MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[Vecna]

Am I the only one who thinks Will is being too performative with his questioning on what just happened?

He suddenly seems extremely excited to me.

Do you think that makes him more likely to be town, mafia, or 3P?

in a vacuum, mafia.

in the context where I believe you and ghug are probably the remaining mafia, 3p or town.

[ghug]

##VOTE VECNA

##END

Really wasn’t brain hm, glad I got off that wagon

Stinks I may have been wrong on ghug

Why the fuck are people hammering?

[brainbomb]

The only person who actively tried to go after people for 3p hunting was ghug.

So by that logic ghug is scum trying to get town killed, or 3p trying to get anyone but himself killed.

[bozotheclown]

Thinking about it more, if we hit the mafia PR first, the mafia goon would lose if they NK our last PR and there is a witch, so our best option is probably to try to DK a mafia and hope it is the PR.

the witch can also bewitch the last mafia and make the kill themselves.

if theres a witch they could have a decent idea of the lay of the land by now.

Anyways, im reaching the limit of my patience for mechanics

True, if they can identify the last mafia. They could also do that to eliminate the mafia PR.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

Thinking about it more, if we hit the mafia PR first, the mafia goon would lose if they NK our last PR and there is a witch, so our best option is probably to try to DK a mafia and hope it is the PR.

the witch can also bewitch the last mafia and make the kill themselves.

if theres a witch they could have a decent idea of the lay of the land by now.

Anyways, im reaching the limit of my patience for mechanics

True, if they can identify the last mafia. They could also do that to eliminate the mafia PR.

if they hit the last PR they just win anyway, either the PRs all die or they control the living ones each at least once

[Vecna]

i feel like it should be bozo. 1) demon wanted him and died for it, 2) bozo has read all the 3p set up and noted the PR claim thing and then demon died, and while its sad to scum read this, it is kind of a thing.

Besides that, im back to ghug, but i think he is much more likely mafia than 3p given his fake claim would be super stupid as 3p

I dont get why anyone is giving ghug credit for that priest claim.

He does that shit as every alignment, all the time, every game.

Anyone paying attention knew what RHK was claiming. Any mafia team that has ever before played with Ghug knew his claim was bs.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

oh nevermind, maybe it has to be ALL of them even the ones died already

[Vecna]

the witch can also bewitch the last mafia and make the kill themselves.

if theres a witch they could have a decent idea of the lay of the land by now.

Anyways, im reaching the limit of my patience for mechanics

True, if they can identify the last mafia. They could also do that to eliminate the mafia PR.

if they hit the last PR they just win anyway, either the PRs all die or they control the living ones each at least once

I dont think thats how the 2nd wincon works for witch?

Seems like that one become invalid as soon as we daykilled red d1.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

i feel like it should be bozo. 1) demon wanted him and died for it, 2) bozo has read all the 3p set up and noted the PR claim thing and then demon died, and while its sad to scum read this, it is kind of a thing.

Besides that, im back to ghug, but i think he is much more likely mafia than 3p given his fake claim would be super stupid as 3p

I dont get why anyone is giving ghug credit for that priest claim.

He does that shit as every alignment, all the time, every game.

Anyone paying attention knew what RHK was claiming. Any mafia team that has ever before played with Ghug knew his claim was bs.

sure, but if he was 3p, he was seriously chancing them taking it seriously more than they otherwise would. Idk seems like a stretch to me, unless he saw this exact outcome coming which he could only do as mafia last night

[Vecna]

oh nevermind, maybe it has to be ALL of them even the ones died already

sir, are you trying to dumbtell?

[brainbomb]

##vote ND

[bozotheclown]

i feel like it should be bozo. 1) demon wanted him and died for it, 2) bozo has read all the 3p set up and noted the PR claim thing and then demon died, and while its sad to scum read this, it is kind of a thing.

Besides that, im back to ghug, but i think he is much more likely mafia than 3p given his fake claim would be super stupid as 3p

It was obvious DemonRHK was claiming to be a PR.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

i feel like it should be bozo. 1) demon wanted him and died for it, 2) bozo has read all the 3p set up and noted the PR claim thing and then demon died, and while its sad to scum read this, it is kind of a thing.

Besides that, im back to ghug, but i think he is much more likely mafia than 3p given his fake claim would be super stupid as 3p

It was obvious DemonRHK was claiming to be a PR.

in retrospect yes, but it seems like food, will and I all missed it so...

[SpiritoftheRadio]

at least at the time

[Vecna]

i feel like it should be bozo. 1) demon wanted him and died for it, 2) bozo has read all the 3p set up and noted the PR claim thing and then demon died, and while its sad to scum read this, it is kind of a thing.

Besides that, im back to ghug, but i think he is much more likely mafia than 3p given his fake claim would be super stupid as 3p

It was obvious DemonRHK was claiming to be a PR.

in retrospect yes, but it seems like food, will and I all missed it so...

i guarantee at least 1 of these names was faking that

[SpiritoftheRadio]

oh nevermind, maybe it has to be ALL of them even the ones died already

sir, are you trying to dumbtell?

no tbh the rules are just kind of a lot for the 3rd parties, wish we werent in this position. And yeah dude, i've missed some things I should have saw at EoD, but I was just annoyed and ran off to a game night I was late for and didnt reread

[Vecna]

its mostly a shame he didnt just fullclaim 2 minutes earlier so ghug would be in the ground

[Vecna]

its also interesting to me that ghug hasnt mentioned ND in a long time it feels like.

can hardly blame him, since I also sorta forgot he was in the game untill bb just voted him just now.

[bozotheclown]

i feel like it should be bozo. 1) demon wanted him and died for it, 2) bozo has read all the 3p set up and noted the PR claim thing and then demon died, and while its sad to scum read this, it is kind of a thing.

Besides that, im back to ghug, but i think he is much more likely mafia than 3p given his fake claim would be super stupid as 3p

It was obvious DemonRHK was claiming to be a PR.

in retrospect yes, but it seems like food, will and I all missed it so...

I don't think foodcoats said that, and I don't think Just really missed it.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

tbh itd be hilarious if ND was 3p and has just been fucking around the whole game to fly under the radar. Some real Palpatine shit