MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[heartthrob24909]

@Bozopedia: has Jamie ever crumbed or does he often crumb?

I feel like you all are over-reading that post

Instance 1 and 2 out of 4 of "crumb" showing up in Chaqa's posts

[heartthrob24909]

@Bozopedia: has Jamie ever crumbed or does he often crumb?

I feel like you all are over-reading that post

Jamie typically crumbs when he is a PR, but I think he is usually more direct when he has an informative scan. I am not convinced that Jamie did not just suspect Bonatogether was mafia without any N1 scan.

Yeah, this is how I read the post originally.

Bona claiming Doctor is the bit that makes me think Jamie *did* see something, but it's unclear to me what the truth of it all is yet.

Instance 3

[ghug]

Why is everyone voting me?

I'm the only one putting colored VCA together and working with bozo to analyze things.

They killed bozo to keep him quiet from searching...

And vig obviously shot bona because vig trusted me.

I did tell damo to shoot bona. You the vig, damo? Should the vig even claim at this point since they're out of shots?

What the fuck is this post?

[ghug]

A pretty bad choice from Vig, which probably should claim today as we can afford a 1x1.

##vote Bunny - The reaction to the flip is fake as hell.

What does this mean? Vig is now vt.

No, vig still has a unique, claimable role.

[heartthrob24909]

I'm 100% sure Jamie is in the god chat raging that we're missing that he's caught Bona, or he's raging that we're misinterpreting his post as having caught Bona lol

a Jamie mention from Chaqa following Jamie's elimination

[heartthrob24909]

Oh great Bozo!

Please explain what the fuck just happened with Bona. Too many people are saying things are obvious, but I just saw 3 pages of WORDS, and I'm confused.

Do we have to neck him now?

I think if I understand it right, Jamie saw Bona visit someone, and now Bona claims doctor

another one. Retelling of the story with no opinion given

[heartthrob24909]

Like, normally I'm all for letting suspicious PR claims sit because it's often town fakeclaiming to draw kills or a real PR that just happened to look bad.

In this case, though, Jamie outed a scan on Bona that has no other explanation, and then Bona claimed the only town role scum could claim there in the hopes of taking the doc down with him. I don't see any other plausible way to interpret what happened. Jamie isn't going to leave a crumb like that if he doesn't have mechanical information. Letting Bona take the doc down with him is just bad play.

That's assuming that Jamie had a scan

and this one

[heartthrob24909]

I told you guys he wasn’t crumbing

This whole thing has been dumb

I disagree with you that you communicated this.

##vote Chaqa for the time being

[heartthrob24909]

also did a search on Bona's name in Chaqa's posts and didn't find anything particularly persuasive regarding his thoughts on Bona's alignment but I'll cease my spamming for the time being

[BunnyGo]

Why is everyone voting me?

I'm the only one putting colored VCA together and working with bozo to analyze things.

They killed bozo to keep him quiet from searching...

And vig obviously shot bona because vig trusted me.

I did tell damo to shoot bona. You the vig, damo? Should the vig even claim at this point since they're out of shots?

What the fuck is this post?

I'm honestly surprised people are voting me. Isn't it towny to be wrong about Bona?

[BunnyGo]

A pretty bad choice from Vig, which probably should claim today as we can afford a 1x1.

##vote Bunny - The reaction to the flip is fake as hell.

What does this mean? Vig is now vt.

No, vig still has a unique, claimable role.

I don't think they should claim it though. But rdr disagrees.

[heartthrob24909]

The only person I firmly believe is town is Macca

[rdrivera2005]

Why are we assuming the vig didn’t shoot Bozo?

I think Bona is much more likely because nobody scumread bozo but this is a fair question.

It's not MILO. I don't think the vig should claim unless they're on the block, though they do need to claim at EoN if we miskill again today.

If we miskill today a scum might try to win a CC against the real vig. Plus, any scum in the block will claim Vig. Claiming today is a death sentence but we solve this too problems. Not sure which is the best play here.

[BunnyGo]

The only person I firmly believe is town is Macca

why?

[BunnyGo]

Why are we assuming the vig didn’t shoot Bozo?

I think Bona is much more likely because nobody scumread bozo but this is a fair question.

It's not MILO. I don't think the vig should claim unless they're on the block, though they do need to claim at EoN if we miskill again today.

If we miskill today a scum might try to win a CC against the real vig. Plus, any scum in the block will claim Vig. Claiming today is a death sentence but we solve this too problems. Not sure which is the best play here.

If we miskill today we lose.

It IS MiLo

[heartthrob24909]

The only person I firmly believe is town is Macca

why?

Because on Day 1, when her wagon was in a 3-way tie with Just and Sweet, Just voted for Macca to put her in the lead

[BunnyGo]

I think Bona is much more likely because nobody scumread bozo but this is a fair question.

It's not MILO. I don't think the vig should claim unless they're on the block, though they do need to claim at EoN if we miskill again today.

If we miskill today a scum might try to win a CC against the real vig. Plus, any scum in the block will claim Vig. Claiming today is a death sentence but we solve this too problems. Not sure which is the best play here.

If we miskill today we lose.

It IS MiLo

Goddamn I su** at math...

Not MiLo...

[BunnyGo]

If we miskill today a scum might try to win a CC against the real vig. Plus, any scum in the block will claim Vig. Claiming today is a death sentence but we solve this too problems. Not sure which is the best play here.

If we miskill today we lose.

It IS MiLo

Goddamn I su** at math...

Not MiLo...

##unvote

[rdrivera2005]

I think Bona is much more likely because nobody scumread bozo but this is a fair question.

It's not MILO. I don't think the vig should claim unless they're on the block, though they do need to claim at EoN if we miskill again today.

If we miskill today a scum might try to win a CC against the real vig. Plus, any scum in the block will claim Vig. Claiming today is a death sentence but we solve this too problems. Not sure which is the best play here.

If we miskill today we lose.

It IS MiLo

No, it's not, we are 6-2. What are you on?

[BunnyGo]

If we miskill today a scum might try to win a CC against the real vig. Plus, any scum in the block will claim Vig. Claiming today is a death sentence but we solve this too problems. Not sure which is the best play here.

If we miskill today we lose.

It IS MiLo

No, it's not, we are 6-2. What are you on?

I'M COLD!!

It's 12 degrees C in my house.