Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[Bonatogether]

The scum explanation is that the list was fake and he sloppily failed to check if it was still up to date.

if it's fake, why wasn't it dropped at EoN?

Posting at Night is not allowed.
Plus, he wasn't here.

i think i obviously meant the time at the end of night (alternately known as the start of day) where many other people dropped posts

[Hamilton Brian]

If he is, in fact, Mafia, he is doing an excellent job of laying low and staying out of people's crosshairs.

That's Rivera for ya.

[Bonatogether]

guys the obvious busser on will is sweet. will and i had been going at it for hours, and he's been given way too much credit for being the first vote. i registered in the thread at the time that i thought i was getting onto a wagon with a scum member on it bussing, and i just don't see how it doesn't work out to be either me or sweet as the earliest bus, from an outside pov

So you moved from sweet to join him on Will although you continued to scumread sweet.

So presumably you either had doubts about sweet or you thought Will was GF. What do you think was sweet's motive for bussing the GF?

i never think about roles. i thought there was a bus, but i didn't read the role list until this game-day

[Bonatogether]

guys the obvious busser on will is sweet. will and i had been going at it for hours, and he's been given way too much credit for being the first vote. i registered in the thread at the time that i thought i was getting onto a wagon with a scum member on it bussing, and i just don't see how it doesn't work out to be either me or sweet as the earliest bus, from an outside pov

Aside from the idea I have that I "think" sweet is ok, it's also not like mafia wouldn't get an early bus vote on. Why wouldn't sweet have moved if Will was in trouble? I haven't looked at the EOD to see that particular timeline.

he hedged on some posts, and put will as third on his would-vote list, which gives him lots of outs. he was very sporadically present at eod, and didn't mention will after his vote.

[Hamilton Brian]

Against my better nature I'd take the gamble of putting Sweet up today then, on the hypothesis that it was a very early bus.

[Bonatogether]

Against my better nature I'd take the gamble of putting Sweet up today then, on the hypothesis that it was a very early bus.

put the vote down then

[BunnyGo]

I also feel horrible about this, but Sweet is on my scum list, so:

##Vote sweetandcool

I'm willing to switch to my other three reads, name Jamie, Bunny, or Food.

Cmon man…seriously? Help a guy out in not tunneling on you as scum.

[BunnyGo]

I also feel horrible about this, but Sweet is on my scum list, so:

##Vote sweetandcool

I'm willing to switch to my other three reads, name Jamie, Bunny, or Food.

Na it's fine.

Though I humbly request you switch to your top scumrrad, Food.

[BunnyGo]

I also feel horrible about this, but Sweet is on my scum list, so:

##Vote sweetandcool

I'm willing to switch to my other three reads, name Jamie, Bunny, or Food.

Na it's fine.

Though I humbly request you switch to your top scumrrad, Food.

I wouldn't necessarily make him my top scum read, but I would like a rationale before doing so.

Ffs. We JUST TOLD you.

[BunnyGo]

Bozo is doing the thing he does as scum where he focuses on the possible instead of the probable.

Yeah. Let’s kill him.

I think if he was scum he would've been all over me by now.

That is actually his #1 scummeta. tunnel on vecna

Good to know

[BunnyGo]

I feel like this is the first game where I’ve seen the use of “anchor.” What is that?

Damo, you have to get off of me. I mean, really, pull back the hounds. Unless you’re scum.

Clearly I haven’t spent enough time reading.
Letting all things be equal, Bunny appears most town.
Enough analysis makes me think we solve this by Day 3 or 4.
Reflect on what Will published; the answers have to be there.
Keep on truckin’, y’all.

Sweet, if I met you walking down through our town, I’d high five you and say, “Got past D1, man!”

##vote hamilton brian

##vote hambone

[Lord of Words]

Na it's fine.

Though I humbly request you switch to your top scumrrad, Food.

I wouldn't necessarily make him my top scum read, but I would like a rationale before doing so.

Ffs. We JUST TOLD you.

Note the time, that I'm on EST, and in NYC.

[worcej]

##vote Vecna

[BunnyGo]

That's an awful lot of town reads.

Could you tell me more about your opinion on Food and damo's connection?

That reads list is so fake. ##vote lordofwords

the guy was unaware that the target of the NK has subbed out.

Do you really think that was faked?

Because that is generally what you actually call a real townslip.

No.

Town who claim to have read everything three times would be aware of actions.

Scum putting together a reads list would be aware of players. And aware of NK. But not as aware of non DK/NK changes as they put it together.

This is closer to a scum slip.

[BunnyGo]

I guarantee you’re wrong.

By all mean, explain why I am wrong about you in your eyes, then.

Even the consecutive post exchange with bunny just oozes townyness. Dude is visibly proud of what he produced and dares anyone to disagree.

LoW went from absent to locktown pretty much instantly.

Hmm. That’s an interesting point. You may be right.

[BunnyGo]

##vote sweetandcool

dude is openly powerwolfing.

I have not been wrong on this slots alignment in a single game.

Really?

Hmm. Will need to reread.

[Bonatogether]

jamie spent much of d1 protecting will

now he protects sweet. coincidence?

[worcej]

This game just got made a lot easier by the newer players putting in a few killer posts that pretty much absolves them.

The irritation with certain players is palpable.

Balki Bartokomous
kingofthepirates
Rdrivera2005
Bonatogether
Bozotheclown
Spartaculous
BunnyGo
Jamiet99uk
damo666
Lord of Words
ghug
Vecna
The above group is probably all town, in no particular order

Leaving a very easy poe:
Hamilton Brian
Sweetandcool
worcej

Maybe im wrong about 1, which is likely either Rdrivera, Kotp or Bona if some weird bussing occured.

But for now, fuck whether any of these slots bussed or not, thats a crapshoot anyway. Reads reign supreme.

This just comes off as a low effort listing of players.

What makes the POE here? What's any of the rational?

[worcej]

And I've changed my mind about food, I have come to the conclusion he's town.

Glad you got there.

[worcej]

I'd like the vote reconsidered, so I'm happy to answer questions about my reads list and myself to that end.

Question 1: Why did you think Dr.Fidelis was still in the game?

Question 2: Why did you think Foodcoats was still in the game?

If you actually "read the thread three times" and you are an experienced player of this kind of game, I find it very hard to understand how you would completely fail to notice people dying. Player deaths, and the accompanying role flips, are pretty much the most important pieces of information revealed during the game.

Your reads list appears to be what it would have been after 24 hours of Day One. It is currently the latter part of Day Two.

This is all highly suspect.

Stealing Jamie's post to piggy back - but I'm very not in alignment with the agreement that LoW is "lock-town" and believe it's more of a ploy than anything.