Mafia 87: Madness in Mega-City One - GAME THREAD

[damo666]

I've got an inkling that Balki Andrews Sweet might be a pair of Judges. Just a small inkling. An inklingling if you will.

And not Andrews. Stupid phone.

[damo666]

I have remarkably few townreads

Chaqa food Kak kotp and getting there brain.

Actually given the number of potential scum maybe it's not that remarkable.

[damo666]

Hypo count

Dip 1 (dip)
Ghug 4 (ghug, Balki, sweet, damo)


Aligning myself with 3 scumrrads V a null lol

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Hypo count

Dip 1 (dip)
Ghug 4 (ghug, Balki, sweet, damo)


Aligning myself with 3 scumrrads V a null lol

Ghugs plan it is then

[snowy801]

A few points of order:

I never kill rdrivera d1. This is a known factor for me. I have no similar policy for Vecna, but didn't particularly have a reason to want to kill him. Similar low posters like fidelis/brian or late posters like worcej/kaka also did not garner any major interest, so I didn't find Vecna's major absence all that questionable
Though Balki wasn't my strongest town read I had no intentions of ever ending on him
I did not help vote out Brian, I wanted dip> nd> damo, I voted 2 seconds before EoD to avoid tie (here I'd like to pose my own question on whether you actually didn't realize that as this is a strange framework)
The valid vote comment: I do believe I misquoted someone, but someone voted ##vote Will and I wanted to ask if this could be made a valid vote, as it wasn't (since ##vote Just is a valid vote already my comment would make no sense otherwise)
I'm not sure what touch and feel PR element you purport (thanks Jamie) I hate, I dislike PRs as a whole. Most of my "town hero" games, if such games can be said to exist, come from a VT perspective I think
Not much to say on kotp now
Once again, the Balki push from my perspective was never serious and I once again inquire whether you actually don't see that, given that you seem to have deep dived me

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

If I were a cop, I would scan Kak.
Brain, perhaps analyze ghug?

[snowy801]

I also take requests if anyone has one to review

Nacho man please

[damo666]

Hypo count

Dip 1 (dip)
Ghug 4 (ghug, Balki, sweet, damo)


Aligning myself with 3 scumrrads V a null lol

Ghugs plan it is then

Ok that's decided

[snowy801]

I would like to hear snowy explain his progression on Hamilton and his progression on ghug.

I did not have too deep a thought on Brian throughout the day until a flash was proposed very late. I vaguely recall town reading him and my rushed ISO at the end town read him as well

I liked a fair few of the early comment throws ghug made [comments upon request] and I found his willingness to throw more town reads than scum reads around to be good. I would think between that and his willingness to throw an insanity flash wagon at the end to be very towny, though I will spend some time considering the implications of the 3p system before running with that idea

[snowy801]

I am somewhat being turned around on sweet being scum

[damo666]

Lets do some gunboat mafia here

Kak-vecna-worcej

How many scum in that crew

Pr(0) about 4%
Pr(3) about 4%

so Pr(1 or 2) > 90%

I would guess 1 and I would guess it's worcej.

[damo666]

I am somewhat being turned around on sweet being scum

Which direction?

[Jamiet99uk]

##CALL GM

If the Judge Fire player ignites someone, will we be told that they were killed due to Judge Fire? Or just that they died?

As I already clarified, when people die, the flavour will not reveal who killed them.

[snowy801]

Balki kinda sus ngl... perhaps he is imposter? Once we eject him, perhaps we may find out? Unless Balki wishes to perform a Visual Task like med scan before the time runs out, I'm afraid I will have to

##VOTE BALKI

Seems to be asking balki to doc claim here? Very weird and alot of flavour being forced into this post. Can be justified by hes just new and in pure experimentation.

This was one of my early reasons for scum reading kotp, btw. Not for the visual scan comment, as I think that's just a failed Among Us reference, but I found his wording on "perhaps he is imposter? Once we eject him, perhaps we may find out?" to be very unnatural and uninquisitive, as though the goal isn't determining alignment but killing someone.

I think I've mostly changed my mind on kotp now, but there's that

[Jamiet99uk]

By the way just curious Brian's dead vote counts towards MMA powers right

I can't really imagine it wouldn't but just in case

##Call GM

Yes, it would.
The death of the person voted out occurs after the Day phase has ended.

[snowy801]

I am somewhat being turned around on sweet being scum

Which direction?

Town -> Scum

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Alright, I gtg and will not be back before EoN. Everyone, please give a hypothetical "If I were cop I would scan X".

[damo666]

Alright, I gtg and will not be back before EoN. Everyone, please give a hypothetical "If I were cop I would scan X".

Only right at EON to avoid giving scum clues

[brainbomb]

A few points of order:

I never kill rdrivera d1. This is a known factor for me. I have no similar policy for Vecna, but didn't particularly have a reason to want to kill him. Similar low posters like fidelis/brian or late posters like worcej/kaka also did not garner any major interest, so I didn't find Vecna's major absence all that questionable
Though Balki wasn't my strongest town read I had no intentions of ever ending on him
I did not help vote out Brian, I wanted dip> nd> damo, I voted 2 seconds before EoD to avoid tie (here I'd like to pose my own question on whether you actually didn't realize that as this is a strange framework)
The valid vote comment: I do believe I misquoted someone, but someone voted ##vote Will and I wanted to ask if this could be made a valid vote, as it wasn't (since ##vote Just is a valid vote already my comment would make no sense otherwise)
I'm not sure what touch and feel PR element you purport (thanks Jamie) I hate, I dislike PRs as a whole. Most of my "town hero" games, if such games can be said to exist, come from a VT perspective I think
Not much to say on kotp now
Once again, the Balki push from my perspective was never serious and I once again inquire whether you actually don't see that, given that you seem to have deep dived me

Okay it took me a while to realize this was a reply to me. I am only really interested in the last thing you wrote where you say the balki push was never serious. At the time it occurred it took sweets wagon and diminished it from a 6 down to a 4, and took balki up to a 4. it seems fairly significant to me for final 20 minutes for this to occur. but if you say you were not taking balki serious as a scum candidate, and were not paying any attention to the wagon size I suppose I accept that answer.

[brainbomb]

If I were a cop, I would scan Kak.
Brain, perhaps analyze ghug?

oh dont worry, ghug will get the full brainbomb experience