Have you actually ever see ND lurk as scum though? Because I can only remember ND being active and convincingly town as scum. Which I feel you should also be aware of. This ND just reminds me a lot of our small game where he was the easiest mislynch D1 because he often doesnt care as town.
Yeah I had a gun and I shot Chaqa. I claimed because I figured I'd be able to use it anytime at night and get us some info, I retracted when I found out that wasn't the case just so scum didn't think I had it. But I shot Chaqa. There was no trick here.Vecna wrote: ↑Tue Sep 11, 2018 12:45 pmWere you actually genuine in your gun claim? Or was there some roleswapping shenanigans going on? I did have a feeling that something was off with your claim. If you didnt actually have the gun, its probably wise to out that stuff since the RB would indicate that the chaqa shot was shot by scum.
Low likelyhood this actually happened, but you never know. Would at least make the rb make sense.
What logic between me and squigs is this Ghug? I think I mustve missed itghug wrote: ↑Mon Sep 10, 2018 11:29 pmY'all need to spend less time thinking about where items could be and more time thinking about the game.
Relevant item information:
Barring counterclaim, brain and y2k are conftown
Damo is town unless RHK is scum
Flash is very likely town
Durga is likely town
That's it
We just lynched scum, and another one flipped. That's where we're going to catch the next scum too. If you want to vote for me for that, go right ahead. If you want to vote for me for this Alex Jones item bullshit, feel free to go fuck yourself.
Excluding myself and those soft- or hard- cleared listed above, we have two scum in:
DemonRHK
ND
rdrivera2005
yavuzovic
Tom Bombadil
Vecna
worcej
xorxes
Xorxes has either improved drastically at feigning effort as scum (entirely possible, but less likely than the alternative), or is town. Worcej had an organic reaction to brain's claim and then went hard on Squigs all day, so I'm pretty comfortable clearing him too. My logic clearing Vecna for the Squigs reads stands. We should be lynching between the other five and me at least today and probably tomorrow as well. Add Vecna back in if you don't buy my logic, but it's great logic, so you should just listen it me.
I think Rivera is the likeliest scum of the group and RHK the least likely. I could be talked into lynching any of the other three if Rivera is no fly, but I'd rather just kill him.
Why lol? Why does it give townpoints to RHK?rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 10, 2018 11:31 pmThanks Xorxes and Flash. This clears Damo and also give town points to RHK.
I think this is forcing your brain to find a way to accuse flash. I find flash pretty towny and didn't like this forced read.
Remember, Durga had retracted her claim to the cannon just before EON so at the time I wasn't really sure Durga had a gun or whether she was potentially bluffing. I got excited at the possibility of taking out scum so early (and if BB was lying voting for him D1), so I used my cannon on Moscow.
Assuming he damo did it accidentally, I won't make a case about +1ing this post. No mafia would play that explicit.rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 11, 2018 10:18 amI still think that we have a better chance to hit scum on Ghug. ##vote Ghug
So you are suggesting that y2k faked his nurse kit claim? Someone else saved BB? If yes, why haven't they announced this? Or are you suggesting that scum held their NK to allow y2k to fake claim?
BIRTHDAY CARD - You may pay a friendly visit to a player of your choice at night. PM both GMs in the format ##VISIT [TARGET]. They will be aware of your visit, and you will reveal your alignment to them. Optionally you may write a message of up to 10 words in the birthday card, if you wish. This will be revealed to the target as well.
Vecna wrote: ↑Tue Sep 11, 2018 12:56 pmHave you actually ever see ND lurk as scum though? Because I can only remember ND being active and convincingly town as scum. Which I feel you should also be aware of. This ND just reminds me a lot of our small game where he was the easiest mislynch D1 because he often doesnt care as town.
Maybe he's just lifting on that, but he would be noticing as scum that it isnt working out the way he intends to.
Im pretty much leaning on ND simply being town here.
quite a redeeming post. dont know if scum goes this allin on moonlogicDemonRHK wrote: ↑Tue Sep 11, 2018 1:46 amHoly shit that actually makes a lot of sense.
ghug claimed his item was stolen, but never said WHAT was stolen until AFTER the shot. He knew MF had the head and he could safely claim it after he died.
Scum may have rb'd, killed, and robbed bozo, thinking he had a key item on his silence. And the may have even got a Doc Kit holy fuck that would be some 6D checkers though.
While you are here Damo, why did you send the card to DemonRHK instead of BB? DemonRHK was not confirmed town.
This one, I can't say post number because I use a different order of posts.rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 11, 2018 10:18 amWell, I had some time and re-read Flash and Durga considering Brain's theories. I still think Flash is a stretch. He looks the same as last game and his Moscow shoot as scum only make sense if Durga is also scum.
And this is a possibility, re-reading her seems that Brain have a point, I don't see much effort other then defending himself and calling other people stupid. The reasons that makes me think she isn't scum is that I can't see her and Ghug on the same team and that I don't believe she will claim the cannon at N0 that way. All things considered, I still think she isn't a good choice to lynch now.
I still think that we have a better chance to hit scum on Ghug. ##vote Ghug
Users browsing this forum: Hominidae, Spartaculous
