MAFIA 66: The Battle for Olympus - Game Thread [hidden]

[foodcoats]

foodreads

TOWN
-Bonatogether
-brainbomb
-darg
-kgray
-Vecna
-worcej (but possible WW)

SCUM
-Haas Bioroid
-Kakarroto
-Maniac

NULL
-Fluminator
-celaph (leaning town now)
-Chaqa (had as town but willing to accept the args about his pre-flip VCA)
-damo
-ghug
-Jamiet (scumlean or WW)
-Macca
-rdr (scumlean)
-yavu

[Hamilton Brian]

Can you say more about why you identify Vecna trying to get people off food as scum Vecna? He had put food as his strongest townread earlier in the day so I'd quite frankly be suspicious if he did anything besides trying to protect him.

I think it was the insistence on getting me to move off of whoever I was on at the time; made the offer to discuss reasons with me, but I didn't feel the response was totally adequate. I don't recall Vecna saying food was one of their strongest townreads.

I would say that it was more me not connecting any pertinent dots to conclude with that "feeling," because that's all it was at the time. As we've progressed since the vote and the many hours since, there's been a shift in my perspective around both Vecna and food.

[Hamilton Brian]

So in one of Demon's posts, they suggested their scumreads were Bona, Damo, RDR and townreads were brain, vecna, chaqa.

Simple scum ploy would be to alternate their reads with their teammates, right?

Does this somewhat clear Bona, Damo, and RDR?

Does it make more sus Brain, Vecna, and Chaqa?

Or is it simple enough to avoid mentioning their four other teammates at all?

I am feeling more town on brain. A little more sus on Vecna (really wanted to get people off of foodcoats) and still sus of Chaqa. But a big part of me makes me think they avoided mentioning their other 4 teammates.

My guess would be 1 scum in those 6 and the rest unmentioned.

You?

[Hamilton Brian]

Also, if you would be so kind, I don't like being talked to in third person when you're directly responding to me, feels like belittling me or talking to an audience like in a performance.

Duly noted; I was probably writing and forgot that I was responding to you.

[brainbomb]

it makes very little sense for hamilton to be scum

it makes some sense for me to be scum if I decided early game to call out demon rhk and blast my own scumbuddy for professing a desire to play shitty hack and slash games instead of mafia

get this bread ect

if scum had to choose between saving me hypothetically or saving stalker youd have to logically assume scum was saving me because im an even better scum pr than rhk

[brainbomb]

my viability rose up when kgray ghug and HB voted me 20 minutes out which put the votes rather close between me hb and rhk.

HB was in a self preserving stance so I somewhat forgive that

[brainbomb]

kgray decided along with Jamie that my end hammer on bona was me faking trying to be my town meta

kgray thought my push on kak was scummy

otherwise Kgray gave me a pass early on voting bona but refused to give dargo or foodcoats a pass in that same instance

[brainbomb]

I dont know if kgray is scum or just having a misread the board kinda game

[Hamilton Brian]

also quite puzzled by the statement. How is it suspicious to be herding people away from a (likely town) foodcoats, towards a wagon that resulted in a scumflip?

I think for me it depends on the evidence. Also being D1 with little insight, it's a lot more fluid. Were that to happen in D2 and you'd say, "Brian, there reasons are their vote, their interaction, etc" then I'd be much more trusting of it. I just didn't feel like it was very substantial at the time; I don't even remember what you had said to propel the move.

[brainbomb]

meltdown
meltdown
ernest hemingway
drama
anger

Coming this fall...

BRAINBOMB: The Motion Picture

Featuring...
BRANBOMB as...BRAINBOMB
JAMIET99UK as...THE RIVAL
HELLENIC RIOT as...THE WISE OLD MENTOR
and guest starring...
BTS as.,.THE SON OF BRAINBOMB (Don't ask how an entire band can play one person)

I'd pay money for this movie.

this is worcejs only mention of demonrhk day 1

[brainbomb]

Notice that Worcej totally avoided the last 10 hours of the day.

this is a call out id not expect from scum vs scum after a maf just got caught

[brainbomb]

##Vote kakarroto

I'm townreading brain, a quick iso didn't turn up much, and a self-pres vote.

This came when brain and kakarroto were both 3. I won't be surprised if the scum team is RHK (dead), Brainbomb, Hamilton Brian and two more. What do you think about this Jamie?

That would be too many.
There were 5 scum to start with. Four are left.

I think Maniac is scum, and I think the wagon on HB was an attempt to save DemonRHK. Maniac joined that wagon and then leapt onto DemonRHK to save face when it was too late.

Worcej was locked on HB for shitty reasoning hours before EoD and didn't re-appear.

Scum: Worcej, Maniac, Brainbomb, one more.

Jamie is town

[Chaqa]

Morning all

[brainbomb]

hello Chaq

[Chaqa]

I'm struggling to understand exactly how/why we got scum on Day 1. It makes me think scum just plain wasn't online and that could be interesting information in itself. Makes people like Macca, Flum, Jamiet, worcej, etc. look bad to me.

I think the Kakarot wagon was scum's preferred counter (based on RHK's vote) so that also makes me suspicious of the people on that wagon (though atm I assume Dargo is the cop).

[brainbomb]

I feel incredibly good about Bona.

Food coats and Macca rub me wrong.

Where’s Jamie?

RHK doing his normal scum thing too

Chaqa mentions RHK 5 times, calls him scum early. later votes for him and says choo choo. Chaqa was among the most ardent RHK voters and therefore chaqa looks very good

[damo666]

damo looks totally like a candidate who never once mentions demonrhk. because he never did

There are other players I haven't mentioned. This is not significant.

You might actually think this statement makes you look better. It makes you look even worse

Why?

[damo666]

also, given your vote on me all day and that nickname, would you take a bite from me? *blush*

(oh and I don't especially mean you're werewolf, not that kind of bite)

though thinking about just now, what about it, are you the werewolf, damo?

"No" he growled.

[damo666]

you dont have to mention every player in the game but you seem to be struggling to mention most of them

I will when I have anything if merit to say.

[brainbomb]

damo 0
macca 0
rdrivera 1
yavuz 1
celaph 3
hamilton 5 (and was CW to RHK)
Jamiet99uk 3
worcej 1
chaqa 5

It certainly looks like chaqa and hamilton are town based on willingness to mention a scum PR that was valuable and teammates likely wouldnt have thrown away needlessly