webdiplomacy.net

yavuzovic wrote: ↑

Wed Oct 03, 2018 4:15 pm

I really didn't like Squigs' reads list. If he is scum, his partner is probably Jammie

That seems idiotic

Official Judgmental Voting Adjustment
##Count 1.7

Squigs44 (4) Jamiet99uk. Bozotheclown, Nephthys, damo666
Bozotheclown (2) squigs44, brainbomb
ChippeRock (2) DrCJG, DemonRHK
Jaime99uk(1) ChippeRock,

Unvote: yavuzovic

The hangman keeps measuring out his ropes. Squigs44 is set to be lynched in 5.75 hours.

Not yet voted, and in danger of their immortal souls being cast out into the shades of darkness (although there are almost 10 hours (math double checked) left before they are in REAL danger… but the situation might be getting dire… No… it IS getting dire…)
worcej, Yoyozozo,

Chippee is not scum.

I could be talked into a RHK or DRCjc lynch

@bb do you think they wanted to lynch a newbie?

Is this why they selected chippe

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Wed Oct 03, 2018 4:18 pm

Chippee is not scum.

I could be talked into a RHK or DRCjc lynch

Why are you suddenly down for someone you're net positive and indifferent on, for voting someone you've been indifferent on? That's wildly out of the blue after the vote count, even for you brain.

DurgaRHK's analysis appears right to me.

As DRHK has said, but just to summarise, in the course of a *single* post, ChippeRock:

1. Accused me of being scum for, he claimed, jumping on Squiggs because it was "an easy wagon" (ignoring the fact that I created and pushed that wagon),

2. Declared that he scumread Squigs himself.

So, ChippeRock, you think I'm scum for hopping onto the easy mislynch of someone...that...you....uuhhh.....claim to scumread

If he *actually* scumreads both me and Squigs in that situation, he would accuse me of bussing my scum-mate, but you'll notice he didn't actually do that. Therefore we can conclude that either (a) one or both of his stated scumreads is insincere, or (b) he knows that one of me or Squigs is not scum.

If it's (a) that's fairly scummy, and if it's (b) he's scum for sure.

##VOTE CHIPPEROCK

yavuzovic wrote: ↑

Wed Oct 03, 2018 4:15 pm

I really didn't like Squigs' reads list. If he is scum, his partner is probably Jammie

Why didn't you like them, and how would Jamie be my scum partner?

ретегвот соме васк ше иееδ уоц
@Squigs, I only didn't like your Jamie reads. They feel like forced reads. Like you tried to find a way to make him look clear.
I don't find a reason for scum to clear Jamie-scumfriend at this point. He wasn't even accused.
I felt that, and I'm not voting for you, because I don't have a concrete evidence.

Im looking at game flow. I dont care how my 180ing makes me look-ever- straight up ever.

Game flow looks suspicious. Rhk and cjgc are just on the sidelines too much as all this plays out. Chippee has done nothing scummy

@Yav - I understand your question was directed at BB and you may still want to hear his perspective... however...

No, I was not trying to lynch a newbie... I am voting for the player who I believe is most likely to be scum. He had been a limited poster then jumped in with some very poor logic and OMGUS against Squiggs and Jamie. (Admittedly, it was unclear to me that he was so new until his recent post indicating he had only been in 1 game. I will reread based on this, but his shade throwing tone, his logical fallacies, and his lack of substance still land him at the top of my lynch pool)

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Wed Oct 03, 2018 4:48 pm

Im looking at game flow. I dont care how my 180ing makes me look-ever- straight up ever.

Game flow looks suspicious. Rhk and cjgc are just on the sidelines too much as all this plays out. Chippee has done nothing scummy

I've literally explained the scummy thing he did, here on this page. DRHK has too.

Please explain why the things we've highlighted are not scummy?

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Wed Oct 03, 2018 4:48 pm

Im looking at game flow. I dont care how my 180ing makes me look-ever- straight up ever.

Game flow looks suspicious. Rhk and cjgc are just on the sidelines too much as all this plays out. Chippee has done nothing scummy

I doubt both rhk and cjg are scum, they likely wouldn't push together like this. I can see where you are coming from, but I think they are genuine. Neither of them have played with ChippeRock before, and he has been doing scummier things. Something to remember, but not lynch-worthy for sure.

Note:

ChippeRock is newish *here* but before he joined (and cheated in, and forced the abandonment of) that recent game, he stated he was familiar with Mafia / Werewolf, just hadn't played it here. He shouldn't be written off as a newb.

This makes his failure to accuse me of bussing Squigs, despite claiming to scumread us both, make him seem even more scummy.

Moreover, when questioned by DRHK, Chippe claimed he had been scumreading me and Squigs at different times.

This was incorrect and looks like back-pedalling.

He scumread us both IN THE SAME POST, and then denied it.

Tell me this isn't scummy?

I’ve been in a frenzy about flying out to DC this week so I haven’t read anything yet. Want to get my vote in just in a case and on my break I’ll catch up

Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑

Wed Oct 03, 2018 5:06 pm

Moreover, when questioned by DRHK, Chippe claimed he had been scumreading me and Squigs at different times.

This was incorrect and looks like back-pedalling.

He scumread us both IN THE SAME POST, and then denied it.

Tell me this isn't scummy?

Youre scumreading him for not accusing you of bussing -simply because he has you both as scum-.

NEXT

(As in whats the next bs reason for scumreading chippee)

DemonRHK wrote: ↑

Wed Oct 03, 2018 2:05 pm

I'm going to come in with a ##Vote Chippe.

The last post voting Jamie felt awful. He scumreads Jamie, then scumreads Squigs, THEN uses Squigs' post to confirm a scumread of Jamie. You don't scumread, then use your scumread as evidence in the same fucking post. It's an incredibly obvious confirmation bias.

... thats how most of webdip plays.

##Vote yavuz

I like this better. Hes playing exactly how he did last game