Mafia XXXV - The WebDip Class Reunion

[Foxcastle]

Maybe Xorxes shouldn't be the lynch today. If we all pile on Xorxes as the obvious scum lynch, then we've learned nothing, just like day 2. Currently, we're at 3 Scum + 6 Town. If we mislynch we'll be at 3 Scum + 4 town at the start of Day 5.

So let's start scumhunting elsewhere.

Hey Tham... why did you kidnap Bo_sox?

[Foxcastle]

@Pouncy and @Dargorygel... What do you make of the Day 3 votes? Who bussed Xorxes?

[Ezio]

Hey guys. We've got something here. My flavor name is "also" peterlund. I checked today.

##vote RDrivera.

[Foxcastle]

You think Thamrick and Rdrivera both bussed Xorxes and left town to kill ghug all on their own?

[Ezio]

Idk about thamrick, I wouldn't be surprised if he bussed but I don't know his scum meta.
I'm certain that's exactly what RD has been doing this game. I'm in the process of a reread now.

[Pouncy Silverkitten]

why do you assume anyone bussed xorxes?

I agree that xorxes is probably scum. But if scum knew that I (town) and the other person who got subbed out (maybe town) were not active, wouldn't they be more likely to pile on and force a lynch when they had numbers?

##vote xorxes

[Pouncy Silverkitten]

so ezio and rdrivera can't have the same nametag right? so one of them is lying?

[Ezio]

Pouncy rd is claiming to have my nametag. The only reason someone has for not peeking is because they're scum and afraid of being bo_sox. RD must have just claimed a role he thought was plausible to be around, but not actually in the game.

I say he's bussing xorxes because he's been voting xorxes and he has to be scum.

[Pouncy Silverkitten]

seems risky to just guess a nametag if rdrivera was mafia. Seems like the cost/benefit is pretty low. Why not just wait until other people peek so you don't make up a duplicate?

but it doesn't make sense for you to lie either. so i'm confused.

[Ezio]

Earlier when we had been discussing this we had said whoever posted late/after Bo_sox had been revealed was going to look very scummy anyways. Perhaps he thought it was best to post earlier with a recognizable but unassuming name and hope he would avoid suspicion.

[thamrick]

Hey all,

I was working all day yesterday then went to a bar to watch the NCAA tournament after. Just sleeping off the hangover now.

I was starting to doubt Durga so honestly, kinda good that she was NK'd. If we somehow wind up pulling this out as town, she's a strong MVP candidate.

Foxy, sorry for doubting you.

I've submitted a peek. I'll let you know when it reveals.

[thamrick]

@Pouncy - I'm not saying who is more believable, but Ezio easily could have lied about having the same nametag as rdr. If town mislynches today, it's game over. If he thought he could set up rdr as mislynch by claiming the same nametag afterwards, it wouldn't matter if he exposes himself as long as he could get rdr lynched first.

[thamrick]

Interesting that Bo was kidnapped today, not tomorrow

[Pouncy Silverkitten]

if xorxes is scum he is probably kidnapper so they didn't want it to go to waste. Otherwise they would hold it and use it to win probably

[Ezio]

Worth nothing: If scum get a mislynch today it is probably auto-win for them anyways.

[thamrick]

I'm TEACON7

[bozotheclown]

I already thought rdrivera was scum and Ezio was town, so I tend to believe Ezio. However, I am interested in hearing what rdrivera has to say about Ezio's nametag claim.

##VOTE rdrivera2005

[bozotheclown]

I am not convinced xorxes is scum, but if he is, he is definitely getting bussed, because everyone left in the game besides myself have scum read him at some point.

[bozotheclown]

@Pouncy: Have you checked your nametag?

[thamrick]

Bozo's probably town