M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[brainbomb]

GM Note

yoyoyozo has replaced Chaqa

chaqa has been replaced by yoyoyozo

[BunnyGo]

Found one boys!

Yep...still looks bad.

Why does this look bad? It was actually my sentiment even earlier than when Dip posted it.

There was more than an hour left.

Encouraging town to lump up and not have volatility is bad.

ESPECIALLY now we know one wagon was town, it's possible a scum player saying "OH! OH! Town should really get together and stop fighting! Look at me helping! Oh...and don't worry about the lead wagons being town..."

[BunnyGo]

GM Note

yoyoyozo has replaced Chaqa

chaqa has been replaced by yoyoyozo

Thank you yoyo

@chaqa, I hope your partner recovers quickly!

[Dousing]

Anyway, I’m trying not to get burnt out so I’m just stick to lurking for the rest of my night (irl not in game) unless I see something that requires my attention.

If you need something from me you should probably ask within an hour.

[BunnyGo]

I don't know if Vecna has ever realized this, but I am practically on board with all of his takes when we are Town. Vecna must be Town this game because almost everything he says so far makes sense to me.

IIRC wasn't he scum just last game and you were on board with his takes then?

So on board with his takes I scanned him N2 because I thought he was scum....

Ah right...forgot that

[BunnyGo]

I CAUGHT UP!

GOOD NIGHT EVERYBODY!

[Dousing]

Yep...still looks bad.

Why does this look bad? It was actually my sentiment even earlier than when Dip posted it.

There was more than an hour left.

Encouraging town to lump up and not have volatility is bad.

ESPECIALLY now we know one wagon was town, it's possible a scum player saying "OH! OH! Town should really get together and stop fighting! Look at me helping! Oh...and don't worry about the lead wagons being town..."

Hindsight’s 20/20 and at least foxcastle was present unlike you Bunny (I’m aware of the hypocrisy of my statement)

[Dousing]

Why does this look bad? It was actually my sentiment even earlier than when Dip posted it.

There was more than an hour left.

Encouraging town to lump up and not have volatility is bad.

ESPECIALLY now we know one wagon was town, it's possible a scum player saying "OH! OH! Town should really get together and stop fighting! Look at me helping! Oh...and don't worry about the lead wagons being town..."

Hindsight’s 20/20 and at least foxcastle was present unlike you Bunny (I’m aware of the hypocrisy of my statement)

But yeah, it was kinda sus from Foxcastle though (even if hindsight is 20/20)

[sweetandcool]

Yep...still looks bad.

Why does this look bad? It was actually my sentiment even earlier than when Dip posted it.

There was more than an hour left.

Encouraging town to lump up and not have volatility is bad.

ESPECIALLY now we know one wagon was town, it's possible a scum player saying "OH! OH! Town should really get together and stop fighting! Look at me helping! Oh...and don't worry about the lead wagons being town..."

I agree. But coming from Dip it looks a whole lot more like newbie town.

That sentiment makes sense in other contexts, so he misapplied it here.

[Yoyoyozo]

I'm going to be honest, I'm not reading this entire thread. Hi everyone.

[sweetandcool]

Looking "scummy" is kind of my Town meta.

Is that true??? I don’t think that’s true… I also don’t 100% know what you mean by “looking ‘scummy’” but regardless I think you’re lying (a little bit)

It's an oversimplification. I won't elaborate even though many players probably understand my Town game by now. Then again, Mafia stumbled face first into me last game, so who knows.

[sweetandcool]

I'm going to be honest, I'm not reading this entire thread. Hi everyone.

Honestly, there might not be much of interest other than VCA anyways.

[Foxcastle]

Yep...still looks bad.

Why does this look bad? It was actually my sentiment even earlier than when Dip posted it.

There was more than an hour left.

Encouraging town to lump up and not have volatility is bad.

ESPECIALLY now we know one wagon was town, it's possible a scum player saying "OH! OH! Town should really get together and stop fighting! Look at me helping! Oh...and don't worry about the lead wagons being town..."

I disagree with this, mostly because I think you're trying to inject "lumping up" into what he was saying and I don't think that's justified. Sure, he said "consolidate," but I would interpret more as encouraging one-vote wagons to find something more useful to do.

Honestly, I kind of scum read you for this, Bunny.

[Foxcastle]

Why does this look bad? It was actually my sentiment even earlier than when Dip posted it.

There was more than an hour left.

Encouraging town to lump up and not have volatility is bad.

ESPECIALLY now we know one wagon was town, it's possible a scum player saying "OH! OH! Town should really get together and stop fighting! Look at me helping! Oh...and don't worry about the lead wagons being town..."

Hindsight’s 20/20 and at least foxcastle was present unlike you Bunny (I’m aware of the hypocrisy of my statement)

I was barely present, and I was not at all present the last 30 minutes or so.

[ghug]

I flipped real quick on this one so just a town

Your answer to this question is the one I care about the least, unfortunately.

This is the town!flav I remember.

I have no memory of scum!flav to compare to.

It's really weird that you said this twice

[Foxcastle]

I'm going to be honest, I'm not reading this entire thread. Hi everyone.

Hi yoyo, I would encourage you to read the whole thread closely. There's a lot of nuance and some really excellent, well thought-out points that are made right from the beginning of the thread. It's very much worth it. Enlightening, I'd even say.

[ghug]

I don't know if Vecna has ever realized this, but I am practically on board with all of his takes when we are Town. Vecna must be Town this game because almost everything he says so far makes sense to me.

IIRC wasn't he scum just last game and you were on board with his takes then?

So on board with his takes I scanned him N2 because I thought he was scum....

Do you townread me? Are you concerned that one of us is buddying the other?

[sweetandcool]

Why does this look bad? It was actually my sentiment even earlier than when Dip posted it.

There was more than an hour left.

Encouraging town to lump up and not have volatility is bad.

ESPECIALLY now we know one wagon was town, it's possible a scum player saying "OH! OH! Town should really get together and stop fighting! Look at me helping! Oh...and don't worry about the lead wagons being town..."

I disagree with this, mostly because I think you're trying to inject "lumping up" into what he was saying and I don't think that's justified. Sure, he said "consolidate," but I would interpret more as encouraging one-vote wagons to find something more useful to do.

Honestly, I kind of scum read you for this, Bunny.

Huh? Sounds like you are saying the same thing as Bunny.

[ghug]

Hi Yoyo I love you

[DemonRHK]

GM Note

yoyoyozo has replaced Chaqa

chaqa has been replaced by yoyoyozo

Welp.