MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[Tom Bombadil]

Who would roleblock a person that makes zero sense to roleblock?

vote yavu with me.

[brainbomb]

Sigh. Another losing lions season this is awful

[Tom Bombadil]

Its just one game brain. It will be ok

[DemonRHK]

A couple of thoughts:

-If ghug is scum, y2k isn't fully cleared, but brain is now 100%.

- There is a high chance that the foam hammer is lost or still in play. Scum likely all agreed to claim the hammer so if they ever got caught rb'ing they would have an alibi. This also means bozo did not have the armor or car (obviously on those) but the shock shield as well, else there is no reason to fake claim hammer.

- (OPINION) If the repair was town AND got a cannon, they should claim so we can fire it. Hide if it was Cop Kit because we don't know if the second Med Kit is still out there.

[brainbomb]

Its just one game brain. It will be ok

We fired a good coach who won 9 games- beat the packers twice. To replace him with this fat slob who looks like he spends all his time bear hunting

[DemonRHK]

Holy shit that actually makes a lot of sense.

ghug claimed his item was stolen, but never said WHAT was stolen until AFTER the shot. He knew MF had the head and he could safely claim it after he died.

Scum may have rb'd, killed, and robbed bozo, thinking he had a key item on his silence. And the may have even got a Doc Kit holy fuck that would be some 6D checkers though.

[ghug]

I'm not that dumb Jesus Christ.

[xorxes]

- There is a high chance that the foam hammer is lost or still in play.

Yes, I'd say about 99%. The other 1% is the chance that the GMs lied to us and it was never part of the setup, so it was neither lost nor still in play.

Scum likely all agreed to claim the hammer so if they ever got caught rb'ing they would have an alibi.

ELECTRO-SHIELD - If the player with this item is targeted by the Mafia roleblock, the roleblock will fail and the shielded player will learn the identity of the Mafia member who roleblocked them.

Nope, the foam hammer is no alibi.

[worcej]

Sigh. Another losing lions season this is awful

That's an understatement...

[ghug]

Ok, all of you people doing this conspiracy theory bullshit, either tell me what advantage worth fakeclaiming for I was supposed to be giving myself or accept that it's really not alignment indicative right now and move on with your lives.

[brainbomb]

Ok, all of you people doing this conspiracy theory bullshit, either tell me what advantage worth fakeclaiming for I was supposed to be giving myself or accept that it's really not alignment indicative right now and move on with your lives.

Id rather you stop using the same "why would I do _______" fuckboy defense and actually explain who is scum and why.

[brainbomb]

Way too many players keep falling back on "why would I claim ____, why would I post _______, why would I fake claim gun, why would I claim _____ as scum.

Nobody gives a fuck what you wouldnt do as scum. Do something as town if its such a dramatic fight.

[brainbomb]

Ghug claiming hes had shit stolen- durga claiming gun early. These arent important facts unless they ALSO exist simultaneously with bad reads- bad pushes- dodgy ass play- poor reasoning- or NO reasoning.

So far this list does still include durga and ghug both. Random argumentative AtE- occasional appeals to authority. And shock at being scumread despite having never firmly reread.

Both ghug and demon have on occasion felt like teammates.

When it came to worcej both fail to acknowledge squiggs IMMEDIATELY pushes worcej as soon as the gun goes off.

Unless yer making an argument for squiggs insta bussing worcej this line of thinking was hollow- thoughtless and just random

[brainbomb]

Ghug pushes on durga are met with personal meta AtE that nobody in their right mind can interpret. And then they both always cop out on it anyway.

Durga pushes on ghug always have no real reasoning other than "hes hard to read". Again- nothing game related- nothing specific. Completely hollow and derivative.

My case on flash is substance laden. You have to actually go reread some people.

The time for vomitting stupid accusations should be over by now. Get with the program or get lynched

[ghug]

It's hard to offer new analysis when nothing new has happened because everyone's busy speculating on dumb item shit. I've given my thoughts of the game up to this point, and I'm continuing to look for new things, but I'm also going to spend time trying to put this time-wasting nonsense to bed because it's time-wasting nonsense. "Why would I do [stupid thing someone is suggesting I've done]" is a perfectly valid defense against these arguments, because they're not "ghug did this thing with scum motivations, thus he's scum", they're "this is something that is possible, I am incapable of higher brain function, and it intrigues me at this moment, so it must be what happened".

[ghug]

Ghug claiming hes had shit stolen- durga claiming gun early. These arent important facts unless they ALSO exist simultaneously with bad reads- bad pushes- dodgy ass play- poor reasoning- or NO reasoning.

So far this list does still include durga and ghug both. Random argumentative AtE- occasional appeals to authority. And shock at being scumread despite having never firmly reread.

Both ghug and demon have on occasion felt like teammates.

When it came to worcej both fail to acknowledge squiggs IMMEDIATELY pushes worcej as soon as the gun goes off.

Unless yer making an argument for squiggs insta bussing worcej this line of thinking was hollow- thoughtless and just random

It's almost like I used this very logic to clear worcej myself...

[brainbomb]

Im basing 100% of what im seeing off how bizarre as fuck it is for flash to shoot moscow and then suddenly jump on squiggs- NEVER LEAVE SQUIGGS- but make these musings:

flash2015
Day-1 24:33
page 24 Still feels wrong not voting for BB today. Perhaps I should just go down the list?:

##VOTE Squiggs44

■what list does it go bb -> squiggz? Who else is on THIS alleged list?



flash2015
Day-1 23:45
page 25 I am not believing he is being sincere: ##VOTE Xorxes.

flash2015
Day-1 23:36
page 25
↑Durga: "Strangely this is the towniest I've ever seen xorxes"
In what way?

■durga post seems fake. Shes seen xorx as town in most games. Even when he was a serial killer arsonist she once argued he was towny.


flash2015
Day-1 17:23
page 28
↑Durga: "I'm shooting him"
Then do it finally...


flash2015
Day-1 06:01
page 30 Squiggles is still the number 1 wagon with 6 hours to go...and he hasn't even tried to defend himself? Have all my dreams become true? Have all my Christmas's come at once? I didn't want it to be this easy though

■reading the context of the above post flash is against the idea of lynching squiggs and wants to make it feel its too easy.

04:19
page 32 I see that you have been online for a while, Squigsy. Are you writing war and peace there? C'mon, it won't be very enjoyable if you make this too easy.

##VOTE Squigs44

■Now hes suddenly certain squiggs is scum and says its not gonna be enjoyable. But the context here is he wants squiggs to post more and thinks squiggs has a long post to share.


flash2015
Day-1 03:52
page 33
↑y2kjbk: "I’d rather lynch snowy or Vecna over Squigs. Lynching a lurker at this point is better than lynching active Squigs that..."

Squigs isn't doing much either though. I see him lurking a lot but not interacting. This hasn't been his MO in previous games...especially when he is questioned

■Flash has been in 1 game or 2 at most with squiggs. A meta read??



Now flash entertains all kinds of options other than squiggs.



Page 36 : g=39&part=Day%201&user=flash2015
flash2015
Day-1 02:31
page 36 I am really not seeing the argument for Tom...but I haven't played with him before in another game so perhaps I am missing something here.

flash2015
Day-1 02:30
page 37 His hassling of ND sounds like something I would want to do...

flash2015
Day-1 02:27
page 37
↑brainbomb: "Sometimes when scum is losing they fear safe places to go and they bus hoping none of those happen"

But the ND thing all happened very early, didn't it...before you tracked Moscow? Was ND's response real...or is he really that touchy?

flash2015
Day-1 02:25
page 37
↑brainbomb: "ND and Jamie have done this smoke and mirrors bus strat is known. ND likes that crap"
So you are suggesting potentially Tom and ND are both scum?

flash2015
Day-1 02:20
page 37
↑brainbomb: "Technically ghug durga also feels like w/w fakery"
Or Durga-Xorxes? After Durga claimed, Xorxes was suggesting that if the other cannon holder didn't claim they must be scum.

flash2015
Day-1 02:11
page 37
↑brainbomb: "Durga ghug xorx?"
Could be.

■flash despite presence on Squiggs-wagon never moves but encourages subtly all options- tom- nd- ghug- durga. Even xorxes

[brainbomb]

Its probably just flash and vecna or flash and yavuz

[flash2015]

I don't understand - I WANTED Squigs to be scum. We have been joking about catching each other as scum for a few weeks now. But I thought it was coming all too easy.

Of course while voting for him I am still trying to understand what other people are thinking...as I am trying not to tunnel. What is wrong with that? You are really reaching here.

[flash2015]

Its probably just flash and vecna or flash and yavuz

OK, as usual, everyone needs to be on BB's scum list at least once, no matter how crazy the idea may be. Your mvp is fading away fast...