M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[snowy801]

Yknow I expected most of the usual suspects to take jasnah at face value, but ghug.....really? your vote is on jasnah?

Oh I changed my mind a page or two ago but haven't moved yet.

##VOTE Durga

so scummy it can't be scum?

Who, ghug or Durga?

[TheFlyingBoat]

Re reading the earlier exchanges funnily enough has flipped me on Durga and given me very strong town reads. I still the PE is town and think his grilling of Durga while incorrect was coming from a townie place and appreciated his other posts. Jasnah is all but confirmed VT to me based on this reread and unless there is another CC I buy that Bunny is the Miller. If we could start a bandwagon on literally anyone else I'd be much happier.

As for bunny, if I am wrong on bunny, I think it is almost certain that worcej is also scum. I still get slight scum reads based on the desire to quick hammer jasnah, but I don't necessarily view that as ironclad proof of anything

I think Jamie's obstinance here is town-ish, though I really, really think they should reconsider their view. Jasnah has proven in the past to be a good scum hunter.

I have slight scum reads on Sabi based on their response to Bunny's claim, but that's ultimately I think attributable to being new.I strongly disagree with some people's claims here that fluidly shitposting in a comfortable manner while disengaging as much as possible is a town sign for a new player to the site that has played mafia before. That seems pretty off-base.

Fluminator seems kinda off to me as well given he seems to have indicated he has a reputation for low volume and wanted to change it, but most of his post count was just silly attempts to see what the Bot would count as a vote and what it wouldn't. I also didn't like his desire to steer the no vote so heavily before jumping randomly at damo (no read either way on damo as of now). That seemed pretty odd. I'll be truly back in like 7 hours since I have lots of work to finish before my late night sync, but knowing me I'll probably pop in a couple times more than I should between now and then.

[ghug]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

Irrationality is kinda worcej's town MO, isn't it?

It's like saying Jamie's scum because he doesn't understand that a claim might have been fake.

[Durga]

Why on Earth is your vote still on BG after all this?

Where should I put it PE? Why is yours on jasnah?

Someone who has a real chance of being mafia would be great...

I explained earlier that I intend to move my vote once the BG voters come back, recognize BG is the real Miller, and go somewhere else. To be honest you're not going to be very pleased with where it's likely to go

Go ahead PE, put your vote on me.

[worcej]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

I've explained that I 100% believe Bunny based off personal experience with him softing a role in prior games.

I've also explained that that means Jasnah is town or scum and, in either case, needs to be removed.

[Tom Bombadil]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

Irrationality is kinda worcej's town MO, isn't it?

I mean, yes. But it was such a quick pivot (which again, could be just town worcej jumping to conclusions without thinking, but I still find it very suspicious)

[Tom Bombadil]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

Irrationality is kinda worcej's town MO, isn't it?

It's like saying Jamie's scum because he doesn't understand that a claim might have been fake.

I like that you threw this in there solely as a way to insult someone

[Durga]

Oh I changed my mind a page or two ago but haven't moved yet.

##VOTE Durga

I know you don't think I'm scum.

Would you then say ghug is doing this because he's scum?

I'm leaning that way. I was leaning that way prior because whenever he's scum he does this thing where he tries to undermine me and he's been doing a lot of that by calling my comments weird or odd or wrong without backing it up. I don't buy that town!ghug's two votes were me and jasnah here

[Bonatogether]

Oh I changed my mind a page or two ago but haven't moved yet.

##VOTE Durga

so scummy it can't be scum?

Who, ghug or Durga?

ghug

[snowy801]

Re reading the earlier exchanges funnily enough has flipped me on Durga and given me very strong town reads. I still the PE is town and think his grilling of Durga while incorrect was coming from a townie place and appreciated his other posts. Jasnah is all but confirmed VT to me based on this reread and unless there is another CC I buy that Bunny is the Miller. If we could start a bandwagon on literally anyone else I'd be much happier.

As for bunny, if I am wrong on bunny, I think it is almost certain that worcej is also scum. I still get slight scum reads based on the desire to quick hammer jasnah, but I don't necessarily view that as ironclad proof of anything

I think Jamie's obstinance here is town-ish, though I really, really think they should reconsider their view. Jasnah has proven in the past to be a good scum hunter.

I have slight scum reads on Sabi based on their response to Bunny's claim, but that's ultimately I think attributable to being new.I strongly disagree with some people's claims here that fluidly shitposting in a comfortable manner while disengaging as much as possible is a town sign for a new player to the site that has played mafia before. That seems pretty off-base.

Fluminator seems kinda off to me as well given he seems to have indicated he has a reputation for low volume and wanted to change it, but most of his post count was just silly attempts to see what the Bot would count as a vote and what it wouldn't. I also didn't like his desire to steer the no vote so heavily before jumping randomly at damo (no read either way on damo as of now). That seemed pretty odd. I'll be truly back in like 7 hours since I have lots of work to finish before my late night sync, but knowing me I'll probably pop in a couple times more than I should between now and then.

I quite like this, but want to point out that just because we think Jasnah was fake claiming shouldn't exonerate her entirely. It makes no sense as scum, but neither does it really make sense as town.

I mean I don't think she is, but I imagine a more enterprising sort might employ this to get some significant cred while equally giving on out on why they're not dying night after night

[Tom Bombadil]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

I've explained that I 100% believe Bunny based off personal experience with him softing a role in prior games.

I've also explained that that means Jasnah is town or scum and, in either case, needs to be removed.

Why would she need to be removed if town? That doesn’t make sense

[worcej]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

Irrationality is kinda worcej's town MO, isn't it?

I think I make a lot of sense with my town play. Get on my level.

[Durga]

Good post by the flying boat and not just bc he town reads me

[worcej]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

I've explained that I 100% believe Bunny based off personal experience with him softing a role in prior games.

I've also explained that that means Jasnah is town or scum and, in either case, needs to be removed.

Why would she need to be removed if town? That doesn’t make sense

Because it's awful and I don't expect much value from her as town down the road.

[snowy801]

Also where the hell is Jasnah? I feel that she should be held responsible for creating the situation she has birthed.

We're talking circles around the contention when we can ask the source.

[worcej]

I've explained that I 100% believe Bunny based off personal experience with him softing a role in prior games.

I've also explained that that means Jasnah is town or scum and, in either case, needs to be removed.

Why would she need to be removed if town? That doesn’t make sense

Because it's awful and I don't expect much value from her as town down the road.

Also, let's say we do keep her alive. At some point, say D5, she'll become a leading 'what if she wasn't a VT after all...' contender to be miskilled then.

Deal with the crap in front of you now so scum cannot utilize it later.

[Durga]

Also where the hell is Jasnah? I feel that she should be held responsible for creating the situation she has birthed.

We're talking circles around the contention when we can ask the source.

she posted in some diplomacy thing that she was going to bed

[Bonatogether]

##vote kgray

tied the vote, can we get this wagon going?

[snowy801]

##vote kgray

tied the vote, can we get this wagon going?

kgray, huh? Sell me on this. What makes her scum?

[Jamiet99uk]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

Irrationality is kinda worcej's town MO, isn't it?

It's like saying Jamie's scum because he doesn't understand that a claim might have been fake.

Obviously one of the claims is fake, duh.

There aren't two Millers.