Sweet and I are already mechanically guaranteed to be aligned from last night's investigation. I made a chart that I think shows Just's plan to be pretty tight. I don't want to do all the analysis on Sweets plan. https://i.postimg.cc/yNK4WGZV/20240103-220304.jpg VT Vote BK3K In the above, you can i...

sweetandcool wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 04, 2024 5:45 pm

I'm pretty sure scumteam is Will and Heart.

Except this plan is good. I wish he went, but I think Will is town. My biggest complaint is how confident he was and unwilling to discuss. He go really lucky that investigation is in our favor, otherwise he'd look way worse

It was not resolved at all. Everyone except you (although I assume you will do it anyway) agrees and has stated that the Investigate 3 plan is the best we have come up with. Even BK agrees, and his life is on the line! If B3K3Y2J and Sweet are both town, I expect Worcej and either Chaqa or Rdr are ...

Here's where I wonder if we drop the parity cop for the next night phase: if VTs calibrate the investigation off of either BK or Sweet, we will find out whether the two of them together have an opposite alignment to some third person. With only 2 scum left after we dayvote Ghug, then if BK, Sweet, ...

Now I’m going to say that BK and sweet are both probably town. It would be really unlucky if they were both mafia Here's where I wonder if we drop the parity cop for the next night phase: if VTs calibrate the investigation off of either BK or Sweet, we will find out whether the two of them together...

Now I’m going to say that BK and sweet are both probably town. It would be really unlucky if they were both mafia Here's where I wonder if we drop the parity cop for the next night phase: if VTs calibrate the investigation off of either BK or Sweet, we will find out whether the two of them together...

If they aren't aligned one of them is scum. If one them is scum then Sweet and B3K are town because they have same alignment and there is 2 scum left. Right but how do you find out whether B3K is aligned with Sweet, by not investigating B3K? Sweet and I are already mechanically guaranteed to be ali...

Eh? How does this townclear both of you? How does proving that, for instance, Worcej and Chaqa are not paired, reveal anything about your alignment, Sweet? If they aren't aligned one of them is scum. If one them is scum then Sweet and B3K are town because they have same alignment and there is 2 scu...

FWIW, it isn’t scummy to end the phase on a confirmed scum. Keep the momentum moving forward. If the conversation you find important stops, that’s your fault not mine. It's the abundance of shit takes like this one that has made this the single most difficult game of Mafia for me, which is shocking...

worcej wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 04, 2024 3:05 am

BK3K wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 04, 2024 3:04 am

I did a table of analysis in Excel, is it legal to paste an imgur link to a photo of that analysis?

I think so because it’s a link. Just make it an image.

Imgur wasn't working

https://postimg.cc/pms16qC7

I think the plan is good tho

I did a table of analysis in Excel, is it legal to paste an imgur link to a photo of that analysis?

I think the vote for BK3K is the most optimum. Let’s say we get another parity - use rdr and myself for an example. We learn that me and him are on a team while sweet and BK3K are on a team too. This doesn’t result in clear path forward, it just eliminates pairs and creates no clears. The best case...

JustAGuyNamedWill wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 04, 2024 2:35 am

BK3K wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 04, 2024 2:33 am

JustAGuyNamedWill wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 04, 2024 2:31 am

I now realize that the NK is probably going to be BK if he isn’t scum.

Oh you realize something after that fiasco?

I do.

I'm logging off for now. I cannot handle this lmao

Yes, fair modification here. Kill the recent scan to confirm alignment of 2. If they are town, we win because they are scum and we have the votes to kill them. Thanks for coming to the party worcej. Now consider any edge cases before we blow ourselves up by accident. There is discussion on prior pa...

Do we have an established consensus for VT votes? I didn’t see it yet. This needs to be established. My 2cents here is it’s 6-2 and if we scan BK3K again and create 3 clears, because him and sweet are town, it’s pretty much auto. If we scan BK3K and get a scan of someone and they are opposite, we f...

Argument resolution any% speedrun I'm (supposed to be) prepping for an all day meeting tomorrow, and I'm out of commission for much of the next 21 hours. I really would have preferred the extra time. If it really is the best, it'll hold up after 2 days of analysis, just the same as 1 day. That's wh...

Proposing* not protesting. I'm protesting your "what is measure?" attitude Don’t care. My plan is the most optimal until proven otherwise. Which it wont. So it doesn’t matter how long the night is. Wow this came off really cocky. Sorry BK. Just mad And I'm sorry for calling you a nitwit lol

I will write it now. Sweet, BK, heart, and Chaqa in that order were against my plan Just writing it down I was never against your plan, you nitwit! I still am not! I'm against rushing deciding the plan from 45 to 21 hours! See the difference? I'm protesting measure twice, cut once. Proposing* not p...

JustAGuyNamedWill wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 04, 2024 2:10 am

I will write it now.

Sweet, BK, heart, and Chaqa in that order were against my plan

Just writing it down

I was never against your plan, you nitwit! I still am not!

I'm against rushing deciding the plan from 45 to 21 hours! See the difference? I'm protesting measure twice, cut once.

My concern is that there is some edge case we haven't thought of yet or one we haven't fully thought through. Now that investigate goes first, I'm more on board. But you're rabid push to end still leaves a weird taste in my mouth Well if you can, we will discuss. For now, there is no such case disc...