MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[DemonRHK]

Enjoying valentines day with my wife and not this shit

fair enough, spooky that your were summoned by it tho

Biggie Smalls
Biggie Smalls
Biggie Smalls

*gunshots erupt*

-----

So based on the few posts quoted by spirit, I suddenly feel like bozo needs a really, really long look.

[ND]

##Vote Will

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Won’t be online until tmrw for obv reasons

[brainbomb]

Won’t be online until tmrw for obv reasons

Didnt know you had a boo. Congrats.

[worcej]

Enjoying valentines day with my wife and not this shit

fair enough, spooky that your were summoned by it tho

Biggie Smalls
Biggie Smalls
Biggie Smalls

*gunshots erupt*

-----

So based on the few posts quoted by spirit, I suddenly feel like bozo needs a really, really long look.

I definitely feel that you are going a little more rogue than necessary with this

[worcej]

D1 last 10 minutes, the votes were this:
Dip (4) - Bunny, brain, Demon, Will
Red (4) - food, kotp, ND, Spirit
ND (4) - Dip, ghug, Red, Vecna
Will (2) - bozo, mimi

My same analysis ends up with Brain/Demon/Will being best votes, with my preference as Will but totally fine with a BB flip too.

[worcej]

I don't credit BB for "getting" Dip when how he did it really feels like a bus vote.

BB didn't even mention Dip as an option when I made my initial post for the phase:

I have read next to nothing from this day phase and won’t pretend to have an informed opinion.

First gut take is the bozo wagon feels good as my vibes from him are off.

I feel like the D&W wagon is a revisit of D1, which I think is acceptable as I kinda threw the vote into chaos and he got “saved” from that.

There was a good amount of discussion over foodcoats today, varying opinions on him. There has been some discussion around if ND is a valid push or a behavioral matter to be handled by the kouncil. Some discussion early on about why damo would be the kill, and then lots of other mini aggressions among people

Demon rhk has earned a voter or two here and there

Ect

I feel more that the food/ND commentary could be subtle direction steering to get me to help make another wagon option versus reinforcing the dip one

[worcej]

This reminds me a lot of D&W's BS with darg last game.

I have no idea what happened last game. Tell me about it.

He spent a large chunk of D1 peddling a theory that darg was editing his posts before posting them because there was a post with a double line break in it. It was terrible logic, they were both town, and it was a major factor in Dip getting miskilled.

Digging on BB, I found this nugget and it looks

[ghug]

Won’t be online until tmrw for obv reasons

Ah, young love.

[ghug]

I have no idea what happened last game. Tell me about it.

He spent a large chunk of D1 peddling a theory that darg was editing his posts before posting them because there was a post with a double line break in it. It was terrible logic, they were both town, and it was a major factor in Dip getting miskilled.

Digging on BB, I found this nugget and it looks

I stand by the analysis. Apparently Dip can fake his tinfoil lunacy.

[Vecna]

##vote will
I really wish that I had time to read everyone's posts and make a decision, but I have 8 minutes and I am somehow a wagon today

I think this vote for Just is inconclusive. If DiplomacyandWarfare had voted for anyone else there, Just would look bad when DiplomacyandWarfare flipped mafia. DiplomacyandWarfare did make some posts that made it seem like he was trying to get Just DKed over him:

unacceptable. ghug is towny.

actual reasons behind scumreading me will has stated today: 0

However, DiplomacyandWarfare didn't make a town PR claim, which might have been able to divert the DK to Just.

This is actually a good point

I think this lends more merit to that the wolves were bussing DIp for credit

interesting data point to follow up on.

a town/3p just would know for certain that DW didnt forego claiming to save his ass, so id expect this to influence his behaviour going forward from this point if he indeed did think it was a good point.

[Vecna]

I just had another thought, which is that Will's saying that worcej is a townclear and getting annoyed that he (Will) isn't getting cleared for VCA does kind of point to town worcej and scum will.

No, these are entirely different things

I’m saying worcej is town because he was the flash CW to dip

I’m saying I’m town bc I pushed Dip all day and all night

Different circumstances

also note to see if Will takes the existance of another person potentially being 3p into his calculations at all.

This post reads as if he is only analyzing the game in terms of town vs scum

[Vecna]

Wagons EOD were Red/Dip, until you popped up as a CW, and the Dip wagon died

There practically no chance you’re a wolf with Dip

This assumes that scum pushed the worcej wagon, when in fact most things are town driven and scum just shuttle along as best they can to obscure. I don't think the worcej wagon was STARTED by scum, but worcej could still be scum.

I would agree in principle, but I believe Dip was likely bussed, and Worcej goading people onto his wagon just gives scum the perfect opportunity to flip off a teammate

Ok so

Brain fits a few criteria

He flipped from Dip to Worcej last second D1

And he was an early and stagnant voter on Dip D2

I think its likely a wolf would do one of these, but both? Lol

follow-up posting definately in-line with the earlier outspoken stuff. Feels pretty natural and like someone actually chasing down leads

[Vecna]

The thing is with scum!brain is im unsure of where I sort Spirit and Bozo. Its possible Spirit is 3p, but idk

I really havent been thinking about the 3p that much tbh, I think the best way to deal with this game is solve it as close to vanilla as possible, and only when it is pertinent should we actively hunt for a 3p

townread intensifies, although I think the danger is understated

[Vecna]

My one concern with your latter point is that Vecna calling it out the way he did seems like a textbook case of scum noticing inconsistencies in their teammates more acutely.

I think I'm in aggregate he does look more good than bad, but it's not a certainty.

I also question why DiplomacyandWarfare would choose to antagonize a town Vecna the way he was after Vecna almost single handedly got worcej DKed D1.

im sure he'll think twice next time

[Vecna]

I'll read and post more in like 4 hrs when my lab finishes

I had some very nice live posting with spirit early game, but he seems to have really vanished and gone underground since.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

I'll read and post more in like 4 hrs when my lab finishes

I had some very nice live posting with spirit early game, but he seems to have really vanished and gone underground since.

how dare you?

[SpiritoftheRadio]

I'm pretty much in agreement with you analysis, i am just kind of lukewarm on voting brain since i havent seen anything about how he responds to the last 48hrs or so

[SpiritoftheRadio]

will has felt town to me since day 1, but also, i am worried the folks just wont get off him until hes dead, and am contemplating just getting it over with so we can move on

[SpiritoftheRadio]

My 500th post:

Squawk

(an homage to ND)