Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Carl Tuckerson]

Let's just say I've had some realllly bad n1s recently

I’m afraid I can’t let you “just say” that. More context. Why were they bad, what does your apparently deliberately quiet d1 have to do with it?

Ok so 5 games ago, I was the sheriff/town role checker and got shot by the mafia night one.

4 games ago I actually survived until the end

3 games ago I was a 3rd party killer and got discovered night 1 and lynched day 2

2 games ago I got killed n1 as mafia by a 3rd party killer

my last game I got to day 4 before getting shot as a townie

If you are what I think you are, you’ve already blown it, but for future reference, the best way to live is to participate more and trust your team. Let people like me who aren’t anything special put ourselves out there to get shot.

[ChippeRock]

Wow, 3-4 IRL games that's probably more than Chippie lol

Still better at reading people than you & him. And that's saying something.

[Carl Tuckerson]

In fact, you can make use of this suspicion to trick the mafia into thinking you can be mislynched.
Start solving like you did 4 games ago

[ND]

Lol, K Chippie you are the desperate one here and your entire defense was proven bunk then you vote for me, k. Bout what I expected.

And, Cruaader I think you are scum and I vote my read. I'm not like Chippie and vote for whoever has 'more votes' well until I infuriated him to the point of voting me anyway hahahahaha.

So desperate omg.

[CruaaderReynauld]

I’m afraid I can’t let you “just say” that. More context. Why were they bad, what does your apparently deliberately quiet d1 have to do with it?

Ok so 5 games ago, I was the sheriff/town role checker and got shot by the mafia night one.

4 games ago I actually survived until the end

3 games ago I was a 3rd party killer and got discovered night 1 and lynched day 2

2 games ago I got killed n1 as mafia by a 3rd party killer

my last game I got to day 4 before getting shot as a townie

If you are what I think you are, you’ve already blown it, but for future reference, the best way to live is to participate more and trust your team. Let people like me who aren’t anything special put ourselves out there to get shot.

That implies I'm actually special, and I don't think it's a good strategy to get everyone to believe you're scum, no matter what the role.

[CruaaderReynauld]

Lol, K Chippie you are the desperate one here and your entire defense was proven bunk then you vote for me, k. Bout what I expected.

And, Cruaader I think you are scum and I vote my read. I'm not like Chippie and vote for whoever has 'more votes' well until I infuriated him to the point of voting me anyway hahahahaha.

So desperate omg.

Then agree to my deal, lets lynch me tomorrow and see if I'm townie or not. If I am we know you're at least suspicious and at most a confirmed mafia.

[Carl Tuckerson]

Lol, K Chippie you are the desperate one here and your entire defense was proven bunk then you vote for me, k. Bout what I expected.

And, Cruaader I think you are scum and I vote my read. I'm not like Chippie and vote for whoever has 'more votes' well until I infuriated him to the point of voting me anyway hahahahaha.

So desperate omg.

Then agree to my deal, lets lynch me tomorrow and see if I'm townie or not. If I am we know you're at least suspicious and at most a confirmed mafia.

Why would we want to lynch you?

[ChippeRock]

Lol, K Chippie you are the desperate one here and your entire defense was proven bunk then you vote for me, k. Bout what I expected.

And, Cruaader I think you are scum and I vote my read. I'm not like Chippie and vote for whoever has 'more votes' well until I infuriated him to the point of voting me anyway hahahahaha.

So desperate omg.

I vote for whichever strong scum has more votes. Since I downgraded TrPrado to moderate scum, that leaves you.

[Squigs44]

solving what? defending and town reading someone is as much solving as scum reading someone is

shooting down other people's arguments without putting forth your own is not solving

You are making me irate before bed. I literally explained why his argument was bad, and then explained why I townread ND because of that.

How is that not putting forth an argument?

This was not a townread of ND nor an explanation:

Your rationale is flimsy af ND, but I don’t think it is contrived.

The only reason you gave clear reads on Fox, Crusader and ND was because I prodded you over and over again - you did not make that clear, and your original posts were not solving.

You still have, what, just 1 hedged scumread so far in this game? During the course of this conversation you doubled your townreads I think? If you really are town, please be more clear about your reads and why you read them the way you do, preferably before EoD.

[CruaaderReynauld]

Lol, K Chippie you are the desperate one here and your entire defense was proven bunk then you vote for me, k. Bout what I expected.

And, Cruaader I think you are scum and I vote my read. I'm not like Chippie and vote for whoever has 'more votes' well until I infuriated him to the point of voting me anyway hahahahaha.

So desperate omg.

Then agree to my deal, lets lynch me tomorrow and see if I'm townie or not. If I am we know you're at least suspicious and at most a confirmed mafia.

Why would we want to lynch you?

Well ND seems to be 100% convinced I am scum, so if I'm lynched and it just so happens to be that I'm actually a townie, then it'd prove that ND is either suspicious or just a straight up mafia member

[Carl Tuckerson]

Then agree to my deal, lets lynch me tomorrow and see if I'm townie or not. If I am we know you're at least suspicious and at most a confirmed mafia.

Why would we want to lynch you?

Well ND seems to be 100% convinced I am scum, so if I'm lynched and it just so happens to be that I'm actually a townie, then it'd prove that ND is either suspicious or just a straight up mafia member

Or that he's a townie and wrong.
Which, after this episode, is what I'm betting is the case (revised reads incoming btw).
Seems like a terrible deal, kill a townie to make another townie suspicious.
Why don't you just show ND you're town by digging into what people have said, providing analysis, etc.? That would be the best outcome.

[CruaaderReynauld]

To put it simply I'm calling out his bluff, as a normal townie I'm useless to the team besides my vote, but if it turns out ND is mafia then my death will turn out to be valuable to the team.

[CruaaderReynauld]

Anyways I'm going to start rereading today's discussion to see if I find anything suspicious.

[ChippeRock]

Why would we want to lynch you?

Well ND seems to be 100% convinced I am scum, so if I'm lynched and it just so happens to be that I'm actually a townie, then it'd prove that ND is either suspicious or just a straight up mafia member

Or that he's a townie and wrong.
Which, after this episode, is what I'm betting is the case (revised reads incoming btw).
Seems like a terrible deal, kill a townie to make another townie suspicious.
Why don't you just show ND you're town by digging into what people have said, providing analysis, etc.? That would be the best outcome.

Unlikely, ND's read on Cruaader is just straight up dumb. He would clearly be scum if Cruaader gets mislynched.

[Carl Tuckerson]

Halfway Thru D1 Readz Part II: Cruaader Boogaloo


COOL: Affirmatively confident they are town.

Squigs44
Balki Bartokomous
ChippeRock
Carl Tuckerson
FlaviusAetius

PASS: Not sold they are town yet but feeling okay about them.

TrPrado
Durga
et
connorcompton
ND
CruaaderReynauld

WHO?: No opinion, low enough activity that I don't think it means anything.

MoscowFleet
bozotheclown
rdrivera2005
Nephthys
EspressoPatronum
xorxes
damo666

HANG: Voting pool for today. Either did something actively suspicious or have comparatively high post count without leaving a firm impression.

teacon7*
Percy Williams*
Tom Bombadil
Foxcastle
dargorygel


*: I owe these two a reread of their posts to see if my lack of impression is a product of us not being around at the same time and me skimming their posts, or if they are legitimately high-volume low-content posters. They probably belong in WHO? but they've posted way too much for that.

[ND]

Lol, K Chippie you are the desperate one here and your entire defense was proven bunk then you vote for me, k. Bout what I expected.

And, Cruaader I think you are scum and I vote my read. I'm not like Chippie and vote for whoever has 'more votes' well until I infuriated him to the point of voting me anyway hahahahaha.

So desperate omg.

I vote for whichever strong scum has more votes. Since I downgraded TrPrado to moderate scum, that leaves you.

NAH, you have just jumped on me because I not only debunked your entire defense of him but have also basically proven him to be highly suspect if not total scum based on his own statements. Your scum reads are people who are questioning Cruaader which makes you very suspect as well.

And Cruaader, you aren't going to flip town. You know that, but sure if you somehow, magically, flip town then yeah I will offer myself D2 to be lynched although that would accomplish literally nothing because if you magically flipped town (not going to happen) and I am lynched D2 then all that is accomplished is that the town will have lost two town members.

But, that's like saying pigs fly. You aren't going to flip town you are scum. Your statements and actions have basically proven it.

[ChippeRock]

Lol, K Chippie you are the desperate one here and your entire defense was proven bunk then you vote for me, k. Bout what I expected.

And, Cruaader I think you are scum and I vote my read. I'm not like Chippie and vote for whoever has 'more votes' well until I infuriated him to the point of voting me anyway hahahahaha.

So desperate omg.

I vote for whichever strong scum has more votes. Since I downgraded TrPrado to moderate scum, that leaves you.

NAH, you have just jumped on me because I not only debunked your entire defense of him but have also basically proven him to be highly suspect if not total scum based on his own statements. Your scum reads are people who are questioning Cruaader which makes you very suspect as well.

And Cruaader, you aren't going to flip town. You know that, but sure if you somehow, magically, flip town then yeah I will offer myself D2 to be lynched although that would accomplish literally nothing because if you magically flipped town (not going to happen) and I am lynched D2 then all that is accomplished is that the town will have lost two town members.

But, that's like saying pigs fly. You aren't going to flip town you are scum. Your statements and actions have basically proven it.

Yes, I always OMGUS vote people. Just ask Jamiet when I correctly read him as scum last game. Cruaader probably will reveal VT, and if lynching him is what it takes to get everyone to realize that you need to be lynched, I would join that wagon.

[ND]

Well i am going to bed. All I have left to say is good god WOW.

[ChippeRock]

Well i am going to bed. All I have left to say is good god WOW.

Agreed. Experienced players just don't lurk and suddenly try lynching someone with faulty logic.

[ND]

Well i am going to bed. All I have left to say is good god WOW.

Agreed. Experienced players just don't lurk and suddenly try lynching someone with faulty logic.

One last thing. I posted thoughts after I caught up. I work all day. I have a job and it's end of semester grading. Sorry I can't sit around and jack off on the thread all day like you. Fuck off and stop being salty I proved your fucking defense was bunk. Grow a pair and get out of your salty shitty little tunnel.

Good night