A well-deserved retirement for a good friend.

I'm sure he will be back to play at some point, but for now he is devoted to Managed Democracy.

We could PM our votes to Darg and trust him to tally. I'm a little hesitant to use a polling service online rather than linking to accounts.

I am more in favor of post maximums than post minimums

I think on the whole the proposals are good. However, I'm only going to comment on the MVP proposal because I feel strongly about it. I don't think it's a good idea to formally make a system for MVP. As others have said it has the potential to breed resentment or feelings of being left out. And it ...

I will say I also do not like MVP statistics and find them very arbitrary.

I’m generally on the “empower GMs to do fun stuff” side so I think we can mess with post mins/maxes and phase lengths within reason.

Ghug/Chaqa 2024 - A High Standard

The reason I suggested the "&" thing is because that is how we have had to enter D&W's name in the game setup box since he started playing. It seems like the bot handled it a bit differently elsewhere, so I'm curious to see if we can just enter his name normally now.

I know it ended a bit rough but I though it was a very fun setup. I would like you to consider running more games this year. I am hoping to help more with setup review going forward since I have a history of mechanically diverse games.

So after a night's sleep, and a lot of chat in Discord, I'll make some comments. I acknowledge that the setup worked out as slightly town-sided; the Angel team, in particular, was slightly too weak. But on reflection, and based on a lot of feedback from others, I do not think it is fundamentally br...

I think we should have post maximums.

How does the next mafia game start, if I may ask? is it as simple as someone stepping up with an idea and saying they want to GM/run a game, or is there some kind of process? We've run the gamut from a long queue to basically forcing people to run games. If you're interested, generally we mention i...

I would like to run a mostly vanilla mini or full game

I would like to run a more vanilla game or maybe a mini

It was unclear exactly when action could be taken I thought perhaps that you would ignite on N4, so it was my thought that we should sneak in a kill power at EoD4 so we can kill off as many town as possible But you popped it early and then, well, see my earlier post You mean 3? That's why you were ...

I ruined the game for my team. I claimed a guilty when I didnt need too I also retracted into a lost position I then claimed scum openly And in none of these things did I ever manage to open a lane of opportunity for either scumteam. I ruined the game and blew it all for everyone involved. Entirely...

As the GM, I am sorry that this setup turned out to be somewhat town-sided. Of course that was not the intention. I will comment on the assumed balance of the game, and how that did not hold up in the face of real gameplay, in due course. In the meantime, I hope some of you had fun, and I am sorry ...

There is nothing more satisfying than scum crying about game imbalance. It was not exactly the most balanced setup, but I think the angels literally never doing anything helped town a lot. It was unclear exactly when action could be taken I thought perhaps that you would ignite on N4, so it was my ...

ghug wrote: ↑

Sat Apr 13, 2024 12:15 am

Chaqa wrote: ↑

Sat Apr 13, 2024 12:15 am

I was convinced ghug was scum because of how he was simping for DrFidelis.

Let it never be said that you always read me right.

I think this is the first time I’ve been wrong in a long time. And I was scum, do reading you wrong is extra funny lol

I was convinced ghug was scum because of how he was simping for DrFidelis.

Balki Bartokomous wrote: ↑

Sat Apr 13, 2024 12:12 am

There is nothing more satisfying than scum crying about game imbalance.

It was not exactly the most balanced setup, but I think the angels literally never doing anything helped town a lot.