Mafia 86: Accidents Happen... - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I am really struggling to townread people this game. I'm not that interested in pursuing Will or Frog anytime soon even if there are little doubts, and my townreads on Chaqa and brain persist, but that's about it.

Why are so many people scumreading brain? Am I missing something??

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I am really struggling to townread people this game. I'm not that interested in pursuing Will or Frog anytime soon even if there are little doubts, and my townreads on Chaqa and brain persist, but that's about it.

Why are so many people townreading brain? Am I missing something??

I meant to say townreading. How is brain town??!?

[bozotheclown]

also, i dont actually think youre scum at all brainbomb.

I think will is town

I think foodcoats is town.

I think bozo is probably town.

I think the 2 new guys are probably town.

I think bunny is probably town

I think scum is in [chaqa, jamiet, damo, HB] - sweet is still hard to read for me

Eh, I find it far more plausible that scum is nervous because town got their big prize ticket and they were caught off of the wagon.

Even sleep's "at least I participated" today speech fits much better in a world where he's semi-dickhurt his team was absent to save him.

I wouldnt consider chaqas and ghugs vote bussing.

I find it way more likely there were 5 town in the first 5 sleep voters than that theres 2 scum in the 7 people that ended up on him.

What changed your opinion of Chaqa?

This was a cross post, but are considering Chaqa and ghug as being "caught off of the wagon"?

[bozotheclown]

Maybe bozo is just scum.

If you think I am mafia do you think I am trying to protect one of these 5, and if so, which one?

Unsure. It's less about protection and more that you're spending time being snarky and difficult rather than plowing through someone with lots of evidence and questions like you normally do (obviously you're doing some of that with Vecna).

I reject the premise that I am being either of those things.

[Vecna]

also, i dont actually think youre scum at all brainbomb.

I think will is town

I think foodcoats is town.

I think bozo is probably town.

I think the 2 new guys are probably town.

I think bunny is probably town

I think scum is in [chaqa, jamiet, damo, HB] - sweet is still hard to read for me

Eh, I find it far more plausible that scum is nervous because town got their big prize ticket and they were caught off of the wagon.

Even sleep's "at least I participated" today speech fits much better in a world where he's semi-dickhurt his team was absent to save him.

I wouldnt consider chaqas and ghugs vote bussing.

I find it way more likely there were 5 town in the first 5 sleep voters than that theres 2 scum in the 7 people that ended up on him.

What changed your opinion of Chaqa?

He's still in my list of most likely scum

Nothing changed

I meant that those votes of Ghug and Chaqa could never be considered bussing votes. Noone would give them any credit for those votes. It just invites suspicion. (which in itself can be seen as a way again to garner some credit I guess, but alas).

My vote timing was basically the last vote that could be perceived as having any merit to get credit.

The one thing that gives me some pause is that both Ghug and Chaqa seem to be townreading eachother.....and theyre usually pretty good at figuring eachother out. Ghug figuring out Chaqa more so than the other way around though. (Hence also my earlier comment about Ghug doing these mini-things to get on people's goodsides. Ive identified some minors things aimed mainly towards myself and towards chaqa, although there was some towards others as well)

[Frogsterking]

@ghug
@darg

#1

How did the sweet (godfather) elimination affect your plans for this game?

#2

Is there any possibility ghug was distancing from sweet d1 and didn't actually want to kill sweet?

#3

What have you noticed about each other that you haven't shared?

[Vecna]

After some more consideration im sad to note that I did not really like that Darg post.

[Chaqa]

I don't really need any credit for voting Sweet. I was not voting to kill Sweet, I was voting to save Bunny. I think the logical thing to do is to pair me with Bunny, not Ghug, if you think I'm scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

I am really struggling to townread people this game. I'm not that interested in pursuing Will or Frog anytime soon even if there are little doubts, and my townreads on Chaqa and brain persist, but that's about it.

Why are so many people townreading brain? Am I missing something??

I meant to say townreading. How is brain town??!?

I stated my reasoning, in the big reads list I posted that you had specifically asked for.

[Jamiet99uk]

@ghug
@darg

#1

How did the sweet (godfather) elimination affect your plans for this game?

#2

Is there any possibility ghug was distancing from sweet d1 and didn't actually want to kill sweet?

#3

What have you noticed about each other that you haven't shared?

@Froggo:

You have an un-answered question from me, last page back, if you have a moment.

[BunnyGo]

Eh, I find it far more plausible that scum is nervous because town got their big prize ticket and they were caught off of the wagon.

Even sleep's "at least I participated" today speech fits much better in a world where he's semi-dickhurt his team was absent to save him.

I wouldnt consider chaqas and ghugs vote bussing.

I find it way more likely there were 5 town in the first 5 sleep voters than that theres 2 scum in the 7 people that ended up on him.

That’s insightful re:sweets last post

[Vecna]

I don't really need any credit for voting Sweet. I was not voting to kill Sweet, I was voting to save Bunny. I think the logical thing to do is to pair me with Bunny, not Ghug, if you think I'm scum.

It wasnt meant as a pairing.

More so that id feel its about equally likely that either of you is scum

My reads are a bit of a mess anyway

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Why are so many people townreading brain? Am I missing something??

I meant to say townreading. How is brain town??!?

I stated my reasoning, in the big reads list I posted that you had specifically asked for.

“ Overall he is giving me town vibes; it’s a meta read but that’s all I’ve got.”

I guess I understand that a lot of reads are based on this, but did everyone suddenly come to this conclusion?

[Vecna]

Eh, I find it far more plausible that scum is nervous because town got their big prize ticket and they were caught off of the wagon.

Even sleep's "at least I participated" today speech fits much better in a world where he's semi-dickhurt his team was absent to save him.

I wouldnt consider chaqas and ghugs vote bussing.

I find it way more likely there were 5 town in the first 5 sleep voters than that theres 2 scum in the 7 people that ended up on him.

That’s insightful re:sweets last post

I dno man, its probably quite dangerous to add any actual meaning to it

[ghug]

I am really struggling to townread people this game. I'm not that interested in pursuing Will or Frog anytime soon even if there are little doubts, and my townreads on Chaqa and brain persist, but that's about it.

Why are so many people townreading brain? Am I missing something??

I meant to say townreading. How is brain town??!?

He's just the right amount of crazy.

[Vecna]

goddamn its johny big horse observing our game.

I miss that guy

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Why are so many people townreading brain? Am I missing something??

I meant to say townreading. How is brain town??!?

He's just the right amount of crazy.

So you townread brain? Why?

[brainbomb]

I think most sensible people have accepted that if theres two bussers on sweet, brainbomb is the best person to nightkill here

[dargorygel]

@ghug
@darg

#1

How did the sweet (godfather) elimination affect your plans for this game?

#2

Is there any possibility ghug was distancing from sweet d1 and didn't actually want to kill sweet?

#3

What have you noticed about each other that you haven't shared?

1) not at all. I think I would have been townreading him though. But i haven't really thought through his case.
2) sure. He voted sweet early, iirc. He might have been making himself look good. But that doesn't prove his scum. Just something he would do IF scum.
3) i like his abs, his sweet smile, and his collection of butterflies.

Frog, have you considered that asking a lot of deep questions during the night aids scum?

[brainbomb]

or something about ms rachel really turned them on