M53: Mafia 1 Redux

[brainbomb]

youve done fine.
##Vote Damo

[Jamiet99uk]

#VOTE PEDRO

[brainbomb]

thank you for the compliment earlier kalel.

[Foxcastle]

I would rather lynch Flash, and I'd be willing to vote Damo, instead of Kalel.

[brainbomb]

TOWNREADS
today bobmcbob has reinforced my belief that hes a towny who says scummy looking things, is not advised, unrehearsed. just says whatever he thinks. it feels incomplete at times but isnt scummy.

Kalel lynched scum. his tone has been towny, he appears to be forthcoming and shares his opinions. I think one of he or damo is probably mafia based on how thats gone.

foxcastle - if he is still alive late id be concerned. but he would be scheduled to be nk ahead of alot of others based on skills.

kitsune - lynched scum in a weird way but her posts are usually decent. Not overly defensive or arrogant. just seems busy.

NULLS
flash
food
kak

Scum
Damo
Bunny
Jamie

[Kitsune]

Hey everyone, awake again and online.

I'm satisfied with Flash's answers to my questions (for now) and will not be voting him at EoD. I'm considering my other options and expect to cast my vote elsewhere within the hour.

@Brainbomb: As KalEl (I think?) said while I was asleep, I just said the only DnD character I'd played when I was asked for a class/race combination. Didn't realise it was a question of "how would you describe your role in this game of Mafia using only race and class" or I probably would have picked someone other than a tiny loner

Anyway. Reading and thinking time, will try to keep one eye on the thread if anyone has questions for me.

[brainbomb]

My nightkill will be among bunny, jamie, kak or food.

I expect to die and be roleblocked. it has been an honor.
May the light of brain shine upon all ye who lived to see such times

[brainbomb]

Hey everyone, awake again and online.

I'm satisfied with Flash's answers to my questions (for now) and will not be voting him at EoD. I'm considering my other options and expect to cast my vote elsewhere within the hour.

@Brainbomb: As KalEl (I think?) said while I was asleep, I just said the only DnD character I'd played when I was asked for a class/race combination. Didn't realise it was a question of "how would you describe your role in this game of Mafia using only race and class" or I probably would have picked someone other than a tiny loner

Anyway. Reading and thinking time, will try to keep one eye on the thread if anyone has questions for me.

kak
jamie
damo
or bunny

2 scum in those 4?

[brainbomb]

this kalel guy has certainly shown a lot of personality that I am sad to say I had not yet gotten to witness. Bobmcbob too. I gotta get used to all these new people and pay more attention to them.

[brainbomb]

foodcoats personality is very strong. his depth as a player on both scum and town is probably the biggest jump ive seen since xorxes. The guy is a natural talent at a variety of playstyles that make it challenging to guage.

[Foxcastle]

Bob, you voted Kalel because people thought it was either you or him. Since you're safe from the lynch today, what do you think about the wagons in play?

[brainbomb]

Id say I struggle reading emc, neph, flash, kak because I just lack any understanding on them. worcej, damo, bozo always seem like ezio evil types to me

[Kitsune]

Hey everyone, awake again and online.

I'm satisfied with Flash's answers to my questions (for now) and will not be voting him at EoD. I'm considering my other options and expect to cast my vote elsewhere within the hour.

@Brainbomb: As KalEl (I think?) said while I was asleep, I just said the only DnD character I'd played when I was asked for a class/race combination. Didn't realise it was a question of "how would you describe your role in this game of Mafia using only race and class" or I probably would have picked someone other than a tiny loner

Anyway. Reading and thinking time, will try to keep one eye on the thread if anyone has questions for me.

kak
jamie
damo
or bunny

2 scum in those 4?

Probably one or two, yeah.

I'm still trying to look at the relationships as have been shown and I don't have the same highly trained gut as you do, but if we assume there's at least one there then that leaves us looking for 1-2 in the remaining group.

I know you've been butting heads with him a bit, but for me Jamie is a bit like Bozo. I don't always find his investigations amazingly towny, but when he's acting at his blatantly scummiest is usually when he's actually Town and however his detectiving is working he seems to have fairly solid voting instincts so far.

If I was prepared to sheep (and I'm not), I'd be tempted to follow him onto Kalel - but for my own developing reads, Kalel still seems Townlean to me.

I have to dig deeper.

[brainbomb]

Fox is very dangerous as scum
he has a natural talent typically for looking like a leader when he wants. And hes very good at writing towny looking material. I can say fox is in the low tier of any townread for his bozo lynch. The night debate where rivera lists him, he lists rivera and rivera dies by maf nk. it certainly could be incriminating.

though I didnt really wanna shoot fox. and obviously rivera wanted vecna dead, maybe to kill scum. its possible he sr vecna, or the kill was motivated to assist scum.

either way I think scum didnt plan to kill.sk. they maybe thought that since rivera said shoot fox, that we would equate the kill to be protectivist

[brainbomb]

probably?

what do you mean probably?

kit?

[Kitsune]

probably?

what do you mean probably?

kit?

I mean I believe there are 1 or 2 in that group.

I'm less certain which, but let me give an impromptu gut Read list while I'm wading through your ISO.

kak - feels scummy
jamie - feels towny, if sometimes frustrating
damo - feels scumlean
or bunny - feels 'towny' for a drunkbunny definition of towny. Like jamie, sometimes frustrating.

If I had to call it now I'd say of the four, kak is scum and maybe damo too.

[brainbomb]

can you provide a more specific answer? probably is woefully unhelpful

[brainbomb]

probably?

what do you mean probably?

kit?

I mean I believe there are 1 or 2 in that group.

I'm less certain which, but let me give an impromptu gut Read list while I'm wading through your ISO.

kak - feels scummy
jamie - feels towny, if sometimes frustrating
damo - feels scumlean
or bunny - feels 'towny' for a drunkbunny definition of towny. Like jamie, sometimes frustrating.

If I had to call it now I'd say of the four, kak is scum and maybe damo too.

why damo
why kak

[Foxcastle]

Fox is very dangerous as scum
he has a natural talent typically for looking like a leader when he wants. And hes very good at writing towny looking material. I can say fox is in the low tier of any townread for his bozo lynch. The night debate where rivera lists him, he lists rivera and rivera dies by maf nk. it certainly could be incriminating.

though I didnt really wanna shoot fox. and obviously rivera wanted vecna dead, maybe to kill scum. its possible he sr vecna, or the kill was motivated to assist scum.

either way I think scum didnt plan to kill.sk. they maybe thought that since rivera said shoot fox, that we would equate the kill to be protectivist

I think my record would show that, except for my first game where I won by being a newbie/nobody, I haven't won a game as scum since. And the only time I managed to become town leader was when everyone else was dead and I managed to mislynch anyway

[Jamiet99uk]

##CALL GM

1. Aren't you doing vote counts today?
2. Will Steve be replaced if he doesn't vote?