MAFIA 45 GAME THREAD - BETWEEN A ROCK AND A...ROCK

[brainbomb]

...
it kinda lacks common sense though. why is damo scum and bussing?
why is moscow opting to bus? thats not his style as scum really

and vapor has a tendency to omgus.
...

I'm not saying they're all scum in my opinion. That's not even possible. These are just uncensored and unredacted 'facts' from D1. Conclude from it what you will.

I was actually looking for my notes on protection of people before they've even posted (!), but those happen after page 6. You'll have to look for those yourself.

I think its extremely towny the way you presented it. it was unique. I dont think many people try to look that far ahead on that many worldviews.

Most folks just lynch who they find scummy and let the rest take care of itself.

[Claesar]

if you want me to be lynched you probably should get that train started soon because ill catch scum eventually and itll be much harder to be rid of me once I hit aces up

I'm usually not someone who tries to rally other people. I just post observations and analysis and allow others to draw their own conclusions. I know that's not the effective way to do it. In fact, I don't think anyone has ever followed my lead in forum Mafia Then again, I've never been in a team (that I knew the members of). Just D1 with Chaqa in M16, but he died before we could work together.

I know I should try to post a fancy infograph like Emc did in the mini-game, admit it's based on false data and still get everyone to follow my lead.. But that's not me. Form your own opinion.

[brainbomb]

It always just starts with a hunch
a vote
and a heartfelt discussion

nothing else ever actually matters

[brainbomb]

people like simple cases. that feel right. They dont want long messes of quotes they just want scummuly folk to die so they can see the flip and move onto the next person.

the harder it is to explain something theres only three reasons why
●that scum player is playing phenomenally well
●the game is full of klingons who dont speak english
●the guy youre harping about simply isnt scum

[Claesar]

people like simple cases. that feel right. They dont want long messes of quotes they just want scummuly folk to die so they can see the flip and move onto the next person.

the harder it is to explain something theres only three reasons why
●that scum player is playing phenomenally well
●the game is full of klingons who dont speak english
●the guy youre harping about simply isnt scum

In the mini-game, it was clear that it was Scum vs lurkers. Trying to convince anyone was rather pointless.

• The people you're trying to convince are scum too

[Claesar]

Rereading D1 does make me remember something I wanted to bring up around this time. I need to find the EOD GM posts for this, so I'll try to find them again. Does Peterbot log those?

[brainbomb]

people like simple cases. that feel right. They dont want long messes of quotes they just want scummuly folk to die so they can see the flip and move onto the next person.

the harder it is to explain something theres only three reasons why
●that scum player is playing phenomenally well
●the game is full of klingons who dont speak english
●the guy youre harping about simply isnt scum

In the mini-game, it was clear that it was Scum vs lurkers. Trying to convince anyone was rather pointless.

• The people you're trying to convince are scum too

ok. true. I dont think this game is dominated by high volume scum though.

[Claesar]

It does!

The chief of the cave stood on a rock, wearing the crown of rocks and waving the big rock. “Whoo Wee Keel? Whoo wee makk ded?” He yelled to the gathered tribal men.

“Boh suh” chanted those assembled.

“Dat yor deh cie son?”

“Boh suh”chanted those assembled.

“Otay” said the chief.

Boh was pushed outside into the sun, and was beat with the spears and poked with the clubs. Percy looked up from the bath he was taking atop the hill, and saw Boh be killed by his comrades. It was clear he was one of them, but Percy was covered in suds, a very inconvenient time to prevent an unjust killing. EMC just didn’t care. He was still off cataloguing the various residents of the third cave, and naming them after the webdippers that shared the most traits.

Bo_sox48 is dead, and has died, he was: Vanilla Town

Night had fallen in the valley. So had E.M.C. Percy heard the fall, and ran to a large pit, surprisingly unnoticed so far, that E.M.C had fallen into.
"Are you okay?!" Percy hollered into the hole.
" I think so, but everything's a little... " E.M.C's voice floated up out of the hole, followed by another thunk!
Percy was now mildly concerned. He didn't really know how the time travel was supposed to work. That was E.M.C's job. Percy went over to the tea machine, now that he needed to know how to use it right. There were a number of knobs and buttons, as well as an unnoticed 8-do bit display.
"Blimey, I really don't pay attention, do I?" Percy muttered to himself being slightly insane already. On the screen there was a message scrolling across. Hardio had decided to stop possessing Boohm Smahtz body. Apparently he drew the line when bit by Fie uh wah tuh. Down in the cavern there was a stab, punch, grunt, and fart. The stab was a piece of meat Panthera wanted. The punch was to a rock that looked at the chief wrong. The grunt came from the Doctor's cave. And the fart came from Nuhpthjkeeffees Hadrian Von Swartz Lukreer.
Also Vecna died.
Percy pushed a very shiny button. Suddenly In front of him was crusader Reynolds.
"Whoa, what is this place?"
"Ahhhhhhhh!" Percy screamed and violently mashed all the buttons, dials and switches. The moon zoomed across the sky and sank, and the sun rose. As soon as the sun was visible, it slowed, slower than normal.
"Beep boop. One hour of day added, to be removed in two days. Daylights savings has been invented."THIS DAY PHASE WILL BE ONE HOUR LONGER, BUT THE DAY PHASE AFTER WILL BE ONE HOUR SHORTER TO RE-ALIGN PHASE END TIME. (Unless too many people complain, then I'll find another solution.
In the morning, everyone arose to a smell of freshly cooked meat, and made some primitive sandwiches. (Except Vecna)
Vecna has died he was: Vanilla Town
It is now DAY 2 you may post. (Including Brainbomb)

What I find interesting about this is that apparently Bo was named Boh Suh, while Vecna had no name? But I have an in-game name! And it's not related to my username (as far as I can tell).

Instead, I thought I recognised a theme. That's why I tried to hint at my game name in my first couple of posts, to see who would pick that up. At first I thought MF and Vapour did, but now I'm not so sure anymore..

Can we use this information for scumhunting?

[Nephthys]

It does!

The chief of the cave stood on a rock, wearing the crown of rocks and waving the big rock. “Whoo Wee Keel? Whoo wee makk ded?” He yelled to the gathered tribal men.

“Boh suh” chanted those assembled.

“Dat yor deh cie son?”

“Boh suh”chanted those assembled.

“Otay” said the chief.

Boh was pushed outside into the sun, and was beat with the spears and poked with the clubs. Percy looked up from the bath he was taking atop the hill, and saw Boh be killed by his comrades. It was clear he was one of them, but Percy was covered in suds, a very inconvenient time to prevent an unjust killing. EMC just didn’t care. He was still off cataloguing the various residents of the third cave, and naming them after the webdippers that shared the most traits.

Bo_sox48 is dead, and has died, he was: Vanilla Town

Night had fallen in the valley. So had E.M.C. Percy heard the fall, and ran to a large pit, surprisingly unnoticed so far, that E.M.C had fallen into.
"Are you okay?!" Percy hollered into the hole.
" I think so, but everything's a little... " E.M.C's voice floated up out of the hole, followed by another thunk!
Percy was now mildly concerned. He didn't really know how the time travel was supposed to work. That was E.M.C's job. Percy went over to the tea machine, now that he needed to know how to use it right. There were a number of knobs and buttons, as well as an unnoticed 8-do bit display.
"Blimey, I really don't pay attention, do I?" Percy muttered to himself being slightly insane already. On the screen there was a message scrolling across. Hardio had decided to stop possessing Boohm Smahtz body. Apparently he drew the line when bit by Fie uh wah tuh. Down in the cavern there was a stab, punch, grunt, and fart. The stab was a piece of meat Panthera wanted. The punch was to a rock that looked at the chief wrong. The grunt came from the Doctor's cave. And the fart came from Nuhpthjkeeffees Hadrian Von Swartz Lukreer.
Also Vecna died.
Percy pushed a very shiny button. Suddenly In front of him was crusader Reynolds.
"Whoa, what is this place?"
"Ahhhhhhhh!" Percy screamed and violently mashed all the buttons, dials and switches. The moon zoomed across the sky and sank, and the sun rose. As soon as the sun was visible, it slowed, slower than normal.
"Beep boop. One hour of day added, to be removed in two days. Daylights savings has been invented."THIS DAY PHASE WILL BE ONE HOUR LONGER, BUT THE DAY PHASE AFTER WILL BE ONE HOUR SHORTER TO RE-ALIGN PHASE END TIME. (Unless too many people complain, then I'll find another solution.
In the morning, everyone arose to a smell of freshly cooked meat, and made some primitive sandwiches. (Except Vecna)
Vecna has died he was: Vanilla Town
It is now DAY 2 you may post. (Including Brainbomb)

What I find interesting about this is that apparently Bo was named Boh Suh, while Vecna had no name? But I have an in-game name! And it's not related to my username (as far as I can tell).

Instead, I thought I recognised a theme. That's why I tried to hint at my game name in my first couple of posts, to see who would pick that up. At first I thought MF and Vapour did, but now I'm not so sure anymore..

Can we use this information for scumhunting?

Yea no way this guy is scum

[brainbomb]

My advice would be no. because hes a new GM and we probably shouldnt use flavour to solve a game for us.

I also have a flavour name that was given to me. And yea thats not a good idea to do. But mostly the point of the game is to catch mafia by use of things the players are doing and saying. not random stuff in EOD EON posts.

We have all that we need to catch mafia by simply using the vote count analysis. Lynching durga-worcej-yavuz-jamie looks like itll yield most of the scumteam.

[rdrivera2005]

This time I have to make a lot more effort to catch up.

I liked Claeser a lot more in this exchange with BB.

I am still not convinced on Worcej, I think Brain citation describe him pretty well and it's more or less what I am seeing here.

@Brain - To answer an earlier question of yours, I usually easily townread Vecna because I can see his burst posts and recognize the way he is thinking as a towny approach because I had the same thoughts many times. This game I can't agree with him in anything, it seems to me he was emulating his style but without the content. Of course, it has a bit of OMGUS, because I thought I was obviously town at D1, but I was wrong.

[rdrivera2005]

My advice would be no. because hes a new GM and we probably shouldnt use flavour to solve a game for us.

I also have a flavour name that was given to me. And yea thats not a good idea to do. But mostly the point of the game is to catch mafia by use of things the players are doing and saying. not random stuff in EOD EON posts.

We have all that we need to catch mafia by simply using the vote count analysis. Lynching durga-worcej-yavuz-jamie looks like itll yield most of the scumteam.

I would not mind lynching Durga. She gave just excuses and I think town Durga would have shredded Brain into small pieces after that playdip comment.

[yavuzovic]

TLDR.

Wagons today should be worcej/Jamie

I firmly am of the belief that if someone left the game, its highly likely they arent scum

Actually few games ago I replaced snowy. Vecna told us that Snowy hates playing as scum - this was right and I was scum. He must've left the game for rolling scum.

[damo666]

Interesting.

Damo calls for a Yav lynch. Neph votes for Yav, and then Damo joins.

Later Damo claims he wasn't the one who started the wagon.

What do you gotta say abou dah, Damio?

I simply referred to peterbot. Nothing stranger.

[FlaviusAetius]

When Cleasar first joined this game, and was basically just lurking, it seemed like weak excuses, but I wanted to give him a chance to defend himself

When he initially started posting again after he read everything it definitely seemed like he was a mafia, he basically wasn't talking about the game, but side things

Then these last few posts, have convinced me, Cleasar is a town in my eyes. What is more concerning is that Jamie was so dead set on killing you Cleasar...

[FlaviusAetius]

TLDR.

Wagons today should be worcej/Jamie

I firmly am of the belief that if someone left the game, its highly likely they arent scum

Actually few games ago I replaced snowy. Vecna told us that Snowy hates playing as scum - this was right and I was scum. He must've left the game for rolling scum.

Yea....
We had a big conversation about this last night, I understand now why this might be jumping to conclusions

[yavuzovic]

I chose to worcej, based off of our conversation last night
Not because darg also voted him...

ah so you love me

<3 you helped me come to the conclusion

Suspect BB, and don't use anything named brain except your own, to have a conclusion.

[brainbomb]

Interesting.

in the 1990s Pat Buchannan ran for President

He ran on a platform of building a wall

Republicans panned him for Bob Dole and said Pat was a psychopath

Later Trump became President claims hes gonna build a wall

Later Damo claims he wasn't the one who voted Trump

What do you gotta say abou dah, Damio?

[brainbomb]

When Cleasar first joined this game, and was basically just lurking, it seemed like weak excuses, but I wanted to give him a chance to defend himself

When he initially started posting again after he read everything it definitely seemed like he was a mafia, he basically wasn't talking about the game, but side things

Then these last few posts, have convinced me, Cleasar is a town in my eyes. What is more concerning is that Jamie was so dead set on killing you Cleasar...

your concerns are so bewildering. its really something to observe. I dun even know what to say. keep churning out these diamonds

[damo666]

On brief VCA durga is town

What part about the vote makes you town read her?

Why would scum durga join the wagon at the point she did