M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[aarodactyl]

Meeting time. See you all in two hours.

[worcej]

##vote Hamilton

I think the damo wagon is weak and opportunistic. My vote was a joke.

I don’t like the fact that people were treading water for Flum either…

[Fluminator]

Like Flaviois I don't understand you. You say it's anti town to talk about the tadpole and I literally agree which is why I'm saying anyone who talks about wanting it should die.

Like I'm beginning to think there's a language barrier here and why I asked if you lived outside of North America.

GM NOTE
Editing posts is strictly prohibited. Please do not do this again

My bad, I'm phone posting at the gym and made a typo lol. Won't happen again

[Jamiet99uk]

Where the fvck has this Flum wagon come from.

[sweetandcool]

I am so pro town here it's spectacular

I wish you would have a D1 that's not "scummy". I've been fooled in the past, but I'm not sure what to make of it this game.

[FlaviusAetius]

Like Flaviois I don't understand you. You say it's anti town to talk about the tadpole and I literally agree which is why I'm saying anyone who talks about wanting it should die.

Like I'm beginning to think there's a language barrier here and why I asked if you lived outside of North America.

No im saying that asking people "would you take the tadpole" IS ANTI TOWN.
What their response to it shouldnt matter, because the question ITSELF is bad.
I also explained why the responses to this question reveals a lot for the mafia! (who is potential PR and who is not)

[Jamiet99uk]

@Kingo'thepirates:

Why are you still self-voting?

[damo666]

will switch yo lfischl if necessary obviously.

I got 5 mins if anyone wants to repeat unanswered qs.

I would like to know why you thought Jamie hard claiming was reasonable, but most other people seem not to care about that

I want to know that too, especially since normally, I would expect damo to be negatively thrilled towards anyone who decreases the pool of PR hiding spaces.

Damo, do you think PR's don't need to hide this game?

ofc.

I don't think J's claim was wise but the point I was trying to make is that it is not SI.

[Fluminator]

Like Flaviois I don't understand you. You say it's anti town to talk about the tadpole and I literally agree which is why I'm saying anyone who talks about wanting it should die.

Like I'm beginning to think there's a language barrier here and why I asked if you lived outside of North America.

No im saying that asking people "would you take the tadpole" IS ANTI TOWN.
What their response to it shouldnt matter, because the question ITSELF is bad.
I also explained why the responses to this question reveals a lot for the mafia! (who is potential PR and who is not)

I've never once asked that question

[damo666]

How much have you had to drink?

only 4 pints of stella and half a bottle of merlot and a few anti-histamines and nifedipine

If you drank less merlot you'd also need less nifedipine.

So?

[DemonRHK]

The fish is slowing down.

How bout a ##Vote flum to spice some stuff up? I like 3 D1 wagons.

??? I DONT WE CANT TIE THIS THING
Why are people still on the HB wagon again?? What has he done!

Friend I don't know what the fuck you are on, but I want some.

I went from a 3 vote wagon to make another 3 vote wagon, niether of which was damo or HB.

And it was the fucking wagon you were on.

[Jamiet99uk]

Like Flaviois I don't understand you. You say it's anti town to talk about the tadpole and I literally agree which is why I'm saying anyone who talks about wanting it should die.

Like I'm beginning to think there's a language barrier here and why I asked if you lived outside of North America.

No im saying that asking people "would you take the tadpole" IS ANTI TOWN.
What their response to it shouldnt matter, because the question ITSELF is bad.
I also explained why the responses to this question reveals a lot for the mafia! (who is potential PR and who is not)

But he didn't ask that question.

You are shouting at Fluminator because you think he asked a question that, in fact, he did not ask.

[brainbomb]

Hamilton Brian (5) DiplomacyandWarfare Fluminator Ezio Foxcastle BunnyGo
Fluminator (5) FlaviusAetius sweetandcool DemonRHK lfischl Hamilton Brian
damo666 (4) worcej Squigs44 Jamiet99uk Dousing
FlaviusAetius (3) JustAGuyNamedWill aarodactyl damo666
lfischl (2) Kakarroto Chaqa
kingofthepirates (1) kingofthepirates
Jamiet99uk (1) Vecna
Vecna (1) TheMadMonarch
BunnyGo (1) ghug*
ghug (1) Bonatogether
JustAGuyNamedWill (1) Col7by
worcej (1) foodcoats

No one is scheduled to die 28 minutes remain

[sweetandcool]

##vote Flavius

Get his teammate Ham 2m.

I'm much more suspicious of Sweet than Flav as the partner.
From my perspective sweet is very disingenuous, although that's probably something only I can pick up on since his push is directed at me.

I think you are a clever player Flum. Lots of respect.

[Kakarroto]

I feel like most of the people I want to vote are just anti-town and all the people I have any sort of reason to scumread are people you want to keep past day 1.

Like my head tells me that damo, lfischl, HB, Jamie are all fine votes but my heart wants to vote Dip or BunnyGo or maybe even Kakarroto. Why can't one of the anti-town players just obvscum?

I agree with the feeling that D&W and bunny feel quite mafia-like. I have my doubts there, still. You putting me into that pool makes me feel I'm wrong about the two though. Which would be fitting for me having awful reads d1

[Jamiet99uk]

Why is Vecna still voting for me?

[foodcoats]

##VOTE damo666

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

please explain your read on lfischl in more detail

I also want your explanation for the placement of dargo, please.

And if you be so kind and have still time for it, please tell me the difference between Hamilton and kotp.

I forgot why I townread lfischl. 26 people and a very complex setup. It's hard to remember everything.
Dargorygel is lawful exalted because he's a moderator and Co-GM
Kotp was doing useful contributing before the NoKill arc. Hamilton didn't do anything useful until he became a major wagon, and now he's just reacting to the wagon on him. In other words, kotp has done some good stuff and questionable stuff. Ham's only done questionable stuff.
My townread on kotp has a bit of personal intuition thrown in. My HB scumread, however, has a very provable point: Ham has done no analysis this game that is not specifically biased for and pointed towards stopping his wagon.

oh boy, where to begin?

well at least you didn't forget that dargo was just a gm

now this:

Kotp was doing useful contributing before the NoKill arc

these are all kotp posts before:

Howdy folks! I dunno what my gimmick is going to be this game, but whatevs, yo! Let's get this show on the road! lock in, buckle your seat belts, and prepare to shoot any stray Illithids you find along the way!

Again, let's please not tell mafia who would accept a tadpole.

hard agree with dipandwar here, we don't to give mafia any more advantages.

We need a magic dude or smthn

AHA! A gimmick for me to steal! rolling... a 19! Mine now! I shall not cast fireball just yet though, lol.

I say it's very bad when strange things are a foot, especially when you are only three foot tall

well since you are 3 feet, you clearly are not a strange thing. though you may very well be 3 strange things in a trench coat... but I would know nothing about that (just rolled investigation)!

##vote no kill
In such a massive game, I don't see the point in not skipping when there is not enough info. unless there is a major scum slip, or some other great realization, this is my vote for the day.

please, point out here, exactly where in your opinion Kotp is doing this useful stuff.



Brian on the other hand has provided his thoughts of his reads and shown a bit of him. Your arguments and statements don't represent the reality.


It's the same with Fluminator and me, you read him as "Absolute Exalted" and suspect me with the argument I was pushing to everyone the tadpole question, yet it was HE who did it, while I tried to mirror it to himself, to present it as the flaw it is.

m89 - repelling tadpole question.png


I'm heavily doubting you are of a sound logic in your arguments for your classification. You either need to cleanse yourself, or you are just mafia trying to give misinformation into the game.

First of all, Fluminator being absolute exalted is a joke. My serious read of him is neutral moral. Fluminator.
Second, note kotp agreeing with me and rejecting your scum-benefitting 'lets all reveal if we would accept a tadpole' proposal
Third, its a light townread. Chill. It's not like I'm calling kotp absolute exalted
Fourth, Fluminator started a list of people he would, and would not, consider wagoning D1. You turned that into "would you accept a tadpole".
Fifth and finally, I agree that I may have gotten a bit carried away with wagoning HB. However, the HB wagon is better than either the damo, lfischl, and fluminator wagons.

Hmm. Maybe we should flashwagon sweet.

[FlaviusAetius]

YOOOOOO THIS IS A SCUMSLIP BY HB

So me copying the first post I made, because I didn't want to retype it all, and instead just move the names around as they then felt to me is a ...SCUMSLIP!

I expect better. I explained myself. Y'all can pound sand with your bullshit "gotcha's." You ain't got shit.

I like this response by HB.

Me too, and also for the record, me and sweet stayed on the Flum wagon because we were trying to build a case around it, and with no case built around it, people started jumping onto it for no reason

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm going to make a pot of tea. I'll be back in 7 minutes or thereabouts.