MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[brainbomb]

I feel like you are misrepresenting my post to say that im advocating a sloppy ramrod style of play. Like you wanna make it sound like im gonna just barrell through a bunch of inaccurate meta reads and that town will just arrive at accurate reads by playing very slow and itll just happen effortlessly

I'm saying townreading or scumreading someone off a single post is a stupid idea, especially when it could conceivably be made as either alignment.

it was easily 11 or more posts taken from 6 or 7 games. again this completely misses my point

[Hamilton Brian]

Let me just put this out there because I am curious... is there value to doing any role claims now? Later on?

[Vecna]

I think I'm town

Bona is once again his way too fluffy playstyle. Somewhat equating it to him being non-town by now

It's an early d1 offhand comment. You can't read anything into it.

Is that so?

[Vecna]

Bona is once again his way too fluffy playstyle. Somewhat equating it to him being non-town by now

It's an early d1 offhand comment. You can't read anything into it.

this implies you think Vecna is town, and an authority over public opinion.
Do you fear Vecna will sway the game his way?

I.....feel so pocketed already.

I should probably be terrified, but it feels like a warm blanket.

[foodcoats]

Scum tick. If you think player X is scum defending scum player Z, you should vote Z first, because X could be town defending scum incorrectly. Logically you should want to vote Macca, not bona.

That's actually a very interesting point. I hadn't considered that. I didn't find Macca's posts very interesting and had kind of "forgotten" them; it was bona that was "before my mind." In retrospect, Macca's posts were a little fluffy, as Macca dwelled on the flavour. Which is what I accused celaph of and linked to scumliness. So, hm.

Yeah, a good point, and I accept my flawed logic. Chaqa is Lord of Deduction for today.

bona still seems a good vote to keep a wagon.

LET'S SEE SOME MORE VOTES FROM THE PEANUT GALLERY PLOX AND THOX.

You can't actually agree and then not change your behavior without giving a reason as to why I'm still a good wagon.

To keep a two-voter rather than switching to Macca and generating a new one-vote wagon. Having some non-vanity wagons will help drive interesting play that can be analyzed later.

How would you conclude your disagreement with brainbomb? Do you think he is scummy concocting reasons to vote Macca - and then flipping that on yourself? Or do you think he's just misguided/incorrect town?

If you don't think brainbomb is scummy, who do you currently scumread? Who do you confidently townread? Don't worry, I understand it is the beginning of the game and those reads can be hazy and mutable. I'm just curious where you are at, based on the arguments flying around right now. Is there someone you would vote for right now?

[foodcoats]

@bona

Derp, I see you voted for celaph.

[Vecna]

It's an early d1 offhand comment. You can't read anything into it.

this implies you think Vecna is town, and an authority over public opinion.
Do you fear Vecna will sway the game his way?

Regardless of whether or not Vecna is town, there's no basis for making a read off of it.

Youre normally completely fine with it if I take a random D1 post of you and townread you for it though

[Bonatogether]

Bona is once again his way too fluffy playstyle. Somewhat equating it to him being non-town by now

It's an early d1 offhand comment. You can't read anything into it.

Is that so?

That is so

[Bonatogether]

this implies you think Vecna is town, and an authority over public opinion.
Do you fear Vecna will sway the game his way?

Regardless of whether or not Vecna is town, there's no basis for making a read off of it.

Youre normally completely fine with it if I take a random D1 post of you and townread you for it though

When was this?

[brainbomb]

I dont know who top town is right now from scums point of view. but it probably isnt kgray so far

[brainbomb]

maybe celaph, people love celly

[Vecna]

In honor of being a game regarding gods I'mma play PoE and murder the shit outta some gods, maybe even polay some Hades and see if I can actually get a run all the way through as well.

Here is a player really excited to play something else.

I mean, hades is pretty good

[brainbomb]

In honor of being a game regarding gods I'mma play PoE and murder the shit outta some gods, maybe even polay some Hades and see if I can actually get a run all the way through as well.

Here is a player really excited to play something else.

I mean, hades is pretty good

how much bread can one acquire in this hades you speak of

[Bonatogether]

You can't actually agree and then not change your behavior without giving a reason as to why I'm still a good wagon.

To keep a two-voter rather than switching to Macca and generating a new one-vote wagon. Having some non-vanity wagons will help drive interesting play that can be analyzed later.

How would you conclude your disagreement with brainbomb? Do you think he is scummy concocting reasons to vote Macca - and then flipping that on yourself? Or do you think he's just misguided/incorrect town?

If you don't think brainbomb is scummy, who do you currently scumread? Who do you confidently townread? Don't worry, I understand it is the beginning of the game and those reads can be hazy and mutable. I'm just curious where you are at, based on the arguments flying around right now. Is there someone you would vote for right now?

That's better, but feels concocted, imo.

I think brain is mildly scummy for it the whole thing.

I scumread you too, and I'm eyeing Chaqa as well.

[Vecna]

Brain, I tend to agree with your point, but also don't think Bona is scummy for this. Both sides of this argument seem reasonable to me.

Oh.

A chaqa post mediating a crapfest.

Interesting

[Bonatogether]

@bona

Derp, I see you voted for celaph.

[Chaqa]

Let me just put this out there because I am curious... is there value to doing any role claims now? Later on?

Ah, trying the "2 scummy 2 be scum" strategy.

Werewolf in sheep's clothing pretending to be a werewolf?

[Chaqa]

That's actually a very interesting point. I hadn't considered that. I didn't find Macca's posts very interesting and had kind of "forgotten" them; it was bona that was "before my mind." In retrospect, Macca's posts were a little fluffy, as Macca dwelled on the flavour. Which is what I accused celaph of and linked to scumliness. So, hm.

Yeah, a good point, and I accept my flawed logic. Chaqa is Lord of Deduction for today.

bona still seems a good vote to keep a wagon.

LET'S SEE SOME MORE VOTES FROM THE PEANUT GALLERY PLOX AND THOX.

You can't actually agree and then not change your behavior without giving a reason as to why I'm still a good wagon.

To keep a two-voter rather than switching to Macca and generating a new one-vote wagon. Having some non-vanity wagons will help drive interesting play that can be analyzed later.

How would you conclude your disagreement with brainbomb? Do you think he is scummy concocting reasons to vote Macca - and then flipping that on yourself? Or do you think he's just misguided/incorrect town?

If you don't think brainbomb is scummy, who do you currently scumread? Who do you confidently townread? Don't worry, I understand it is the beginning of the game and those reads can be hazy and mutable. I'm just curious where you are at, based on the arguments flying around right now. Is there someone you would vote for right now?

As if a two-vote wagon on Day 1 means anything.

Yeah, I think I've found my first sus.

##Vote foodcoats

[Vecna]

This is a scumtell from you bona. for a number of reasons.

but the most important reason is that you are fighting tooth and nail to keep a player as a null when you should be seeking to prove that player is town or scum by any means necessary.

this arbitrary use if logic and judgement mirrors how you played as scum in m64 where you would argue just for the sake of asinine page filling arguments.

##vote bona

This looks like some classic TvT to me. But it is also interesting that Bona wants to defend Macca so hard... I would expect town to flip it and say brain is scum fabricating a reason to vote, rather than defending.

Macca and Bona scum team?

##VOTE bonatogether

Scum tick. If you think player X is scum defending scum player Z, you should vote Z first, because X could be town defending scum incorrectly. Logically you should want to vote Macca, not bona.

Why is town wrongfully defending scum more common than scum white knighting though?

[Vecna]

and just so the question doesn't get lost:

DemonRHK how do you plan to get this bread while binge playing Path of Exile?

PATH OF EXILE

even better than hades

(yes im an addict to that one)