MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[miminena]

##VOTE DIP

sorry worcej wagoners I want this over worcej a teensy bit

It was very unlikely DiplomacyandWarfare would be DKed with 1 minute to go. Why didn't you vote your preference between worcej and Red Neurax?

oh look bozo is here
next lurker who I scumread:
##vote worcej

i don't like this vote; jumping around people like this might be indicative of a warlock, or it could give a warlock cover if they wanted to try the same thing

this isn't a read, I just think we should be careful with throwing votes out now that a night has passed

[brainbomb]

I'm not quite sure I understand the question.

I meant what worcej was doing was somewhat of a shtick, it took up alot of time and thread energy. I wondered if you at any point felt like what he was doing was creating a lack of clearheadedness

I’m not sure how ghug answered… but brain, I would be interested in your response to your own question…

This was all answered but what I meant was worcej was promoting a strategy to kill among damo, ghug and vecna. This generated a large argument with will which took over the thread for a while and the discussion was somewhat fiesty. I asked ghug if he felt that ND being antagonistic was similar to worcej promoting killing off good players.

[brainbomb]

It was very unlikely DiplomacyandWarfare would be DKed with 1 minute to go. Why didn't you vote your preference between worcej and Red Neurax?

oh look bozo is here
next lurker who I scumread:
##vote worcej

i don't like this vote; jumping around people like this might be indicative of a warlock, or it could give a warlock cover if they wanted to try the same thing

this isn't a read, I just think we should be careful with throwing votes out now that a night has passed

Worcej seems pretty unlikely to be the daykill today?

[brainbomb]

I still feel that pirates is very town

Im at like
Pirates
Will
Mimi
ND

For town

And just gonna restart my whole mafia reads list as this day goes on.

I think this is a pretty accurate set of towney types. The one I feel less sure about is KotP - I think D1 I was feeling them acting a lot but in a waffley manner that didn’t push the game forward. What makes you townread KotP, brain?

He was my first strong gut townread for early posting and tone. I think he is involved in the discussions and is pushing for answers to his questions.

[bozotheclown]

Oh I am for sure about to die and it'll be the most worthless kill

This is fucking hilarious though to be fair.

It's really funny on rerun too...I'm thinking most of the worcej voters are town

"Most" of the players not voting for worcej are town also. If worcej is town or 3P, I think the mafia would have preferred DKing him over Red Neurax.

[brainbomb]

##vote DemonRHK change of pace

[brainbomb]

Alright let's solve.

Will/bozo/food

Spirit is the 3P.

gg go next

This solve doesnt make any sense. Potentially bussing a teammate in these reads.

[brainbomb]

RIP damo. Gj on being the kill as a VT though.

##vote food

third voter rule.

This seems like RHK was annoyed at damo only being a vt

[DemonRHK]

Mornin.

No, I'm happy he was a VT. We straight up miskilled one of our PRs D1 in a game with a 50/50 chance of a 3P role looking to PR hunt.

The solve was admittedly half a shitpost and 30 seconds of lazy wagon analysis.

[bozotheclown]

It is interesting that out of everyone who moved their vote to worcej in the last 4 minutes of D1, only DiplomacyandWarfare had been voting for Red Neurax. It is not clear why all of the DiplomacyandWarfare and ND voters preferred worcej over Red Neurax.

[foodcoats]

Ah one thing I remember about webdip mafia is that getting opinions out of people is like trying to herd cats

This snarky frustration is very townie.

[foodcoats]

so, since the votes are starting to consolidate, i'm curious, would anybody on a wagon other than the top 3 be willing to give their preference between voting ND, DW, and Red, if they absolutely had to choose? I myself would prefer Red from the three, although realistically i'm sticking on Will until EoD

I'd vote red out of the three, dip just isn't seeming scummy to me, and ND's a garbage kill info wise. I don't like killing any of them though

Spirit, what was the differential that made Red NOT garbage “info wise”?

[foodcoats]

the only appeal of red over ND is they're a bit more lurky and its hard to sus those people out in mid-late game if there is a bunch of em

Derp… disregard last question!

[foodcoats]

Screw it. I want more info.
##vote ND

Dip, what did this mean in the context of you switching from brain to ND?

[foodcoats]

Screw it. I want more info.
##vote ND

Dip, what did this mean in the context of you switching from brain to ND?

… not good at keeping the colours straight and whatnot as I go here… you had voted brain, then red, then ND. Can you explain why ND was “more info?”

[brainbomb]

Bozo seems to be in his town game where he hounds people with questions.

[foodcoats]

Need to now catch up from page 53…

After re-reading D1 I think Vecna had some weird interactions with worcej that town Vecna would not make. There’s also some weird interactions of ghug with worcej, but in hindsight I don’t think there’s as… misplaced. Basically it seems like Vecna scumread and voted for worcej but, after Red flipped, decided worcej was town incredibly quickly, in a way that doesn’t feel natural and sounds more like buddying. It just doesn’t square for me that Vecna’s takeaway there is to brake on worcej and tell him… not to get himself scumread? It seems that if Vecna was town he would be upset with worcej irrespective of the flip.

##VOTE Vecna

[brainbomb]

Pirates
Will
Mimi
ND
Bozo

Welcome to the crew bozo

Anyone else wanna join the fun boat?
Vecna? Ghug?

[DemonRHK]

So I was looking at EoD1 (lazily) for people trying to dodge the Judicator (If we have one) and the only one that pings me is Dip.

[miminena]

oh look bozo is here
next lurker who I scumread:
##vote worcej

i don't like this vote; jumping around people like this might be indicative of a warlock, or it could give a warlock cover if they wanted to try the same thing

this isn't a read, I just think we should be careful with throwing votes out now that a night has passed

Worcej seems pretty unlikely to be the daykill today?

fair point, i'm just a bit weary of possible 3p stuff atm, mostly because damo brought it up very early on during day 1, so it's on my mind. I don't really think it means much of anything, just putting my thoughts out there