Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[sweetandcool]

This:

Balki literally just challenged scum to CC him. I am saying Bona has not posted and consequently we me see some action.

If you do not believe a Bonatogether counter-claim would be plausible, why did you say these words?

Hmmm, this must be some sort of communication issue.

Since Bona has not posted, it is plausible that he may CC.

That's all I was saying.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Sweetandcool:

I suggest you iso yourself if you do not get my point.

You have scolded me for coming to conclusions too early, and you have implied that you expect Bonatogether to appear in due course and counter-claim Balki's copclaim, despite your entire narrative resting on Balki being the cop.

You cannot simultaneously stick to your story about seeing Balki's cop crumbs and claim there is any likely validity to a potential Bona counter-claim. You just can't!!!

[Jamiet99uk]

Since Bona has not posted, it is plausible that he may CC.

And if he does that, you will immediately contend that he is lying, yes?

[sweetandcool]

@Sweetandcool:

I suggest you iso yourself if you do not get my point.

You have scolded me for coming to conclusions too early, and you have implied that you expect Bonatogether to appear in due course and counter-claim Balki's copclaim, despite your entire narrative resting on Balki being the cop.

You cannot simultaneously stick to your story about seeing Balki's cop crumbs and claim there is any likely validity to a potential Bona counter-claim. You just can't!!!

Thank you, I actually think that is a good suggestion. I've been meaning to review my thoughts from the earlier phases. Maybe I have forgotten something.

I will be back later with some analysis that hopefully catches the last scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

Hmmm, this must be some sort of communication issue.

Correct!

You are suggesting the potential for multiple narratives, in a space in which only one of them would support the claims you have already made.

[sweetandcool]

Since Bona has not posted, it is plausible that he may CC.

And if he does that, you will immediately contend that he is lying, yes?

He is Town. Consequently, if that were to happen, I don't know what I would do.

[Jamiet99uk]

Hmmm, this must be some sort of communication issue.

Correct!

You are suggesting the potential for multiple narratives, in a space in which only one of them would support the claims you have already made.

..and this is a communication issue because you are communicating in a way that implies information may be forthcoming, from Bonatogether, that would make you either (a) a fool, or (b) a liar.

[Jamiet99uk]

Since Bona has not posted, it is plausible that he may CC.

And if he does that, you will immediately contend that he is lying, yes?

He is Town. Consequently, if that were to happen, I don't know what I would do.

THEN WHY DO YOU IMAGINE THERE IS A SERIOUS POSSIBILITY THAT IT WILL HAPPEN???

[sweetandcool]

And if he does that, you will immediately contend that he is lying, yes?

He is Town. Consequently, if that were to happen, I don't know what I would do.

THEN WHY DO YOU IMAGINE THERE IS A SERIOUS POSSIBILITY THAT IT WILL HAPPEN???

I don't........

But it certainly COULD happen.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Y’all are funny.

I think your best use of time is to re-read based on RDR/D&W and Vecna being on the scum team. Maybe some VCA regarding the first few days. That kind of thing. There should be enough info in the thread now to find that last scum bucket.

[Jamiet99uk]

He is Town. Consequently, if that were to happen, I don't know what I would do.

THEN WHY DO YOU IMAGINE THERE IS A SERIOUS POSSIBILITY THAT IT WILL HAPPEN???

I don't........

But it certainly COULD happen.

YOU SAID IT WAS PLAUSIBLE:

This:

Balki literally just challenged scum to CC him. I am saying Bona has not posted and consequently we me see some action.

If you do not believe a Bonatogether counter-claim would be plausible, why did you say these words?

Since Bona has not posted, it is plausible that he may CC.

That's all I was saying.

You said it was plausible that this would happen.

From the Collins English Dictionary:

Plausible
adjective:

Seeming likely to be true, or able to be believed.

[sweetandcool]

THEN WHY DO YOU IMAGINE THERE IS A SERIOUS POSSIBILITY THAT IT WILL HAPPEN???

I don't........

But it certainly COULD happen.

YOU SAID IT WAS PLAUSIBLE:

This:



If you do not believe a Bonatogether counter-claim would be plausible, why did you say these words?

Since Bona has not posted, it is plausible that he may CC.

That's all I was saying.

You said it was plausible that this would happen.

From the Collins English Dictionary:

Plausible
adjective:

Seeming likely to be true, or able to be believed.

Please focus on the latter half of the definition, which is how I used the word.

[sweetandcool]

I don't........

But it certainly COULD happen.

YOU SAID IT WAS PLAUSIBLE:

Since Bona has not posted, it is plausible that he may CC.

That's all I was saying.

You said it was plausible that this would happen.

From the Collins English Dictionary:

Plausible
adjective:

Seeming likely to be true, or able to be believed.

Please focus on the latter half of the definition, which is how I used the word.

Sorry, I'm not British. I truly think this must be a language barrier ):

[Jamiet99uk]

I don't........

But it certainly COULD happen.

YOU SAID IT WAS PLAUSIBLE:

Since Bona has not posted, it is plausible that he may CC.

That's all I was saying.

You said it was plausible that this would happen.

From the Collins English Dictionary:

Plausible
adjective:

Seeming likely to be true, or able to be believed.

Please focus on the latter half of the definition, which is how I used the word.

How would a Bona CC be "able to be believed" (focussing on the second half), if you have been telling the truth and Balki is the Cop??

[Jamiet99uk]

Let's start again:

What did you have in mind when you told me that Bonatogether might show up and invalidate your claims?

[Jamiet99uk]

Bona hasn't posted yet, so you never know.

I don't.

But you claim that you do know. And Balki has endorsed your version of events.

So this is a weird correction. No?

If you say so. We are all waiting to see if a CC occurs. I have pointed out that one player has not posted yet and consequently we do not know if he will CC.

^ reminder: Here you are telling me that Bona may still show up and invalidate your whole shtick.

[sweetandcool]

YOU SAID IT WAS PLAUSIBLE:



You said it was plausible that this would happen.

From the Collins English Dictionary:

Plausible
adjective:

Seeming likely to be true, or able to be believed.

Please focus on the latter half of the definition, which is how I used the word.

How would a Bona CC be "able to be believed" (focussing on the second half), if you have been telling the truth and Balki is the Cop??

I believe that it could be possible that Bona CC.

It is believable to me that Bona could CC. I am able to believe it could happen.

If a CC were to occur I do not know how I would react since Bona is Town.

I do not believe a CC probable.

Plausible? Yes. Probable? No. Incomprehensible? Perhaps.

I don't know if Brit's have this saying, but I believe you, Sir, are making an unholy Mountain out of a Molehill.

[sweetandcool]

I don't.

But you claim that you do know. And Balki has endorsed your version of events.

So this is a weird correction. No?

If you say so. We are all waiting to see if a CC occurs. I have pointed out that one player has not posted yet and consequently we do not know if he will CC.

^ reminder: Here you are telling me that Bona may still show up and invalidate your whole shtick.

I had in mind Balki's challenge to Mafia to CC him.

We have yet to see a CC, but one player has not posted.

This is similar to rounds where we have no report of a RB, so we eagerly await to hear from the last player that has not posted.

[Balki Bartokomous]

@Sweet, what do you think of my argument that Sparta’s Day 4 hypo claim (Town!Bunny/Town!Bozo) makes Bozo look pretty Town?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Same question for Jamiet or anyone else.