Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑

Fri Mar 24, 2023 2:55 pm

President Eden wrote: ↑

Thu Mar 23, 2023 8:06 pm

ghug in shambles

BTW what was this actually supposed to mean? Were you drunk, PE?

ghug, teenaged ghug, and old Dutch ghug are all on the council, but none of us were suggested as co-GMs.

if i die kill koalagray

Is your case on Jamie just that he's ornery, or what? My case on Jamiet is he got surprisingly annoyed by me stubbornly doing my own thing after watching me do the very same in one game he GM-ed and another game the entirety of which he watched with the perfect info of the God Thread. Well, to answ...

And you seem to be trying hard to point out how my current best hypothesis on you is wrong. Instead of finding and furnishing a better hypothesis. Aha, the shoe is on the other foot! If you'll recall, I brain dumped my view of the game state towards the beginning of the night. I actively avoid tunn...

Let's take a step back. Just go with me for a second please: - I am a Townie (unprovable to you, but I know this) - My current best hypothesis is "ghug is Mafia" followed by "Jamiet is Mafia" - So, my goal is to make as strong a case for current best hypothesis at the moment - Failing that, the nex...

--> Please expand on why you don't feel this is a legit approach for me to ask "hey, others who played with ghuh & Jamiet a lot – is this a normal reaction of being offended by my schtick from them?" I thought the schtick was a fun idea and was fully expecting you to do it as either alignment. I ju...

You're also conflating scumreading you with being offended by your schtick. --> Like how several people have now commented on whether or not it's natural for some of y'all to be as riled up by my silly impersonation. Personally, I have no idea, I just don't have enough data on you folks yet. But ot...

I like the word "gotcha" – thanks ghug. I am a Townie Heel provoking reactions and hunting for Mafia "gotcha" give-aways or inconsistencies with their past behavior. And here is the thing – I don't need to be the one doing the analysis. I just need to get the Mafias to react. Other real Townies can...

Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑

Thu Mar 16, 2023 7:22 pm

ghug wrote: ↑

Thu Mar 16, 2023 5:55 pm

worcej wrote: ↑

Thu Mar 16, 2023 5:53 pm

Got it - checks out now lol

I believe Shit Rising is the name of Jamie's old band, so that explains that.

The name of my band is #Fuckghug

Yeah, Shit Rising broke up.

A meta comment: I think you're going to get extra pushback if you continue to use "slip" this way. It's not really the colloquial "slip up", it's reserved for overt betrayals of knowledge. Worcej is also notorious (and he's far from alone in this) for not being able to put himself in the mind of a ...

My assumption is it requires effort to constantly remind yourself, as Mafia, "I'm not supposed to know the alignments of anyone" ... and it's easy to slip into accidentally saying or doing something utilizing your secret knowledge of everyone's alignment when you are a Mafia pretending to Town. Is ...

Before last night, I saw no effort to try to solve. The argument was accurate at the time. Now you've expanded to scumreading me, which has some positives (a stated opinion, OMGUS is townie) and some negatives (only one opinion, the logic is very tenuous). Are you arguing that you've shown some eff...

worcej wrote: ↑

Thu Mar 16, 2023 5:53 pm

Hamilton Brian wrote: ↑

Thu Mar 16, 2023 3:54 am

Right, this is me hammered-posting. No blaming anyone, but there's shit rising, and I smelt it on D1.

Got it - checks out now lol

I believe Shit Rising is the name of Jamie's old band, so that explains that.

... 2) <Koala's conclusion Suspecting ghug> ... ... 2. The fact that information is imperfect doesn't mean it's not useful. You're drawing a false dichotomy. I don't know how this would be a scumslip regardless. I can't imagine the mafia has greater knowledge than they should about whether you shot...

But why would that be a scumslip ? Why would Scum Ghug be more likely to fail to consider this nuance than Town Ghug? My assumption is it requires effort to constantly remind yourself, as Mafia, "I'm not supposed to know the alignments of anyone" ... and it's easy to slip into accidentally saying o...

Things we know positively. TheFlyingBoat was town. Kak was mafia. We don’t know how or why Kak died. Some observations. Ghug referred back to Kak’s own vote; made the vote on Koala and cast a little shade on Bona. I am not sure that makes Bona look Bona-fide good. Keep an eye on, though. Ghug then ...

@Koala Did you post in Master thread by mistake? I think ghug was suggesting there is a delay or condition mechanism wtt vigshot. Well, I had that thought once night had started. At the time, the thought was just: 1. We're down to minutes, I need to switch to a new viable wagon now that my top scum...

I am happy to. How am I being opaque? I am 100% transparent about what I'm doing. I claim the PR of the Townue Heel . I will troll and rile up the Mafia, and get them to engage. More engagement == mode data for the rest of us to analyze. Just like the mystery AwesomeNinja who shot Kak (way to go!)....

Koala, stop being so opaque. I am happy to. How am I being opaque? I am 100% transparent about what I'm doing. I claim the PR of the Townue Heel . I will troll and rile up the Mafia, and get them to engage. More engagement == mode data for the rest of us to analyze. Just like the mystery AwesomeNin...

You always scumread me, lol. And this time I can't even OMGUS you as I think you are town. Right now I won't vote for Flum, Kak and HB as I believe they are town. Flum because of the weird claim, Kak because of the setup discussions and HR because of the number thing and the reaction to Flum. I wil...