Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Squigs44]

A new player who says "I don't want to die day one, best not to talk too much" is 100000% scum

Go read me in M3.5. I was town and more scared than a long tailed cat in a room full of rocking chairs.

[TrPrado]

Your wisdom is ass backwards.

But it's running at a 100% rate of success for every time I've deployed it.

No. My first game I was VT and terrified of getting killed. I get like if I said something dumb and got mislynched I would look stupid. So I talked less.

Which game? I'll be the judge.

[CruaaderReynauld]

It would seem the town has missed my wonderful and foolproof wisdom How to Read New Players 101.

That implies I've never played Mafia or Werewolf before.

Are you not new?

I'm new in the sense that I haven't played mafia on this website at all, which means I don't know the context of 3/4 of the things you say. I'm not new in the sense that I know how to play mafia in general (the rules, how roles work, ect.)

[Carl Tuckerson]

@CruaaderReynauld:

Cruaader, why are you worried about dying night 1?

I wish the two man clown fiesta would quit drowning out the question they should have been asking

[TrPrado]

It would seem the town has missed my wonderful and foolproof wisdom How to Read New Players 101.

That implies I've never played Mafia or Werewolf before.

Nah my wisdom is solid still super solid

[Squigs44]

Sorry got sidetracked and haven't done a beacon iso yet.

Just want to point out that Tom is finally showing a bit more effort... To defend Crusader from Prado and Fox from ND. Dude still isn't solving

townreading people is solving. It’s how most games are won

But you didn't townread them, you defended them

Do you townread them, and if so, why?

[ND]

He is a new player - he doesn't even know the proper command to vote! If he were a noobie scum, he wouldn't vote for no lynch, he would vote for anybody really. Instead, because he's new to the game, and he doesn't know how to read people, he decided to abstain from the vote. His comment is not a slip, it's more likely an offhand comment in reaction to ND's vote.

Your willingness to lynch someone who's clearly innocent makes you & TrPrado clear partners-in-scum.

1) He said he read the entire game
2) He read the entire game in the course of a few page ticks (I would argue that's impossible) since it's so huge.
3) If he read the whole game he knew the proper command to vote
4) He votes an invalid vote after you suggest it
5) He is corrected and votes correct
6) Votes a no lynch
7) Offers no thoughts on the game
8) Offers no analysis on the game
9) Offers nothing
11) Says he wants to live and best not to say anything?
12) Defended by Chippie as 'clearly innocent'


WTF?

How the fuck is someone who's playing his 1st game supposed to offer analysis?? He can't even fucking read other people. Playing your 1st ever game, especially without reading up on other Mafia games (which even I did!), nobody would have finely tuned reading abilities.

Lol, retard he just said "That implies I've never played Mafia or Werewolf before." (Cruaader)

[ChippeRock]

He is a new player - he doesn't even know the proper command to vote! If he were a noobie scum, he wouldn't vote for no lynch, he would vote for anybody really. Instead, because he's new to the game, and he doesn't know how to read people, he decided to abstain from the vote. His comment is not a slip, it's more likely an offhand comment in reaction to ND's vote.

Your willingness to lynch someone who's clearly innocent makes you & TrPrado clear partners-in-scum.

1) He said he read the entire game
2) He read the entire game in the course of a few page ticks (I would argue that's impossible) since it's so huge.
3) If he read the whole game he knew the proper command to vote
4) He votes an invalid vote after you suggest it
5) He is corrected and votes correct
6) Votes a no lynch
7) Offers no thoughts on the game
8) Offers no analysis on the game
9) Offers nothing
11) Says he wants to live and best not to say anything?
12) Defended by Chippie as 'clearly innocent'


WTF?

Also I'm not sure how being defended by someone makes me innocent or guilty, but I haven't read the previous games too much so I don't know all of your relationships

This is supposed to be a fake town slip ND & TrPrado? He's playing his 1st game for god's sake! He can't even coordinate this fake town slip with his alleged teammates!

[Durga]

Your rationale is flimsy af ND, but I don’t think it is contrived.

Dude, reads like a contradiction to me. I specifically ask him to explain that to me because I don't get it. If you get what Foxyboy is saying then explain it.

It’s well known that you and Durga butt heads. To say that using that meta argument contradicts his lack of reading the game he GM’d is a huge stretch. I could have just as easily remarked that you and Durga hadn’t Burt heads yet and I wasn’t involved in the previous game

i'm also in a group chat with foxyknoxy and probably complained about you endlessly nd so really its n/a

[ChippeRock]

That implies I've never played Mafia or Werewolf before.

Are you not new?

I'm new in the sense that I haven't played mafia on this website at all, which means I don't know the context of 3/4 of the things you say. I'm not new in the sense that I know how to play mafia in general (the rules, how roles work, ect.)

How many games have you played than on other platforms?

[Tom Bombadil]

I townread Crusader because I don’t think a new scum would outright say they were afraid of being killed n1.

I do not townread Fox. My intention of pointing out the argument ND had about Fox was to point out that his argument was garbage, but one that felt genuine and thus is contributing to my townread of ND.

[Durga]

Sorry got sidetracked and haven't done a beacon iso yet.

Just want to point out that Tom is finally showing a bit more effort... To defend Crusader from Prado and Fox from ND. Dude still isn't solving

solving what? defending and town reading someone is as much solving as scum reading someone is

[ND]

Are you not new?

I'm new in the sense that I haven't played mafia on this website at all, which means I don't know the context of 3/4 of the things you say. I'm not new in the sense that I know how to play mafia in general (the rules, how roles work, ect.)

How many games have you played than on other platforms?

haha CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY

He's scum you fucking idiot

[TrPrado]

1) He said he read the entire game
2) He read the entire game in the course of a few page ticks (I would argue that's impossible) since it's so huge.
3) If he read the whole game he knew the proper command to vote
4) He votes an invalid vote after you suggest it
5) He is corrected and votes correct
6) Votes a no lynch
7) Offers no thoughts on the game
8) Offers no analysis on the game
9) Offers nothing
11) Says he wants to live and best not to say anything?
12) Defended by Chippie as 'clearly innocent'


WTF?

Also I'm not sure how being defended by someone makes me innocent or guilty, but I haven't read the previous games too much so I don't know all of your relationships

This is supposed to be a fake town slip ND & TrPrado? He's playing his 1st game for god's sake! He can't even coordinate this fake town slip with his alleged teammates!

You see the problem is it's not a town slip at all.

[ChippeRock]

I'm new in the sense that I haven't played mafia on this website at all, which means I don't know the context of 3/4 of the things you say. I'm not new in the sense that I know how to play mafia in general (the rules, how roles work, ect.)

How many games have you played than on other platforms?

haha CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY CLEARLY

He's scum you fucking idiot

If this is his 1st game, than he's clearly town. Otherwise, I might agree with you.

[ND]

Dude, reads like a contradiction to me. I specifically ask him to explain that to me because I don't get it. If you get what Foxyboy is saying then explain it.

It’s well known that you and Durga butt heads. To say that using that meta argument contradicts his lack of reading the game he GM’d is a huge stretch. I could have just as easily remarked that you and Durga hadn’t Burt heads yet and I wasn’t involved in the previous game

i'm also in a group chat with foxyknoxy and probably complained about you endlessly nd so really its n/a

Whatever, I'll see what he says. Point may be withdrawn. I thought it was weird though.

[Squigs44]

I’m also not defending Foxcastle at all, so glad you are putting that incorrect inference out there

This isn't defending:

Your rationale is flimsy af ND, but I don’t think it is contrived.

Dude, reads like a contradiction to me. I specifically ask him to explain that to me because I don't get it. If you get what Foxyboy is saying then explain it.

It’s well known that you and Durga butt heads. To say that using that meta argument contradicts his lack of reading the game he GM’d is a huge stretch. I could have just as easily remarked that you and Durga hadn’t Burt heads yet and I wasn’t involved in the previous game

ND said Foxcastle was contradicting himself and you explained why he wasn't. If that isn't defending, can you explain to me what defending would look like?

[Durga]

i can't follow this thread there's too much going on

[CruaaderReynauld]

@CruaaderReynauld:

Cruaader, why are you worried about dying night 1?

I wish the two man clown fiesta would quit drowning out the question they should have been asking

Let's just say I've had some realllly bad n1s recently

[ChippeRock]

Also I'm not sure how being defended by someone makes me innocent or guilty, but I haven't read the previous games too much so I don't know all of your relationships

This is supposed to be a fake town slip ND & TrPrado? He's playing his 1st game for god's sake! He can't even coordinate this fake town slip with his alleged teammates!

You see the problem is it's not a town slip at all.

But it is, if he were scum, he would know there's a QT for scum where they can see who the other scum are, and he wouldn't make a slip like this (unless it is a fake town slip - but again, he's a noob, and I don't think he would pull that off w/o any communication with his alleged teammates).