M1019 – Once Upon A Time… [GAME THREAD] [HIDDEN]

[rdrivera2005]

Do you think my reasons for not wanting kaka are scummy? Or do you just think the fact that I tried to save him is the only thing worth looking at? I also don't recall trying to push damo? When was that.

You seem to not like both Kak and lfischl wagon and asked Snowy about Damo. Maybe I am misinterpretation this, but I thought you were saying you prefer Damo over the other two. Ghug questioned you and you answered "why would we kill either of them". I thought you were referring to Uber and lfischl. And later you said again you don't want to kill Kaka, so I assumed you want to kill Damo.

[Jamiet99uk]

I don't have much to add at this point. Still think Durga is town and assuming Damo is. The Ghug vs Bunny interaction is fairly standard for both of them. I don't know why Ghug is calling Bunny "disgusting", that's rather over the top to be honest.

The scum are probably in the pool of Boat, Doom, Bonatogether, Rdrivera and B-Sabi? Put Bunny in that pool too I guess.

Why do you think Doom is a more likely Kak busser than anyone else?

(I didn't call Bunny disgusting, for the record, though I did call one of his actions despicable, so take that as you will)

I didn't specifically consider the bussing angle, it was just a quick surface reflection. I suppose you could actually therefore put DeathLlama in there too because they also voted Kak.

You say disgusting, I say potato, etc. What was so despicable exactly? I wasn't sure what justified that extreme reaction.

[Jamiet99uk]

i've looked over some of kakarroto's posts and have concluded that he was probably scum

Hur hur hur.

[Durga]

Do you think my reasons for not wanting kaka are scummy? Or do you just think the fact that I tried to save him is the only thing worth looking at? I also don't recall trying to push damo? When was that.

You seem to not like both Kak and lfischl wagon and asked Snowy about Damo. Maybe I am misinterpretation this, but I thought you were saying you prefer Damo over the other two. Ghug questioned you and you answered "why would we kill either of them". I thought you were referring to Uber and lfischl. And later you said again you don't want to kill Kaka, so I assumed you want to kill Damo.

No I said snowy damo because I didn't want to kill either of them. I spent all day voting uber and then ended on ifischl.

[Durga]

I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt rdr and say you misread as opposed to actively try and mischaracterize my d1 actions. Also pls comment on my reasons why I didn't want to kill Kak - do you think that was scummy reasoning?

[rdrivera2005]

Do you think my reasons for not wanting kaka are scummy? Or do you just think the fact that I tried to save him is the only thing worth looking at? I also don't recall trying to push damo? When was that.

You seem to not like both Kak and lfischl wagon and asked Snowy about Damo. Maybe I am misinterpretation this, but I thought you were saying you prefer Damo over the other two. Ghug questioned you and you answered "why would we kill either of them". I thought you were referring to Uber and lfischl. And later you said again you don't want to kill Kaka, so I assumed you want to kill Damo.

No I said snowy damo because I didn't want to kill either of them. I spent all day voting uber and then ended on ifischl.

The vote on Uber I didn't see (it was as Invalid on bot). Well, I would put you down to a null then, but you are still on the POE, sorry.

[ghug]

Do you think my reasons for not wanting kaka are scummy? Or do you just think the fact that I tried to save him is the only thing worth looking at? I also don't recall trying to push damo? When was that.

You seem to not like both Kak and lfischl wagon and asked Snowy about Damo. Maybe I am misinterpretation this, but I thought you were saying you prefer Damo over the other two. Ghug questioned you and you answered "why would we kill either of them". I thought you were referring to Uber and lfischl. And later you said again you don't want to kill Kaka, so I assumed you want to kill Damo.

I think she said that about snowy and damo.

[Durga]

You seem to not like both Kak and lfischl wagon and asked Snowy about Damo. Maybe I am misinterpretation this, but I thought you were saying you prefer Damo over the other two. Ghug questioned you and you answered "why would we kill either of them". I thought you were referring to Uber and lfischl. And later you said again you don't want to kill Kaka, so I assumed you want to kill Damo.

No I said snowy damo because I didn't want to kill either of them. I spent all day voting uber and then ended on ifischl.

The vote on Uber I didn't see (it was as Invalid on bot). Well, I would put you down to a null then, but you are still on the POE, sorry.

Which begs the question - did you even read my posts before deciding I was your #1 choice as scum? And why am I still in the POE? Just because why not?

Do you have any kind of strong scumread on anyone? Can you explain what makes the people not in your POE towny?

[rdrivera2005]

I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt rdr and say you misread as opposed to actively try and mischaracterize my d1 actions. Also pls comment on my reasons why I didn't want to kill Kak - do you think that was scummy reasoning?

You just said you want to vote someone unlikely to participate, you didn't gave any reasoning about Kak (at least on D1, didn't read later). This isn't scummy per se, but it's also a good way to drive the voting away of an active partner.

[ghug]

I don't have much to add at this point. Still think Durga is town and assuming Damo is. The Ghug vs Bunny interaction is fairly standard for both of them. I don't know why Ghug is calling Bunny "disgusting", that's rather over the top to be honest.

The scum are probably in the pool of Boat, Doom, Bonatogether, Rdrivera and B-Sabi? Put Bunny in that pool too I guess.

Why do you think Doom is a more likely Kak busser than anyone else?

(I didn't call Bunny disgusting, for the record, though I did call one of his actions despicable, so take that as you will)

I didn't specifically consider the bussing angle, it was just a quick surface reflection. I suppose you could actually therefore put DeathLlama in there too because they also voted Kak.

You say disgusting, I say potato, etc. What was so despicable exactly? I wasn't sure what justified that extreme reaction.

Bunny has an established pattern of trying to use technological shortcomings (like the who's online detail page) to game the game. Beyond the illogicality of his thoughts about QT being down, I'm sick of him trying to do those things.

[Durga]

And for the record I don't have particularly strong reads for scum atm, but I'm waiting till the day to figure it out and see where the discussion takes us. This whole POE nonsense everyone is always going on about is exhausting. Everyone is in the POE unless clear. Don't overlook certain people just because you think they might be town. I also don't think we should be ignoring doom or Sabi just because they are newer.

There's most likely a deep scum that isn't in all this silly "POE" shit so maybe stop making it easy for more than half the game to coast. I think ghug navigating in only finding scum in a small group is the scummiest part of his game so far. I can't understand why town ghug would rule out so many people so quickly

[rdrivera2005]

No I said snowy damo because I didn't want to kill either of them. I spent all day voting uber and then ended on ifischl.

The vote on Uber I didn't see (it was as Invalid on bot). Well, I would put you down to a null then, but you are still on the POE, sorry.

Which begs the question - did you even read my posts before deciding I was your #1 choice as scum? And why am I still in the POE? Just because why not?

Do you have any kind of strong scumread on anyone? Can you explain what makes the people not in your POE towny?

I read the last two hours of D1. My analysis was only based on this.

I don't have a strong scumread on anyone, that's why I was trying to dig into this, this is the better info we have (a scum wagon, two town wagons and a fake claim). Still not perfect because a lot of players (including me) just missed EOD1.

About my list, I don't see scum bussing Kak on D1 that way, specially Ghug and Llama. Doom have been pretty towny too. Vecna could be the busser as he just didn't came back, so Bunny is still on the POE. TFB I townread too, but it's a weaker read. Did I forgot someone?

[Durga]

Like it's legit irritating "oh we're gonna kill off these four players first and then see" like shut UP that's not how this works and each day is gonna get us new info so just stop!!!

[Durga]

Also rdr my last two messages are just in general not just directed at you sorry lol

[ghug]

Durga, do you think scum Sabi would openly ask for Doom to claim PR like that?

Do you think town Sabi would take me offering them a position in my towncore at face value without any skepticism like they did?

Boat, same question.

[Durga]

Durga, do you think scum Sabi would openly ask for Doom to claim PR like that?

Do you think town Sabi would take me offering them a position in my towncore at face value without any skepticism like they did?

Boat, same question.

Why not??? What do you know about scum!Sabi? It's totally within their range.

I can't recall how Sabi reacted to your town core thing but I don't think either instance is necessarily alignment indicative.

[ghug]

Like it's legit irritating "oh we're gonna kill off these four players first and then see" like shut UP that's not how this works and each day is gonna get us new info so just stop!!!

Who said the pool is set in stone? There are four players who look worse than the other players. That's where I want to be looking right now. That doesn't mean ignoring anyone else (except for damo, Boat, and Sabi, my blessed towncore).

[rdrivera2005]

And for the record I don't have particularly strong reads for scum atm, but I'm waiting till the day to figure it out and see where the discussion takes us. This whole POE nonsense everyone is always going on about is exhausting. Everyone is in the POE unless clear. Don't overlook certain people just because you think they might be town. I also don't think we should be ignoring doom or Sabi just because they are newer.

There's most likely a deep scum that isn't in all this silly "POE" shit so maybe stop making it easy for more than half the game to coast. I think ghug navigating in only finding scum in a small group is the scummiest part of his game so far. I can't understand why town ghug would rule out so many people so quickly

I am not ruling out anyone, but I strongly disagree with you about POE. Last game town won basically won by building a towncore and voting in the POE.

And how do we play without sorting people between who we townread and who we scumread? My POE is just the people I don't townread and would consider voting tomorrow. And it could change if we got new info.

[ghug]

Durga, do you think scum Sabi would openly ask for Doom to claim PR like that?

Do you think town Sabi would take me offering them a position in my towncore at face value without any skepticism like they did?

Boat, same question.

Why not??? What do you know about scum!Sabi? It's totally within their range.

I can't recall how Sabi reacted to your town core thing but I don't think either instance is necessarily alignment indicative.

You know them better than I do. That's why I'm asking you.

[Durga]

And for the record I don't have particularly strong reads for scum atm, but I'm waiting till the day to figure it out and see where the discussion takes us. This whole POE nonsense everyone is always going on about is exhausting. Everyone is in the POE unless clear. Don't overlook certain people just because you think they might be town. I also don't think we should be ignoring doom or Sabi just because they are newer.

There's most likely a deep scum that isn't in all this silly "POE" shit so maybe stop making it easy for more than half the game to coast. I think ghug navigating in only finding scum in a small group is the scummiest part of his game so far. I can't understand why town ghug would rule out so many people so quickly

I am not ruling out anyone, but I strongly disagree with you about POE. Last game town won basically won by building a towncore and voting in the POE.

And how do we play without sorting people between who we townread and who we scumread? My POE is just the people I don't townread and would consider voting tomorrow. And it could change if we got new info.

Actually town won last game because scum killed randoms instead of clears and made bad choices.

It's fine to have your townreads and what not but it's fucking irritating that half this game has decided that one half is untouchable for the near future. Like no.