M73 - Fowl Play - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

the best compliment I can give sabi about this game compared to the scumgame is that every 4th post is not to tell us theyre on their way to the dentist or that some drama happened on some other server or that something outside the game is more important.

they arent using out of game crap to evade the thread

Partially this could be due to Sabi having started a new job and therefore simply having less time to get caught up in Discord drama.

[Chaqa]

Scumpool: (ranked so that bottom are more preferred votes)
rdrivera2005
ghug
pyxxy
Maniac
BusinessLamp
TheFlyingBoat
celaph

it seems like the only reason for your suspicion of me is potential association with celaph. Why would I be a preferred vote for you if that’s the case?

Well, I wouldn't vote you before we vote our celaph or TFB, is what I was trying to demonstrate.

[worcej]

wrinkles can be ironed out. you can remove the habit of always claiming to be so overwhelmed on some other server and replace it with a tedious spreadsheet that creates a false narrative that talking incessantly to every person and asking them 60 million questions = townyness

To clarify: are you saying there is potential that Sabi is replacing the distancing employed last time as scum by focusing on a spreadsheet and random questions?

[Jamiet99uk]

As usual, we have an opposite opinion: I think celaph is the better info flip.

Celaph's result would help shine some light onto Maniac, Chaqa, Jamie, bozo, sabi, and TFB in my views of EOD1.

What would flipping Celaph tell you about moi?

That you potentially saved him D1. I don't easily see why you would've picked Kak over him when untieing the vote.

It doesn't auto-lock you as scum, but it makes the potential much higher.

Do you recall me giving a reason?

Have you forgotten it, or do you just not believe it?

[Chaqa]

Oh, and also ##Vote TheFlyingBoat

[President Eden]

the QRD (and then I REALLY REALLY need to get something done today smh) on where I’m at:

I do think Kak died as a result of mafia saving a teammate.
Decreasingly I think that teammate was celaph. Increasingly I think it was Boat. Not to dictate what anybody does, but it would be really helpful if we knew both of their alignments by the start of the next day. I had intended to take care of that myself… but I strongly doubt I’ll be allowed to do so now.

But regardless, some considerations:
• if celaph is mafia and Boat is town, Chaqa’s analysis on celaph being mafia is very strong.
• if Boat is mafia and celaph is town, then I think Maniac is also suspicious for reasons spelled out by Demon and Lamp. incidentally I think both of those guys are town for spelling that out.
• if they’re BOTH mafia… idk man that’s wild.
• if they’re both town then oops lol. Maniac can still be sus here but I would re-examine everything if that’s so.

[worcej]

What would flipping Celaph tell you about moi?

That you potentially saved him D1. I don't easily see why you would've picked Kak over him when untieing the vote.

It doesn't auto-lock you as scum, but it makes the potential much higher.

Do you recall me giving a reason?

Have you forgotten it, or do you just not believe it?

I wasn't here for D1 - I didn't know I was subbed in until N1 and even then was not available to really give this game attention until yesterday.

[brainbomb]

the QRD (and then I REALLY REALLY need to get something done today smh) on where I’m at:

I do think Kak died as a result of mafia saving a teammate.
Decreasingly I think that teammate was celaph. Increasingly I think it was Boat. Not to dictate what anybody does, but it would be really helpful if we knew both of their alignments by the start of the next day. I had intended to take care of that myself… but I strongly doubt I’ll be allowed to do so now.

But regardless, some considerations:
• if celaph is mafia and Boat is town, Chaqa’s analysis on celaph being mafia is very strong.
• if Boat is mafia and celaph is town, then I think Maniac is also suspicious for reasons spelled out by Demon and Lamp. incidentally I think both of those guys are town for spelling that out.
• if they’re BOTH mafia… idk man that’s wild.
• if they’re both town then oops lol. Maniac can still be sus here but I would re-examine everything if that’s so.

OH

[damo666]

As usual, we have an opposite opinion: I think celaph is the better info flip.

Celaph's result would help shine some light onto Maniac, Chaqa, Jamie, bozo, sabi, and TFB in my views of EOD1.

Do me a favour and list it out considering you have already done the work.

What can we infer about who as a result of the following:

a) celaph scumflip
b) celaph townflip
c) TFB scumslip
d) TFB townslip ?

TIA.

a) Jamie/Blamp/Sabi > Maniac > TFB >>>> bozo in likelihood to be scum.
b) Chaqa/Demon become hard-lock town for me. BB gets a stronge town read.

I assume you mean flip for c and d? I'll proceed with that:
c) Sabi looks the worst and comes off as trying to save teammate. Maniac/Demon/Chaqa look bad, but there is easier town logic to justify their moves.
d) I don't see anything gained by a town flip of TFB.

Anyways, ##vote celaph

Thanks and yes I meant f not s.

[brainbomb]

Eden at any point were you concerned that maybe the cop would cc you here? this is pretty high risk the way this went down

[Jamiet99uk]

That you potentially saved him D1. I don't easily see why you would've picked Kak over him when untieing the vote.

It doesn't auto-lock you as scum, but it makes the potential much higher.

Do you recall me giving a reason?

Have you forgotten it, or do you just not believe it?

I wasn't here for D1 - I didn't know I was subbed in until N1 and even then was not available to really give this game attention until yesterday.

So, just to summarise, you've decided that if Celaph dies and flips scum, I become your #1 scumread because of my EoD vote, BUT you've made no attempt to go back and see what my stated reasoning was for said vote.

Superlative detective work right there, Holmes.

[brainbomb]

wrinkles can be ironed out. you can remove the habit of always claiming to be so overwhelmed on some other server and replace it with a tedious spreadsheet that creates a false narrative that talking incessantly to every person and asking them 60 million questions = townyness

To clarify: are you saying there is potential that Sabi is replacing the distancing employed last time as scum by focusing on a spreadsheet and random questions?

yes to all of this

[President Eden]

Eden at any point were you concerned that maybe the cop would cc you here? this is pretty high risk the way this went down

I appreciate you but we’ve crossed the Rubicon, cast all the dice into the River and then drunkenly burned down the bridges in anger at having lost the dice.

No, I was not worried about me cc’ing myself.

[brainbomb]

replaced one scummy out of game issues wrinkle with a new busy work wrinkle

[Jamiet99uk]

Worcej doing his analysis as if all the posts prior to the current phase have been deleted and only the vote count is left. Great.

[brainbomb]

Eden at any point were you concerned that maybe the cop would cc you here? this is pretty high risk the way this went down

I appreciate you but we’ve crossed the Rubicon, cast all the dice into the River and then drunkenly burned down the bridges in anger at having lost the dice.

No, I was not worried about me cc’ing myself.

dont worry I was roleblocked last night so youll be in my arms tonight instead. with our puppy hildy

[Jamiet99uk]

Do you recall me giving a reason?

Have you forgotten it, or do you just not believe it?

I wasn't here for D1 - I didn't know I was subbed in until N1 and even then was not available to really give this game attention until yesterday.

So, just to summarise, you've decided that if Celaph dies and flips scum, I become your #1 scumread because of my EoD vote, BUT you've made no attempt to go back and see what my stated reasoning was for said vote.

Superlative detective work right there, Holmes.

To be clear here: I'm not claiming I cited fantastically strong reasons for my Kak vote. I'm saying Worcej is scummy for not bothering to check.

[pyxxy]

replaced one scummy out of game issues wrinkle with a new busy work wrinkle

The best explanations are based on truth.

[pyxxy]

the QRD (and then I REALLY REALLY need to get something done today smh) on where I’m at:

I do think Kak died as a result of mafia saving a teammate.
Decreasingly I think that teammate was celaph. Increasingly I think it was Boat. Not to dictate what anybody does, but it would be really helpful if we knew both of their alignments by the start of the next day. I had intended to take care of that myself… but I strongly doubt I’ll be allowed to do so now.

But regardless, some considerations:
• if celaph is mafia and Boat is town, Chaqa’s analysis on celaph being mafia is very strong.
• if Boat is mafia and celaph is town, then I think Maniac is also suspicious for reasons spelled out by Demon and Lamp. incidentally I think both of those guys are town for spelling that out.
• if they’re BOTH mafia… idk man that’s wild.
• if they’re both town then oops lol. Maniac can still be sus here but I would re-examine everything if that’s so.

Thank you for this post, finally someone explains what they expect from killing Celaph instead of just repeating "it will sure show a lot, haha".

[worcej]

Do you recall me giving a reason?

Have you forgotten it, or do you just not believe it?

I wasn't here for D1 - I didn't know I was subbed in until N1 and even then was not available to really give this game attention until yesterday.

So, just to summarise, you've decided that if Celaph dies and flips scum, I become your #1 scumread because of my EoD vote, BUT you've made no attempt to go back and see what my stated reasoning was for said vote.

Superlative detective work right there, Holmes.

No, you're in equal footing with Blamp and Sabi as suspicious. I'd be focusing my attention on analyzing the three of you.

You notice how I listed it right?

Jamie/Blamp/Sabi > Maniac > TFB >>>> bozo in likelihood to be scum.

Now, perhaps you're bad at math, but ">" means greater than. And the use of "/" distinguishes a sense of equality and not "more than".