M1023: Mafarmia [GAME THREAD] [HIDDEN]

[lfischl]

Obviously not a lot to go on, NOT gonna vote for the following today

Bozo - too useful if town
Chaqa - because he has bleated
damo - because that would be silly
ghug - see bozo
heartthrob - NEW
Kak - too noisy to be scum
rdr - sheepclaim

So am left with

Bona
Bo
Bunny
celaph
lfischl
worcej

Of these worcej gets a pass as he hasn't spoken yet and celaph will give himself away if scum.

Bo a la worcej, Bona already under pressure. Leaves Bunny or fish.

I'll ##vote lfischl.

That’s quite rude of you

I feel like bona is scum just because of the volume of shitposting he has done, I haven’t played in a while, does he do this as scum?

He does it whatever.

Tell me why I shouldn't vote you. One sentence.

What do you mean by celaph will give himself away?

[BunnyGo]

In response to a ##callGM submitted via PM:

All role PMs were copied and pasted exactly as listed in the OP, except as follows.

- All instances of [DISCORD INVITE] were replaced with the appropriate text.
- The Squirrel That Thinks It's A Sheep received a copy of the Sheep PM.
- The mafia received a separate PM confirming their teammates' identities and also containing the Discord invite.

All numbers were retained as listed in the OP. Sheep PM (including the one sent to the Squirrel) says 7x Sheep, all others say 1x.

As usual you are reminded that the spirit of the game requires you to PM me with any potentially broken PM interactions you think you've spotted and not to use them to break the game by discussing them in the thread.

mfw bungo

this was weird too, very unlike you to guess this.

[Bonatogether]

inadequate time to shitpost

this thread you went down. Why you want so much noise? Now you say your noise has content? Is just noise. You want to shitpost, but then also want to claim there's nothing in your shitposts, but then also want to claim they're full of content. It's inanity.

You took 4 posts to say 4 sentences that were roughly 4 words each. It just felt like filler. Not even jokey filler, just filler filler.

i was having a good time conversing with my fellow refined personages

[Bonatogether]

In response to a ##callGM submitted via PM:

All role PMs were copied and pasted exactly as listed in the OP, except as follows.

- All instances of [DISCORD INVITE] were replaced with the appropriate text.
- The Squirrel That Thinks It's A Sheep received a copy of the Sheep PM.
- The mafia received a separate PM confirming their teammates' identities and also containing the Discord invite.

All numbers were retained as listed in the OP. Sheep PM (including the one sent to the Squirrel) says 7x Sheep, all others say 1x.

As usual you are reminded that the spirit of the game requires you to PM me with any potentially broken PM interactions you think you've spotted and not to use them to break the game by discussing them in the thread.

mfw bungo

this was weird too, very unlike you to guess this.

i know this is false because i know i did it

[damo666]

That’s quite rude of you

I feel like bona is scum just because of the volume of shitposting he has done, I haven’t played in a while, does he do this as scum?

He does it whatever.

Tell me why I shouldn't vote you. One sentence.

What do you mean by celaph will give himself away?

When he's scum he panics and does something daft.

[BunnyGo]

inadequate time to shitpost

this thread you went down. Why you want so much noise? Now you say your noise has content? Is just noise. You want to shitpost, but then also want to claim there's nothing in your shitposts, but then also want to claim they're full of content. It's inanity.

setting aside your context-removal and strategic reordering of what i said, how does that connect to me being scum?

the scum!bona I remember (and the one you claimed in thread somewhere I'm not going to dig up) plays by hypertowny dumb idea bona, that then laughs about how dumb!town he is. Like "hey! town need MORE TIME TO SHITPOST" and "hey! I'm gonna just tie the vote no matter what! I don't have any reason to vote for anyone, so I'll just tie it!"

So...filling up the thread with empty posts that take half a page to say what one post could. Voting for the newbie when you know that nobody is going to join you there. It's all "cringe" as you put it.

[Kakarroto]

now that you know he has mild covid, how would you interpret his actions and lines of reasoning?

it seems it enhanced a bit the sillyness in D1 start posts, be it for fun or getting reactions. It's a bit hard to follow the reasoning behind some (like when I do silly things it all makes sense to me but it's hard to explain it to others, I think bunny might be the same in that regard); of course he could do all that as mafia to try to look like silly town, but normally that's hard to perform and town usually sniffs out the mafia behind, like the game where I was the Hexenjäger. I shall read it again, though right now I'm quite tired from today so not right now but the feel I have about it right no is more like more town than mafia for bunny here.

what specifically would tip off genuine silly town vs fake silly scum? can scum be genuinely silly?

maybe, but I think you ask the wrong one here, when I tried to do it as mafia I was called out D1 and nearly was voted out and only a tracker claim could save me (well I was the target D2 anyway because I faked a scan on damo where I said he didn't visit snowy [who was the N1 mafia target] but he actually did and town didn't believe me anymore). So in my experience fake sillyness will be called out if you aren't very, very good at it.

[BunnyGo]

mfw bungo

this was weird too, very unlike you to guess this.

i know this is false because i know i did it

I KNEW IT!

[bozotheclown]

Initial thoughts:

• Damo and rdr both felt town motivated for the no-nonsense way they entered the thread.
• I don't recall if I've ever seen scum Kak before, but the way he both sent songs and genuinely interacted with the thread felt towny.
• I like Bona so far.
• I'm curious as to what conclusions Bozo draws from talking to Bona and I about our pre-game interactions.

Not much, but I think you and Bonatogether are probably not both mafia for you to bring up a post that only you two could verify.

[bozotheclown]

this was weird too, very unlike you to guess this.

i know this is false because i know i did it

I KNEW IT!

Does that make you think Bonatogether is more or less likely to be mafia?

[BunnyGo]

i know this is false because i know i did it

I KNEW IT!

Does that make you think Bonatogether is more or less likely to be mafia?

Well...at the time, my suspicion was he was the asker and that his asking and then pushing it on me for it was scummy. His admitting it is slightly towny, but mostly NAI. So over all scummy.

[Bonatogether]

this thread you went down. Why you want so much noise? Now you say your noise has content? Is just noise. You want to shitpost, but then also want to claim there's nothing in your shitposts, but then also want to claim they're full of content. It's inanity.

setting aside your context-removal and strategic reordering of what i said, how does that connect to me being scum?

the scum!bona I remember (and the one you claimed in thread somewhere I'm not going to dig up) plays by hypertowny dumb idea bona, that then laughs about how dumb!town he is. Like "hey! town need MORE TIME TO SHITPOST" and "hey! I'm gonna just tie the vote no matter what! I don't have any reason to vote for anyone, so I'll just tie it!"

So...filling up the thread with empty posts that take half a page to say what one post could. Voting for the newbie when you know that nobody is going to join you there. It's all "cringe" as you put it.

this misunderstands why i do things

i do shit cause it's funny or because i want to place my thoughts into the world, but when time comes, i do put in work. just cause i'm having a conversation doesn't mean it's filler.

that's not cringe

[celaph]

I feel like bona is scum just because of the volume of shitposting he has done, I haven’t played in a while, does he do this as scum?

Doing a quick scan of past games, I feel like Bona's shitposting and being mafia are actually negatively correlated. He was mafia last game and had less shitposting than this D1. His game before he was town and shitposting levels were higher. Granted, that town game he was PR and we had 48 hours days so it's not too representative, but it goes to show that I don't think shitposting is a good metric for scumminess.

wait you're literally lying - i was doc or some shit in the last game

Did you forget about M76?

BONATOGETHER has died. He was the RANGER (mafia).

[Bonatogether]

it seems it enhanced a bit the sillyness in D1 start posts, be it for fun or getting reactions. It's a bit hard to follow the reasoning behind some (like when I do silly things it all makes sense to me but it's hard to explain it to others, I think bunny might be the same in that regard); of course he could do all that as mafia to try to look like silly town, but normally that's hard to perform and town usually sniffs out the mafia behind, like the game where I was the Hexenjäger. I shall read it again, though right now I'm quite tired from today so not right now but the feel I have about it right no is more like more town than mafia for bunny here.

what specifically would tip off genuine silly town vs fake silly scum? can scum be genuinely silly?

maybe, but I think you ask the wrong one here, when I tried to do it as mafia I was called out D1 and nearly was voted out and only a tracker claim could save me (well I was the target D2 anyway because I faked a scan on damo where I said he didn't visit snowy [who was the N1 mafia target] but he actually did and town didn't believe me anymore). So in my experience fake sillyness will be called out if you aren't very, very good at it.

interesting

does anyone strike you as being fake silly atm?

[Bonatogether]

this was weird too, very unlike you to guess this.

i know this is false because i know i did it

I KNEW IT!

?

[Bonatogether]

I KNEW IT!

Does that make you think Bonatogether is more or less likely to be mafia?

Well...at the time, my suspicion was he was the asker and that his asking and then pushing it on me for it was scummy. His admitting it is slightly towny, but mostly NAI. So over all scummy.

no, i didn't ask the question, but i did say 'mfw bungo'

[celaph]

I've seen bona do way dumber stuff than this, don't think that means anything really

Ok but is this a scumslip?

@lfischl have you seen this post? Thoughts?

[Bonatogether]

Doing a quick scan of past games, I feel like Bona's shitposting and being mafia are actually negatively correlated. He was mafia last game and had less shitposting than this D1. His game before he was town and shitposting levels were higher. Granted, that town game he was PR and we had 48 hours days so it's not too representative, but it goes to show that I don't think shitposting is a good metric for scumminess.

wait you're literally lying - i was doc or some shit in the last game

Did you forget about M76?

BONATOGETHER has died. He was the RANGER (mafia).

im confused

[ghug]

I feel like bona is scum just because of the volume of shitposting he has done, I haven’t played in a while, does he do this as scum?

Doing a quick scan of past games, I feel like Bona's shitposting and being mafia are actually negatively correlated. He was mafia last game and had less shitposting than this D1. His game before he was town and shitposting levels were higher. Granted, that town game he was PR and we had 48 hours days so it's not too representative, but it goes to show that I don't think shitposting is a good metric for scumminess.

As a prolific shitposter myself, I find it to be more a matter of mood and availability than alignment. You have to focus on the things he's doing with or in addition to the shitposting.

[ghug]

It's been dominated by you and BunnyGo distracting us.

I had hoped for more, but I guess then I should turn down sillyness to a lesser degree.

I'm surprised ghug doesn't mention Bona as the volume poster here.

Bona doesn't seize the conversation in the same way you two do.