MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[Jamiet99uk]

##GM NOTE: In this case, the tracker would be notified that Player A visited Player B. The driver does not change who a player visits.

Lol the GM-ing of this game is so non-standard. Wacky stuff.

[Jamiet99uk]

The driver literally changes who a player visits. That's the whole exact thing a Driver does.

W.T.F., GM's.

[Bonatogether]

if we assume there can only be two prs (what i've been operating on) sweet and i are different alignments

[sweetandcool]

The driver literally changes who a player visits. That's the whole exact thing a Driver does.

W.T.F., GM's.

I did finally checked out other pages on the website they linked in the rules. I could not find a driver role or any mention of it on JOAT.

So I don't know what is standard, but there interpretation makes sense to me.

Tracker is tracking mafia goon, not driven player. So tracker actually sees who mafia goon visited, even though mafia goons visit is a kill action that ends up applying to the other driven player.


You could imagine that Tracker sees mafia goon visit sweetandcool's apartment, but Dousing actually is at sweetandcool's apartment and sweetabdcool isn't home right now.

[sweetandcool]

if we assume there can only be two prs (what i've been operating on) sweet and i are different alignments

Exactly, which y'all seem so inclined to believe. I hope someone is at least considering we have three powers.

[sweetandcool]

if we assume there can only be two prs (what i've been operating on) sweet and i are different alignments

Exactly, which y'all seem so inclined to believe. I hope someone is at least considering we have three powers.

But since I firmly believe Bona is tracker, I know there are three town powers.

[rdrivera2005]

if we assume there can only be two prs (what i've been operating on) sweet and i are different alignments

Exactly, which y'all seem so inclined to believe. I hope someone is at least considering we have three powers.

Something we knew: Eden was goon and believed Chaqa claim. This makes Chaqa top on the list of townies (hint to Sweet...).

It also means Eden either know Bona is scum or that he was hoping Bona was the Traitor and will confirm his RB.

Anyway, I think Bona should consider tracking Sweet if he doesn't have a strong guess on the Mafia doing the NK.

[Chaqa]

if we assume there can only be two prs (what i've been operating on) sweet and i are different alignments

Exactly, which y'all seem so inclined to believe. I hope someone is at least considering we have three powers.

Something we knew: Eden was goon and believed Chaqa claim. This makes Chaqa top on the list of townies (hint to Sweet...).

It also means Eden either know Bona is scum or that he was hoping Bona was the Traitor and will confirm his RB.

Anyway, I think Bona should consider tracking Sweet if he doesn't have a strong guess on the Mafia doing the NK.

That's been my read of the situation too. I don't think mafia recruited the Traitor. I think they took the JOAT upgrade and that may be it.

[sweetandcool]

Exactly, which y'all seem so inclined to believe. I hope someone is at least considering we have three powers.

Something we knew: Eden was goon and believed Chaqa claim. This makes Chaqa top on the list of townies (hint to Sweet...).

It also means Eden either know Bona is scum or that he was hoping Bona was the Traitor and will confirm his RB.

Anyway, I think Bona should consider tracking Sweet if he doesn't have a strong guess on the Mafia doing the NK.

That's been my read of the situation too. I don't think mafia recruited the Traitor. I think they took the JOAT upgrade and that may be it.

So how do you feel about the tie we had the other day? Bona was self-voting and peeled some people off of me. Then at the last moment Bona was flopping between self at Eden.

I interpreted their behavior as wanting to resolve the Eden vs. Bona situation, but also not wanting to die because they know they are legit.

Yes, Chaqa and Bona are hard town reads for me. I can't believe Bona is not legit.

[Chaqa]

Something we knew: Eden was goon and believed Chaqa claim. This makes Chaqa top on the list of townies (hint to Sweet...).

It also means Eden either know Bona is scum or that he was hoping Bona was the Traitor and will confirm his RB.

Anyway, I think Bona should consider tracking Sweet if he doesn't have a strong guess on the Mafia doing the NK.

That's been my read of the situation too. I don't think mafia recruited the Traitor. I think they took the JOAT upgrade and that may be it.

So how do you feel about the tie we had the other day? Bona was self-voting and peeled some people off of me. Then at the last moment Bona was flopping between self at Eden.

I interpreted their behavior as wanting to resolve the Eden vs. Bona situation, but also not wanting to die because they know they are legit.

Yes, Chaqa and Bona are hard town reads for me. I can't believe Bona is not legit.

I'm not sure really. I think that the fact he never voted for you is consistent with him wanting to resolve the 50/50. His N1 no result on Eden is odd, but I could see the mafia using N1 JOAT Ninja ability to ensure they aren't caught early on.

[sweetandcool]

That's been my read of the situation too. I don't think mafia recruited the Traitor. I think they took the JOAT upgrade and that may be it.

So how do you feel about the tie we had the other day? Bona was self-voting and peeled some people off of me. Then at the last moment Bona was flopping between self at Eden.

I interpreted their behavior as wanting to resolve the Eden vs. Bona situation, but also not wanting to die because they know they are legit.

Yes, Chaqa and Bona are hard town reads for me. I can't believe Bona is not legit.

I'm not sure really. I think that the fact he never voted for you is consistent with him wanting to resolve the 50/50. His N1 no result on Eden is odd, but I could see the mafia using N1 JOAT Ninja ability to ensure they aren't caught early on.

That's a good question, can JOAT still perform the factional kill or are they limited to their three one-shots? Because other than recruiting the traitor, that would only leave Eden as the killer each night (or JOAT using ability).

[Chaqa]

Reviewing D1, I'm pretty sure Damo is town after all. Eden seemed fine with killing him.

[Chaqa]

Reviewing D1, I'm pretty sure Damo is town after all. Eden seemed fine with killing him.

Following up on this, I wonder if he attempted to repeat his "roleblock traitor test" that I suspect he did with Bona, but with Damo.

Basically seeing if either would cover for him.

[sweetandcool]

Reviewing D1, I'm pretty sure Damo is town after all. Eden seemed fine with killing him.

Following up on this, I wonder if he attempted to repeat his "roleblock traitor test" that I suspect he did with Bona, but with Damo.

Basically seeing if either would cover for him.

That makes sense to me. So soft confirms Damo as town.

[Chaqa]

Reviewing D1, I'm pretty sure Damo is town after all. Eden seemed fine with killing him.

Following up on this, I wonder if he attempted to repeat his "roleblock traitor test" that I suspect he did with Bona, but with Damo.

Basically seeing if either would cover for him.

That makes sense to me. So soft confirms Damo as town.

Unfortunately, I don't know if we can truly clear anyone.

[sweetandcool]

Following up on this, I wonder if he attempted to repeat his "roleblock traitor test" that I suspect he did with Bona, but with Damo.

Basically seeing if either would cover for him.

That makes sense to me. So soft confirms Damo as town.

Unfortunately, I don't know if we can truly clear anyone.

Yes, but that's most always the case anyways.

Town:

Chaqa (fake claim ploy exposed Eden, seemed like a very genuine exposure).
Bona (argument and actions against Eden seemed genuine, also made claim [Eden visited sweetandcool] that most people assumed was mechanically impossible which is unlike Bona)

Soft, soft Town:

Damo (I think Chaqa is right here)

[Jamiet99uk]

if we assume there can only be two prs (what i've been operating on) sweet and i are different alignments

Exactly, which y'all seem so inclined to believe. I hope someone is at least considering we have three powers.

Something we knew: Eden was goon and believed Chaqa claim. This makes Chaqa top on the list of townies (hint to Sweet...).

It also means Eden either know Bona is scum or that he was hoping Bona was the Traitor and will confirm his RB.

Anyway, I think Bona should consider tracking Sweet if he doesn't have a strong guess on the Mafia doing the NK.

Or Eden and Chaqa were scum working together.

[Chaqa]

I think the most reasonable take for that scenario would be if I were the traitor

[Jamiet99uk]

I think the most reasonable take for that scenario would be if I were the traitor

Are you the traitor?

[Chaqa]

I wish