unless you're reasonable sure someone else is scum, my slot should probably be removed today.

Not really playing against my win condition, because it's genuinely anti-town for someone who hasn't read the game to be in one of the most important positions at the end of the game.

[DemonRHK]

I don't have it.

I set the wine up and assumed the gf wouldn't have the fucking balls to kill reedeer. We both knew it's how I got Balki. I was wrong, or they wanted to get it over with.

I made the posts at start of day to bait the concede. It's dirty, but I tried it anyway.

bozo's no post leave him as top suspect. Vash's reaction make him second.

Reedeer gunned Tom, so he wants Vash dead.

Tom, I request you shoot bozo. If we are wrong, we will hang/hammer Vash per reedeer's wishes.

If we're still wrong...then it's you two against Flum and Fox, and a No Lynch is pointless. 3 clear vs 4 unclears, and we get to kill 3, we've got the odds in our favor.

I may have very well thrown a second game as PR, and I'm sorry.

[Maniac]

Day One Vote Count FINAL

Jamiet99uk (9): DemonRHK, brainbomb, ND, snowy801, rdrivera2005, reedeer1, Balki Bartokomous, yavuzovic, VashtaNeurotic
ND (4): bozotheclown, Rjmcf, Foxcastle, thamrick,
Balki Bartokomous (3): MeanLaQueefa, Maniac, Jamiet99uk
DemonRHK (2): Tom Bombadil, Ezio
brainbomb (1): bo_sox48
yavuzovic (1): dargorygel

Final D2 Vote Count:
Rjmcf (8): Tom Bombadil, Foxcastle, ND, VashtaNeurotic, rdrivera2005, Maniac, Ezio, brainbomb
VashtaNeurotic (5): DemonRHK, Balki Bartokomous, bozotheclown, MeanLaQueefa, thamrick
ND (2): bo_sox48, yavuzovic
Ezio (2): reedeer1, captainmeme/flum
Tom Bombadil (1): Rjmcf

D3 meaningless
FINAL DAY 4 VOTE COUNT

bo_sox48 (8): thamrick, reedeer1, Balki Bartokomous, Tom Bombadil, Yoyoyozo/flum, Maniac, Foxcastle, Bo_Sox
MeanLaQueefa (2): rdrivera2005 Bozotheclown
rdrivera2005 (1): DemonRHK
Balki Bartokomous (1): MeanLaQueefa
thamrick (1): VashtaNeurotic

D5 Vote Count Final:

rdrivera2005 (5): Maniac, reedeer1, DemonRHK, Fluminator, Balki Bartokomous
Balki Bartokomous (4): MeanLaQueefa, Foxcastle, bozotheclown, Tom Bombadil,
bozotheclown (1): VashtaNeurotic
Foxcastle (1): rdrivera2005

Night 5 has begun. You have 24 hours.

D6 meaningless

@Tom - I'd still be surprised if vash is scum. If he is he has played the role excellently. In addition do we really think I 'guessed' two leading scum out on D2 RJCMF and Vash and we had scum v scum lynch? It didn't feel like that at the time. Why didn't the third person in my short-list get any votes; town Yavuz?

My money is on Foxtail or bozo.

Let's shoot one early and then do some proper detective work based on max info and a narrowed down field.

[Maniac]

Oh just for the record...

I shot Ezio. I kept it hidden as I didn't want scum to know when the gun had come into play. I suspected either reedeer1 or Balki as being the GS and wondered if scum would NK one of those unclears at some point. Hence why I thought Balki was a bad lynch. Reading Themrick later it was obv that he had protected reedeer1 on D1. I may have contributed to Themrick's death. When I thought he could be VT, I withheld my info about Ezio so they'd think Themrick was GS. I don't know if they knew he was Doc or if they were going for GS. It was a ballsy kill anyway unless they had stalker info.

Scum have actually done really well in picking off our Oracle, COP, Doc and GS. Fair play to them.

[Maniac]

@tom - don't shoot Flum because he doesn't want to be in the end game. If it goes the distance we have a clear in the last day and they (you or I) will decide the lynch.

[Maniac]

Just a note for last few days. No one should be hammering.

[bozotheclown]

I still do not trust the dargorygel/captainmeme/Yoyoyozo/Fluminator slot, no matter how many times someone occupying that slot tells us they are VT. However, I think Foxcastle is the most likely remaining scum. He has played another great game, but the fact that he has done little to look suspicious could be the result of knowing everyone’s alignment. It is difficult as town to not accidentally do some things that look suspicious.

[Hellenic Riot]

With the conspiracy slowly being unmasked, the nefarious plans of Judge Doom are brought to the fore. In a final showdown, he reveals his ploy to drown Toontown in Dip and replace it with a giant superhighway - truly a looney idea. The remaining toons are having none of it, though, and after a duel featuring singing swords and giant bulldozers, Judge Doom's inner toon is revealed! Still unperturbed, a shot rings out, and his dip spills on him, defeating him forever. Roger Rabbit has been saved, and Marvin Acme's will discovered. Toontown will belong to the Toons!


Bozotheclown has died. He was Judge Doom, the Godfather.

Mafia 34 is over! Town Win!

[Hellenic Riot]

Whoops, damn Bot commands.

GAME IS OVER

God QT: https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/Xe62zjXhC6a
Info QT: https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/ma8VnbGRFWZqZ
Mafia QT: https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/VdZg8UUe53si

Congratulations to town for such a strong victory!

Thanks to RagingIke297 for being a great co-GM, and Jamiet99uk for stepping in and helping a couple of times when we were both unavailable. Hope you all enjoyed! :)

[reedeer1]

GG, I lost us auto when I forgot to gun one night, but good shot tom.

[dargorygel]

GG everyone. I am sorry that RL took a nose dive and that I felt I needed to leave and start a string of replacements. The irony was that I had decided to NOT lurk this game. I started taking part on D1... and left not because I would never be on, but that I knew I would have to lurk to get through the first week. And then the replacements lurked after all! C'est la Vie... And I had the vest!!!!??!!! Thanks to Cap'n Meme and Yoyo and Flum. But thanks to HR and Ike for running a smooth game.

[yavuzovic]

Good game!
Even though I played really bad, you won. I'm not planning to join next game. However I will follow it. Thanks and best regards.

[Tom Bombadil]

Good game everyone.

I think we (town) played very well, though I think there is some luck that we managed to have two scum wagons D1. As much as I think there is some skill in that, I do think it can be pretty random.

Thanks GMs for running (and backup GM Jamie for helping)

I think scum's biggest mistake was not claiming PRs the first two nights to either force mislynches out of fear, or force counterclaims. Our PRs did a great job in general.

It was a fun one!

[reedeer1]

Good game!
Even though I played really bad, you won. I'm not planning to join next game. However I will follow it. Thanks and best regards.

Yav, please play more, each time you play, we get better at knowing your playstyle and can misslynch you less.

[Foxcastle]

Good game, all! Thanks to HR and RagingIke (and Jamiet) for running the thing.

[DemonRHK]

Don’t beat yourself up ya I. At least you didn’t whiff watcher 5 out of 6 nights and panic claim.

Wp everyone

[DemonRHK]

That should said don’t beat yourself up yavu

[reedeer1]

Did anyone catch my breadcrumbs? The first letter of each of my post. D1 spells somthing. I thought brainbomb had, but when I used the same to tell him I was rb he didn’t claim RB, so I don’t know. I also thought Balki had, but reading the mafia QT I see it was a lucky guess.

[brainbomb]

DILLY DILLY
BORK
BORK
BORK DILLY
DILLY DILLY DILLY!