M1010 Mini-Mafia

[brainbomb]

You have moved Xorxes from town to scum.

You have done a complete 180 on me, from saying "there is 0% chance jamie is town" to suddenly putting me in your town reads list.

Could you tell us about these two things? What changed your mind?

None of my thoughts day 1 were set in stone. And I think my read on you is fueled by habitual dislike of how you comport yourself

Okay, thanks. Re-thinking your reads is a perfectly reasonable thing to do.

Can you explain why you claimed Vengeful at EoD? What was that all about?

was to see how youd react to being my target

[Jamiet99uk]

I see.

[damo666]

Something else it occurs to me to ask:

Was anyone Roleblocked?

I was not.

Jamie always does this. I really don't know why. Seems a scummy question to me.

[brainbomb]

it isnt

[Jamiet99uk]

Something else it occurs to me to ask:

Was anyone Roleblocked?

I was not.

Jamie always does this. I really don't know why. Seems a scummy question to me.

Why is it scummy?

If we establish that the roleblock was used (which could be an explanation for there being only one kill), then we know that the scum cannot use the roleblock tonight.

[brainbomb]

I was roleblocked

[Jamiet99uk]

Something else it occurs to me to ask:

Was anyone Roleblocked?

I was not.

Jamie always does this. I really don't know why. Seems a scummy question to me.

Why is it scummy?

If we establish that the roleblock was used (which could be an explanation for there being only one kill), then we know that the scum cannot use the roleblock tonight.

Sorry I'm being daft with the highlighted part. They couldn't have Roleblocked BunnyGo, I assume, because he was dead. Right?

[brainbomb]

scum evidently has a sense of humor

[Jamiet99uk]

I was roleblocked

How interesting.

[bozotheclown]

kgray had a good point about SK24 invalid vote occurring not long after this exchange between Foxcastle and worcej:

I am trying not to get into a worthless argument with you that will lead me to scum read you almost immediately based on your responses. Everything else you've done so far is townie and I wanna keep you there instead of WIFOM'ing away.

That makes SK24's claim that she intended to vote for Foxcastle 2 hours earlier than she did more believable.

If the scum team is bo_sox/Foxcastle/worcej, SK24 correctly identified 2 scum and implicated the third by the timing of her vote.

How does it make it more believable? I don't follow your logic.

She said she intended to vote for Foxcastle when she made her invalid vote. What kgray pointed out shows that she had a reason to connect you and Foxcastle at the time of her invalid vote.

[xorxes]

Something else it occurs to me to ask:

Was anyone Roleblocked?

I was not.

Jamie always does this. I really don't know why. Seems a scummy question to me.

It is not a scummy question in the sense that it doesn't tell mafia anything they don't already know. It may be scummy in the sense that it is pointless: if anyone was roleblocked and they want to tell us they will, it is useless to tell us that you were not roleblocked, so it may be a way of doing busywork. But I think Jamie does it because he does.

[bozotheclown]

Something else it occurs to me to ask:

Was anyone Roleblocked?

I was not.

Jamie always does this. I really don't know why. Seems a scummy question to me.

Why is it scummy?

If we establish that the roleblock was used (which could be an explanation for there being only one kill), then we know that the scum cannot use the roleblock tonight.

Can Vengeful be roleblocked?

[xorxes]

Something else it occurs to me to ask:

Was anyone Roleblocked?

I was not.

Jamie always does this. I really don't know why. Seems a scummy question to me.

Why is it scummy?

If we establish that the roleblock was used (which could be an explanation for there being only one kill), then we know that the scum cannot use the roleblock tonight.

And I had not thought of that, true that they can only use the roleblock in one of three nights.

[xorxes]

I was roleblocked

How interesting.

Hard to believe that they would use that in the first night.

[brainbomb]

I wasnt roleblocked. im addicted to lying

[Jamiet99uk]

Jamie always does this. I really don't know why. Seems a scummy question to me.

Why is it scummy?

If we establish that the roleblock was used (which could be an explanation for there being only one kill), then we know that the scum cannot use the roleblock tonight.

Can Vengeful be roleblocked?

Chaqa said they couldn't be nightkilled, so my instinct was that they couldn't be interfered with by the Mafia in general. The Vengeful Townie would be a very weak role if they could be roleblocked, because of course when N1 begins, Mafia know who the Vengeful Townie is.

But still:

-------------
##CALL GM:

In this setup, can the Vengeful Townie be prevented from exacting their revenge, if the Mafia roleblocks them?
-------------

This is all rather academic, of course, if Brainbomb is telling the truth that he was Roleblocked...

[Jamiet99uk]

I wasnt roleblocked. im addicted to lying

Are you lying now?

[brainbomb]

I just gotta laugh at the people saying im different than last game. ya, being alignment cop tends to do that. Plus not knowing who might be prs playing poorly.

fwiw I had bunny and kgray as null or town mostly. i never saw anything scunmy hy kgray

[bozotheclown]

Why is it scummy?

If we establish that the roleblock was used (which could be an explanation for there being only one kill), then we know that the scum cannot use the roleblock tonight.

Can Vengeful be roleblocked?

Chaqa said they couldn't be nightkilled, so my instinct was that they couldn't be interfered with by the Mafia in general. The Vengeful Townie would be a very weak role if they could be roleblocked, because of course when N1 begins, Mafia know who the Vengeful Townie is.

But still:

-------------
##CALL GM:

In this setup, can the Vengeful Townie be prevented from exacting their revenge, if the Mafia roleblocks them?
-------------

This is all rather academic, of course, if Brainbomb is telling the truth that he was Roleblocked...

If it is possible and that is why there was not a second NK, we would never be able to establish that.

[xorxes]

xorxes has a scumtell

Theory xorx identified bunny and kgray as PR candidates right away

I doubt even town!you would believe that. So my new scumtell is that I talk to my victims before I kill them? That's convenient, because I have probably talked to everyone this game, so whoever is killed I can be accused of having talked to them before I killed them.