MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[ghug]

So, you didn't visit yourself N1?

I'm assuming if he's the real doc he lied about his visits to wifim scum and if he's the fake doc he's pretending to do that. An easily disprovable best-effort fakeclaim and Jamie seeing bona visit himself and scumreading him are both comically unlikely.

Him doubling down in it when called out is panic fakeclaim, not doc misleading. Doc would have just said “not telling you my night 2, but here’s my night 1”

Whoever he protected N1 is protectable tonight though which is useful information.

[ghug]

This is out of date. Read on.

I feel like this whole chain from damo was a townslip.

Why? I’m too far my damo scum tunnel to see it.

Scum probably caught Jamie's crumb, right? He wouldn't overlook the role he flipped after PR hunting him.

[ghug]

Lol wait there's a roleblock.

[BunnyGo]

I'm assuming if he's the real doc he lied about his visits to wifim scum and if he's the fake doc he's pretending to do that. An easily disprovable best-effort fakeclaim and Jamie seeing bona visit himself and scumreading him are both comically unlikely.

Him doubling down in it when called out is panic fakeclaim, not doc misleading. Doc would have just said “not telling you my night 2, but here’s my night 1”

Whoever he protected N1 is protectable tonight though which is useful information.

No. EVERYONE is potentially protectable is the important information. N1 doesn’t matter for the game of RPS they’re playing.

[Bonatogether]

This makes no sense.

If Bona visited himself Jamie would know he was doctor, right? [Would he think RB RB'd themselves jic of being a watch target? No ofcn].

So why would scumBona say that he could say he saved anyone, no? [I'm assuming no message to unsaved save target]

I'm confused.

I'm also clearly non-doc town or a highly skilled scum actor.

what are you saying

[BunnyGo]

Lol wait there's a roleblock.

ROFL. I forgot that too. Just vote bona.

[Bonatogether]

But before Bona posted that couldn't Jamie have see Target X (not Sweet) being visited by Bona?

if he visited me n1, he would have seen me visiting myself, thereby showing that i am doc. therefore this is impossible

So, you didn't visit yourself N1?

?

[BunnyGo]

I feel like this whole chain from damo was a townslip.

Why? I’m too far my damo scum tunnel to see it.

Scum probably caught Jamie's crumb, right? He wouldn't overlook the role he flipped after PR hunting him.

Nah.

Scum got lucky is my guess.

[ghug]

Him doubling down in it when called out is panic fakeclaim, not doc misleading. Doc would have just said “not telling you my night 2, but here’s my night 1”

Whoever he protected N1 is protectable tonight though which is useful information.

No. EVERYONE is potentially protectable is the important information. N1 doesn’t matter for the game of RPS they’re playing.

N1 protect is more likely to be protected though, as bona wanted to protect them to begin with and they weren't protected last night.

[ghug]

Why? I’m too far my damo scum tunnel to see it.

Scum probably caught Jamie's crumb, right? He wouldn't overlook the role he flipped after PR hunting him.

Nah.

Scum got lucky is my guess.

Even if bona's scum?

[BunnyGo]

Whoever he protected N1 is protectable tonight though which is useful information.

No. EVERYONE is potentially protectable is the important information. N1 doesn’t matter for the game of RPS they’re playing.

N1 protect is more likely to be protected though, as bona wanted to protect them to begin with and they weren't protected last night.

WIFOM/RPS is still the game…a doc under pressure wouldn’t give away N2…

[BunnyGo]

Scum probably caught Jamie's crumb, right? He wouldn't overlook the role he flipped after PR hunting him.

Nah.

Scum got lucky is my guess.

Even if bona's scum?

Especially since bona’s scum. They killed Jamie because he was coming around to going for bona.

[BunnyGo]

Ok. Gotta do dishes and put my kids to bed and do some actual work (heart feels me, but he has better balance on time since I flex more hours than he does).

Keep talking about some mechs. Some claims.

Dig into jimbo some more.

And DON’T claim @doc and @vig.

[ghug]

Nah.

Scum got lucky is my guess.

Even if bona's scum?

Especially since bona’s scum. They killed Jamie because he was coming around to going for bona.

And you think damo was ready to come out hard defending Bona?

[Bonatogether]

i lost the plot

bongo needs to shut up about what he thinks optimal pr play is. i don't care. i am revealing what i want to reveal

damo needs to be clear about what he's saying. beating around the bush goes over my head and is irritating

[ghug]

##VOTE bona

Don't shoot him yet but also don't CC him yet.

[damo666]

I'm going to bed.

Good night.

[brainbomb]

(Arriving at the castle on a motorcycle with Paschal Hutton riding with her, arms wrapped around Lacey)

Lacey Chabert: This is my castle. I am princess here. My kingdom is very strict. They may not tolerate me being a lesbian now.

Paschal Hutton: I don't know if Hallmark allows this either.
But my new values are telling me to just go with it.

Lacey: And my Princess values are telling me that if they dont like us; We should just ride to Sturgis.

Paschal Hutton: The Biker Rally? My urges are kicking in again. Would you really take me to sturgis?

Lacey: Sure. lets just go there now instead.

Butler: It's like 11 degrees out here. You two are riding around on a motorcycle in flannel and Jeans?

Bonatogether (2) BunnyGo ghug
Unvote (1) damo666

Bona is scheduled to die
Many hours remain

[worcej]

Every night he kept vigil
Every night he wondered if there would be a girl out there for him

Jebediah stared out his dark room as he heard a noise. Rain fell, steadily for hours now. Noise from the gutter above left a consistent ping.

He turned back to watching a Candace Cameron Bure Christmas movie about shoes.

A dog barked and Jebediah sat up and looked out the blinds again.

-Nothing-

He stared at Candace Cameron and admired her beautiful face, her perfect christmas sweater. And her love of shoes. It was enough that it made Jebediah grunt and smile.

Jebediah turned the TV off after hearing voices..

He stared out the window and then it hit him. Like a brick flung from its foundation he toppled. He could not tell how many times he had been hit; only that he had seen his last Hallmark Movie.

He stared up at the TV and the screen went red.

Jamiet99uk has died, he was Jeb Jeb the Small Town Watcher

Made to hotel, catching up now

[worcej]

My analysis:

People who clearly expressed a reason (or reasons) for voting Hamilton, and whose reason(s), at face value, made some sense, are as follows:

Jamiet99uk
BunnyGo
Temasek22
Bozo

People whose reason for voting Hamilton was unclear, or was not stated at all:

Ghug
JustAGuyNamedWill
Chaqa
Heartthrob

A person who did state a reason for voting Hamilton, but whose vote move looks extremely suspect:

Bonatogether.

Further notes:

(1) Of the 7 people who ended up on Hamilton at EoD:

Myself, Bunny, and JustWill, had voted Hamilton in the first 24 hours.
Chaqa, Bonatogether, Bozo and Heartthrob only voted Hamilton towards the end of the day.

(2) Only Ghug and Temasek voted Hamilton early, and then moved away, not to return to the wagon.

(3) Only Damo, Macca, Rdr and Worcej did not vote for Hamilton at all in D2.

This was posted 7 hours before EOD.

Bona ain't scum.

Disagree - Bona clearly is getting fingered by Jamie here.